« Tonight's Debate Moderator: The Undecided Voter | Home | Candidates Both Take A Crack At Having Bill Clinton Moment »

Obama Hits McCain For Deregulation; McCain Hits Obama Over Town Halls

The debate is underway, and the first exchange is a bit of a surprise: Obama gets in an attack, and McCain, who was expected to go after Obama aggressively, doesn't.

Obama hits McCain for having supporting the deregulatory policies that have created our current mess.

"I believe this is a final verdict on the failed economic policies of the last eight years, strongly promoted by President Bush and supported by Senator McCain that essentially said that we should strip away regulation, consumer protections, let the market run wild, and prosperity would rain down on all of us," Obama said, right on message. "It hasn't worked out that way, and so now we've got to take some decisive action."

McCain, by contrast, gets in a dig on Obama for not agreeing to previous town halls, but in his first answer, avoids directly faulting Obama on a policy level.

Late Update: McCain just hit Obama squarely over Fannie and Freddie, claiming his call for action on the mortgage giants shows he was out front on the crisis. Obama responded by reminding folks that deregulation, not Fannie and Freddie, was at the root of the problem, and that McCain's record on Fannie and Freddie isn't what he says it was.


244 Comments

| Leave a comment

I will say it again, McCain needs to keep still. he is moving around too much.

I disagree with you actually, it's what he does. He's pretty good at these town hall events.

I like him better when he's moving around talking than when he's standing behind a podium.

Of course Obama functions just as well in this situation.

It may come across well there, but it doesnt on tv

he looks like the mummy

Ahhhh!!!! I can't look!!! I feel like Jonze! You all let me know what happens, 'kay?

He looks like a wind-up doll.

http://pufferfish.typepad.com/

automaton for real
can he look any older?

Grandpa For President!

He did mention Ebay when Eay just laid off 1600 people...

Thank you for the Gift, Mr McWar...

Deregulation is what people understand.

Good answer to the QUESTION , yes!!

McCain is standing up, is he getting pissed?

I like how Obama looked directly at McCain when he called out his lobbyist ties.

McCain makes me nervous. He's too jittery and lots of heavy breathing.

user-pic

He's nervous as hell, that's why he's breathing heavily and shaking.

McCain, by contrast, gets in a dig on Obama for not agreeing to previous town halls, but in his first answer, avoids directly faulting Obama on a policy level.

Wow, how completely unsurprising.

Shut your cakehole, Brokaw! Nice try at setting a trap...sucks for you that BO is smarter than that.

Obama on a roll. I am soooo nervous

NO answer, again, it depends...... chicken shit.

user-pic

Damn y'all - you left me downstairs.

Obama is in his groove - he connects with people in person and it works even here.

McLame - not so much.

best exporters, best importers??

I know, that gave me a chuckle.

Damn it, McCain! Stop moving around!

Was Obama asked to sign the "letter", come on, what a crock.

user-pic

This is what I keep hearing from people - both parties got us into this.

No, that isn't true.

Well what do you expect given how the MSM covers the topics.

Shared blame question...interesting

McCain...saying nothing beyond USA number 1.

So...McCain never saw the letter that Obama sent to Paulson in 2007?

"How can we trust either party?"

"Two party system, motherfucker. Better flip a coin!"

user-pic

Make the REpublicans eat their failure!

Senator Obama is good, i was very nervous too, but he is in command, and remains calm and cool...

Listening not watching: has McCrankypants looked at BO yet?

Need to point out Democrats have only been in control of Legislature for 1.5 years.

OBama was STRONG on lobbyists.

user-pic

O he's so so full of compassion tonight - I want to puke.

Give it up, bitch - you'll never connect like Obama does.

"I have been a consistent reformer..."

1st spit-take of the night.

He's been neither.

Take on the special intrest groups...they work for his campaign

y the hell he is not answering the question.

Obama's doing better than last time. McCain's trying to be kinder and gentler.

what about congressional oversight?

