« On Swearing-in Day, a Lesson in Comity | Home | Minnesota Canvassing Board Member Fires Back At The Journal »

Franken's Lawyer Ridicules "Former Senator Coleman"

How is the Franken campaign responding to the lawsuit from Norm Coleman, contesting the results of the Senate recount, which could bottle this up for months? In a briefing just now with reporters, lead Franken lawyer Marc Elias approached it with a very calm and sober demeanor -- and ridiculed Coleman to no end.

"We are on the precipice, I suppose, of the next phase here," Elias said, "which is where the Coleman campaign takes a very big rock, and pushes it up a very steep hill."

What exactly is Coleman's legal complaint disputing about the recount, you might ask? Everything we've heard before, Elias said, with a couple new twists.

The Coleman campaign's complaint shows that they intend to fight on: the allegations that absentee ballots in 25 selected precincts were counted twice to Franken's benefit; the decision of the state canvassing board to revert to election night totals in a pro-Franken precinct where they lost one of five numbered envelopes, containing 133 ballots; to work to get rejected absentee ballots counted that local officials from around Minnesota, in both blue and red counties, have re-examined and say were properly thrown out; and to contest the inclusion of those 930 absentee ballots that were counted this past weekend -- which their own campaign agreed to have counted under a careful bargain.

Elias did say, though, that there's one thing he hadn't heard before: The Coleman campaign wants to have ballots thrown out in cases where the election officials neglected to properly initial them.

But don't expect Franken to be sworn in by the Senate any time soon. Elias said the decision to seat Franken is constitutionally the prerogative of the Senate -- implying that as a trial lawyer it's beyond his area.

One very important thing to note is that Elias repeatedly referred to Coleman as "former Senator Coleman" -- a reference to Coleman's term having expired this past Saturday -- a rhetorical point we'll probably be hearing more of in the weeks and months that this thing takes.

"But you shouldn't confuse the fact that the courts should remain open to hear those claims, with the question of whether or not those claims have any merit," Elias said. "And in this case, former Senator Coleman's claims don't have any merit."


22 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

to get rejected absentee ballots counted that local officials ... and say were properly thrown out; and to contest the inclusion of those 930 absentee ballots that were counted this past weekend

Wait

Both of these things?

user-pic

The former is cherry-picking 650 or so out of more than 10K correctly rejected absentee ballots, piles 1-4.

The latter is cherry icing on the "those ballots I agreed to accept which didn't go my way so I don't want them counted" cake, from pile 5.


Coleman needs to start wearing a cherry-red clown wig and nose.

user-pic

"One very important thing to note is that Elias repeatedly referred to Coleman as "former Senator Coleman"".

It is really great to finally see a Democrat out in front of the Republicans in applying a name in any situation. For many years the Democrats allowed the Republicans to frame arguments - always to the Democrats disadvantage.

Calling Norm Coleman "Former Senator Coleman" fixes in everyones mind that Coleman is no longer a Senator.
.

user-pic

As a once great lawyer once told me, the answer to the question, "Can he sue?", is always "Yes!".

user-pic

Could have also said "you betcha!!"

user-pic

... also

user-pic

And here in MN, "Ya sure!"

user-pic

"Former Senator Coleman" - that's just never going to get old.

user-pic

Why can't the Democrats show this kind of spunk and determination when their people or issues are on the line?

But the former Senator did have his entertainment value -- loved it the day MP George Gallaway used Norm as his punching bag. What a bloody fool Norm exposed himself to be on that day.

user-pic

Harry the Spineless needs to grow one and seat Franken.

user-pic

Franken is not a Senator yet. Since there is a "contest" no official confirmation exists. And because the Democratic Senate (rightly) does not trust a Timmah appointment, they have not declared a vacancy.

There is not officially anyone to seat as of now. There will be. Relax, it'll happen.

user-pic

A suggestrion to Al Franken.

Be in Washington when the Minnesote Supreme Court issues its decision and get sworn in before Coleman can file another brief "contesting" the election.
.

user-pic

I suggest former Senator Coleman get together with former president Bush, former VP Cheney, and former defense secretary Rumsfeld to commiserate together ..and then go jump in the nearest lake, which there are plenty of in Minnesota.

user-pic

Since we Minnesotans are very concerned about the water quality of our lakes, we don't want the have clean up any of the scum that would result from these dirty dudes jumping into our lakes.

user-pic

It's January...in Minnesota, that would be "jump ON the nearest lake".

user-pic

So, Coleman's strategy is to count on the decision of an activist judge? How will that play with his regressive base? Oh, just more of their do-as-I-say-not-as-I-do philosophy. I understand now.

user-pic

How about "Landslide Al"?

user-pic

Coleman is a reptile, but let him have his day in court...

user-pic

Norm, just concede and concentrate on the FBI investigation of your illegal cash gifts. Lawyer up for that deal instead.

user-pic

Those donors are probably the ones paying his attorneys.

user-pic

How about inmate Norm Coleman?

user-pic

"former Senator Coleman" sounds nice, "indicted former Senator Coleman" sounds better, "convicted former Senator Coleman' even better and "we don't hire convicted felons around here Mr. Coleman, close the door on your way out" is just about perfect.

Leave a comment

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address