Barack is just so cool, assuring and has answers. McCain critical of Obama, hitting him somehow in every answer, sounds very negative with that approach.

If you go there you will find Alaska is the worse earmark state in the US.

I like how the mention of Lieberman didn't make the needle move at all on the audience meter. The lines should've spun together and written "Meh."

user-pic

So - what needle are you watching?

Ah, CNN and it's Ohio uncommitted female/male voters. I'm addicted to these. I can't watch debates without em these days. Obama's been killing. He seems to do especially well with women.

user-pic

Earmarks - and here he goes with the same fucking lie-


user-pic

McCain sounds like the old man at the Thanksgiving that won't shut the hell up.

Is McCain wheezing alot or it just me? He sounds old...

Is anyone tracking the CNN undecideds reaction?

Everytime McCains attacks Obama, the CNN meter flatlines.

Nice.

YEA !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Good to know...

user-pic

Woo hoo!

Keep telling us -

Nobody gives a shit about earmarks...

McWar is angry, and more angry and it does go well with the men of women...

The tone is wrong, and he is so negative, bashing Obama...

McCain won't answer the woman's question about trusting the parties, and on CNN, his approval lines just go flat everytime he attacks the Big O.

user-pic

geeze....

McCain was owned on the Fannie and Freddie issue. That was Chuck Hagel's bill and the was put to the Senate on Jan 23, 2005 and Johnny (Come Lately) McCain didn't jump on board until May 26, 2006. Add to that McCain knew full well that bill lay dead in committee since July 28, 2005.

But he was getting ready for another presidential run, wasn't he?

Dang...did Brokaw actually shut McLame down?

He keeps saying he knows how to "blank".

We aren't sending $700 billon overseas

did he answer the question what the hell wrong with him about "he knows how to fix it"

user-pic

McCain goes small ball on "overhead projectors" bloating the budget.

He's trying for a sac bunt when he needs a grand slam.

McCain thinks he's talking to a GOP townhall audience.

"Big spending liberal"

I think its clear that McCain's claim of being "good at townhalls" was based on rah rah rightwing crowds that applauded his 80s era Reagan style platitudes.

user-pic

McLame just ripped that page over on his pad - he's getting pissed - he crossed in front of the camera. And his paunch is hanging out of his suit.

user-pic

Yee Haw! He's breaking up - and he's grabbed the 3d rail!

My friends, noun, verb.

user-pic

he can't think straight

user-pic

No he can't.

Right, Brokaw, like they're gonna admit entitlement is getting the bronze.

user-pic

Wow, did McCain look fragile when writing down the priorities mentioned by Brokaw.

LOL.

If the town hall is McCain's strength 30 minutes in BO is coming across much better.

user-pic

Will Obama please tell the people that he believes in pay as you go. A family budget analogy is not enough. He has to say "I pay for all of my programs by cleaning up the old ones"

Holy shit, he cant get the three categories straight... Unreal.

Holy crap! McCain failed big time on that one!

Jinx?

McCain's "new spending" attack fell flat since Obama pre-empted it.

Yes, that was a beauty by Obama! Completely undermined McCain on that!

Wow, heart Kennedy and Feingold, what a B.S.er

user-pic

viagra!!!!!
kick-in

entitlements - here comes the third rail

reaching across the aile...oh shut up

bad ass BO...kick his old ass

YES!!!!!!!!!!!!

My heart is swelling with joy and pride for this amazing man.

McCain just faded out on that one.

Odd that they show both Obama and McCain when McCain is speaking, but only Obama when Obama talks?

And where McCain failed, Obama triumphed!

Tena: Can you see McCain on CSPAM while Obama speaks, I can't on MSNBC

user-pic

Once in awhile.

He's sitting there minding his manners when I've seen him.

He's doing pretty good.

McCain has a clear record reaching across the isle - Cranston, Glenn, Riegle etc.

user-pic

Obama has been hitting that line item thing over and over - he wants the line item veto.

I remember how badly Clinton wanted that.

heh heh heh - he's already president in his mind - that's a good thing.

user-pic

cool sanity

I want quaruple secret service protection for Obama. He's gonna win this thing.

First softball question to McCain!

Medicare is his first elimination, and Social Security.

Brokaw is penalizing them on time and rules...good!

Energy, Health Care, Education -- entitlements aren't on the list of priorities. The answer is warmly embraced by the CNN group!

Thanks for the update.

user-pic

Alright!

Is McCain trying to say the same thing Obama just said? Because Obama said it way better.

And STFU with the earmarks already.

user-pic

overhead projector....koo koo

That idiot has nothing to talk about so keeps going back to earmark regardless of questions.

National sacrafice = back to f**king earmarks?

One thing I hadn't anticipated: having Brokaw as moderator helps McCain look less old. I had no idea how B. has aged. His voice sounds as though he's about to expire. Makes McC. sound a lot better than he would otherwise.

Good point. Remember that Brokaw had essentially retired. Since Russert's death, he has made an on-air resurgence of sorts.

Too bad Cronkite is in his 90s now, I think.

user-pic

When McCain inhales, I can hear the phlegm vibrate.

Brokaw: I'd like to ask each of you to respond to my questions that would take 5 minutes to answer in 1 minute please.

user-pic

He's such a jackass - I can't figure out why he doesn't just tell them the time is up instead of getting snarky about it -

F**king earmarks = 18 billion = peanuts

Sounds like they need to raise taxes to keep from freezing programs

user-pic

rifle shots

No answer answer.

user-pic

He's trying to be Obama tonight.

puke

We're not "rifle shots" says Mr. "I have to suspend my campaign."

New thread y'all

yeehaw!

McCain is trying to be Obama - Health Care and Energy at the same time. Pathetic.

Spending freeze = no grants to my school = no scholarship for me....

It's all about the framing.

Dont take the hackers scholarship money...

What's wrong with McCain's eyebrows..mascara running? or eyelash problem?

Where is McCain going?

hell?

user-pic

McCain pee'ed hisself....

he's lost

Cindy! CINDY!

Obama was sharp on sarifice.

McCain still talking about earmarks. Never answered.

Jeez, just took a look. McCain looks embalmed.

I'm with Josh. This shit is boring.

user-pic

Yep it is and

now Brokaw is shooting his own mouth off.


user-pic

he's covering up his lap

ooooh!! only $18 billion in tax cuts is not a whole lot

user-pic

mccain letting him talk....let the spot dry

Welcome to the Town Hall meeting...they are bboooorrrrriiiiinnggggggg!

"Jello to the wall???"

He's losing it.

Brokaw is doing nicely. Obama is going pretty strong on the service issue.

OMG, stop my friends. It is driving me nuts. And again, not answering question, attacking Obama.

Liarrrrr liarrrr!

With a $700 billion bailout...where we gonna pay for it, especially when there's been 750,000 jobs lost just this year.

Its line are getting worse,,,Negative, negative, negative....and more negative....

Obama's secret? Is McCain trying to get sneaky or was that just a coincidence?

Okay meter readers, how is this stupid answer going?

Jello to the wall??

Could explain why he seems to be so angry.

Brokaw is nailing them on their own rules.

user-pic

That's fine, but he takes his own license with the rules and he has been snarky about the whole thing.

O, McLame is doing the creepy laugh - o brrrrrrr -

user-pic

Hit him - he's running on the fucking tax lie all over New Mexico.

Go Bama!

Oooh, McSame referencing Hoover was quite bone-headed given the current economic status! Wow, that was bad.

On taxes, McSame is incredibly disingenuous. What a lying, cheap shot. Great response by Obama though!

Grr...I meant coincidental word choice. The "Secret thing," I mean.

user-pic

this is so painful to watch...

McCain and McCain lie lie lie...

McCain = W

Meters???

There you go Joe (OOPS John) looking at the past again .......

user-pic

because you tell them to go fuck themselves

Obama is winning:)

user-pic

He's going to answer - he's not answering.

He doesn't want to say he's going to cut it.

Look at the Dem and the GOP watch parties. The GOP watch party is ALL WHITE PEOPLE. The dem watch party looks like a "we are the world" music video. Every race and nationality you can think of.

How the meter is moving? Can you fill us in who are seeing it on cspan?

McWar= commissions, commissions, commissions, commissions...

My friends, I'm wearing a full body brace composed entirely of lies. It is the only thing keeping me up.

I am dying to know how the meters are reading

Me too!!! Please fill us in, anyone??

McCain remains flat most the time or even some negative. Obama has some good peaks.

Thanks you... that makes me feel better.

Obama is cleaning house. This isn't close.

When McCain starts whispering he starts getting those negatives.

GAH!!!!

Next time I hear "My Friends," I'm going to hurl something.

Me too, OMG

There there my friends, this meeting is important my friends. It is important that I tell you my friends that America is the Best!

The word crotchety comes to mind

When he starts whispering, he sounds so menacing...

user-pic

O boy, McLame is pathetic.


and Obama will cream him on these environmental lies.

user-pic

or sumptin likgat

Every tome Lieberman is mentioned, the lines go down...

You can not even understand his garbage...

user-pic

Overall, how's it going?

This is so boring, that means no game changer.

McCain is making a big mistake by walking around so much. He is simply showing how old he is.

user-pic

McLame is just fucking himself - he's veering away from questions like Princess Sparkle Starburst -

and he's scaring the audience.

hahah...Nuclear power plants on ships!!!

Power Plants!!!

MercerReader, are you still watching the meters?

Is it me, or is McCain answering questions by parroting what Obama just said and adding a steaming pile of negative b.s. and lies?

He is.

You are right my friend!

My friends I age 3 yrs per second on television.

user-pic

He just used McLame's own words and own time in the Senate against him - steam has to be coming out of McLame's ears.

user-pic

McCain keeps telling us hes our "friend"...Who is he talking to???? oh, yea - McCain!!!

Get off that term..."my Friend" he has no Friends

user-pic

Did the Oil Companies pick Sarah Palin?

Crap, just scared the Dupod by stamping feet and throwing things after the last "My Friends."

Time to find & apologize to a 3-legged German Shepherd.

By the way my friends............

user-pic

My friends -

lord.

You're creepy, McLame!

this is troll shit - this is straight up troll jizz.

tell us how u really feel my friend

thats not jizz you can believe in

truly,

Maverick McFriends

user-pic

he's a ghoul

"that one"........ just say boy

TM you're killing me! I'm laughing too hard to be pissed off anymore.

Thank you my friend.

Mc War refers to Senator Obama as "that one"

He is burying himself...

user-pic

He's creepier than shit trying to be a sympathetic character.

He's like something straight out of Dickens.

fuck you Tom!

Great, glad she asked about health care !!!

Anyone ever see Being John Malkovich?

Maverick maverick? Maverick maverick maverick maverick maverick!

My friends, maverick maverick my friends, maverick. Maverick maverick my friends my friends my friends my friends maverick.

user-pic

if you want the "meter" reader...go to cnn.com and click it only for the meter! EHH :)

You all talk about Obama and his looks. First and foremost McCain with those short arms, he looks like a t-rex!!! Second, you all put your trust in that old idiot if you want, he is old and has no future. He has one foot in the grave, if you all would stop looking at the color of Obama skin and his good looks........then you would shut up and listen to what he is saying. Hell Bush does not even care for McCain and Palin with her limited knowledge and background would not be ready to run anything other than alaska, because sha can't even get past her joking, and keeps coming with the same damn facts.

oh shit - a damn trex? :lol:
-----


$5000 refundable tax credit my friends! Who's going to show me how to use this computer doohickey? Email me at maverick@ussenate.gov Cindy will read it to me.

How are the meters moving? Anyone?

Don' think this town hall thing works for McCain. He walks around looking old, and Obama looks like gold......

Lines - McCain talking about healthcare = crater

McWar is losing big...:)

user-pic

head transplant

No laugh as he hoped, fell flat.

For anyone wondering about the meters. For the most part, McCain doesn't move them much, Obama has a lot of high peaks.

Like now. Obama talks healthcare, they shoot back up.

McCain is losing....big!

Here's the deal. McCain is the wrong side of issues that matter. Obama is on the right side. It's that simple.

whatever pundit dipshit came up with the "McCain has the townhall sewn up" should lose his job

CNN just added M/F and income breakouts. Obama high on both. Through the roof with females.

Thanks !!!

Great to know! Thanks...

Obama is kicking ass...

Hee! Brokaw talks and they go way down. These lines are kind of fun.

I am soooooooooooooooooooooooooooooooo friggin glad that America is not taking the stupid angle they did the past 2 elections.
No one is buying this cadaver's lies my friends.

Lebanon? Like most people know WTF he is talking about ?!

As soon as Irak is mentioned, Mc War loses...

POW my friends. - countdown to POW my friends
brace for impact my friends

"Senator Obama doesn't understand..."
"True there's something that I don't understand..."

Jyu-jyutu (sp?) that is!

"We don't have time for on the job training, my friend."

So, having an unqualified vice president "learn at the foot of a master" in order to receive an Internation Relations degree that's at least 30 years out of date might be a bad idea?

user-pic

repubs want that surplus for corporate profits, not paying US back

McWar is so toast...so toast, I am so happy...

Senator Obama is flawless...

My friends? Anybody? Ayers?

You don't understand. Only McCain understands foreign policy. Screw the facts and the people meters.

Loser to mention Iraq.......BIG mistake, meters anyone???

America is the greatest my friends. Dont be cowards like Obama my friends.

POWPOWPOWPOW

Tanking until the victory with honor thing. Then repubs go up a lot, independents a little, Dems not at all.

Then all back down.

Obama represent the poor, the workers, the societism/communism, the idealism, and he can't keep clear of terrorism.
Mccain represent the rich, the bourgeois, the capitalism, the realism, and he can't keep clear of bushism.
Who can represent the world? Obama, of course.
Who can represent the USA? Mccain, of course.
Who should we choose as the president of USA?
See what happened and happens in the societism countries in the world.
We should choose Mccain, of course!

Meters? Please, anyone?

Obama represent the poor, the workers, the societism/communism, the idealism, and he can't keep clear of terrorism.
Mccain represent the rich, the bourgeois, the capitalism, the realism, and he can't keep clear of bushism.
Who can represent the world? Obama, of course.
Who can represent the USA? Mccain, of course.
Who should we choose as the president of USA?
See what happened and happens in the societism countries in the world.
We should choose Mccain, of course!

OMG with the hero shit.

Right now? Red line sort of up, all other lines down.

Never thought I'd see the day when a Republican got pwned on national security by a Democrat.

McCain sounds weird. He's got this "I can't believe you're so stupid I have to explain this shit to you" tone.

user-pic

Yes, the tone he wants to project is that

he is the "teacher"
and
Obama is the "student"

We need a cool hand at the tiller McCain said. And no one's hands are cooler than my corpse like appendages at the end of my short T-rex arms. Oh my god! I can't feel my hands!

user-pic

watch what you say...

I have MS, and I really can't feel my hands while typing! Honest! Sad!

Oh the humanity! and the hands.

I'll get Osama bin laden my friends. I'll get em. I will get em and I will put him in a headlock my friends.

I will redirect the surge towards the border of Iraq and Pakistan to capture Bin Laden my friends. Then on to Czechloslovakia! Then to Latin America to hit that pesky Spain.

This is not even close -- a clear win for Obama, clearer than Round 1, I think!

Leave a comment

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address