« New Republican National Committee Ad Hits Obama In Traditionally Red States | Home | McCain Cancels CNN Interview As Punishment For Criticizing Palin »

Palin Church Speech Shows Intertwining Of Politics And Religion

Sarah Palin clearly doesn't have a problem mixing politics and religion.

The Huffington Post has unearthed a video of Palin speaking to her former church, the Wasilla Assembly of God, a few months ago. Palin shows the degree to which her politics has been shaped by religion -- and also how it's worked the other way around, too:

Asking congregants to pray for the successful organization of a proposed natural gas pipeline.

Saying of her work as governor: "But really, all of that stuff doesn't do any good if the people of Alaska's heart isn't right with God."

And on Iraq: "Pray for our military men and women who are striving to do what is right. Also, for this country, that our leaders, our national leaders, are sending them out on a task that is from God. That's what we have to make sure that we're praying for, that there is a plan and that that plan is God's plan."

In this light, it suddenly seems a lot more believable that as mayor Palin tried to get a librarian fired for not removing books with foul language.

I'm reminded of a religious saying of my own ancestors: Oy vey!

Late Update: It should be noted that a statement from the church says Palin ceased to be a member there in 2002, though she does maintain a friendship with them.


174 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

O she's a lovely person with a lovely family - just like the Cleavers. I bet she wears her pearls when she vacuums and her kids fight over who gets to do the dishes.

If I had to hear that voice for four years, I couldn't be responsible for what I might do to harm myself.

Old enough to remember the phrase "fingernails on a blackboard"?

Check out this photo from today's Washington Post:

http://media3.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/photo/2008/09/01/PH2008090103255.jpg

To me, they look frighteningly like the women and children in the polygamist compound in Texas or from the HBO show "Big Love" -- not the clothes, obviously, but the hair and the facial expressions.

Check out this photo from today's Washington Post:

http://media3.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/photo/2008/09/01/PH2008090103255.jpg

To me, they look frighteningly like the women and children in the polygamist compound in Texas or from the HBO show "Big Love" -- not the clothes, obviously, but the hair and the facial expressions.

Check out this photo from today's Washington Post:

http://media3.washingtonpost.com/wp-dyn/content/photo/2008/09/01/PH2008090103255.jpg

To me, they look frighteningly like the women and children in the polygamist compound in Texas or from the HBO show "Big Love" -- not the clothes, obviously, but the hair and the facial expressions.

Oh yeah she was vetted all right.
*rofl*

user-pic

...paging Mr. Fournier, Mr. Ron Fournier to the white courtesy phone.

user-pic

This is only going to further cement her support from the conservative Republicans, and, I would think, turn off more independents.

This VP candidate is even more extreme than Bush or McCain.

But any criticism of her, I've been told, is "sexism".

user-pic

I don't know. Seems to me that she'll tailor whatever she's going to say to the audience, meaning she tells them what they want to hear. Here she's telling a Christian congregation what she thinks they want a governor to say.

That's how she got to be VP candidate--she told McCains vetters exactly what they wanted to hear. And they didn't bother checking to see if what she said had anything to do with her real values. She seems kind of opportunistic to say the least.

Doesn't this assume she was, in fact, vetted?

John McCain's VP pick, a poor bet instead of a good vet.

user-pic

Nope. If she had, they would have done more than talk to her. They would have dug.

user-pic

Bullshit, you are the biggest bunch of two faced hypocrits alive. Obama quotes scripture and it's fine, Al Gore gives speecehes from the pulpit and it's fine. Call Obama "presuptuous" and y'all say it's code for uppity ni**er. Then someone questions whether she can handle being VP and a mother at the same time, and gets called out for the stupidity of that question and Palin's pulling the gender card. It's amazing how fast femminist become misogynists around here. I can only imagine the shit y'all would be saying if she were black too.

hehe, someone's have a hissy fit.

user-pic

...it's just insane...sure there were a number of knuckle heads posting BS...now the ones I had thought possessed an ounce of sense are gone...Rev. Wright and Black Separatism is not open for discussion...it has nothing to do with the election...let see where Gov. Palin goes to church and ask if she "really" talks to God.

It's the same upside down experience argument but now y'all moved onto religion.

user-pic

What the heck are you talking about, anyway? My comment?

All I said was that this was going to endear her to conservatives, and probably turn off independents.

The remark about "sexism"? Don't blame me, SFC. You can thank the rather surreal Michelle Bachmann for that, as well as Carly Fiorina. Any criticism of Palin's experience amounts to sexism according to these Republicans.

user-pic

Tell you what, give me a quote with a source that obama said that the iraq invasion was God's plan and that we are following God's will invading a country and killing hundreds of thousands of women and children. Got one? Of course not.

How about any evidence or proof that obama belonged to any black separatist organization, with support, not bull shit. How about a video of him addressing a black separatist organization and praising it less than 6 months ago. Got one of those? Of course not.

Obama's campaign hasn't been trumpeting experience as the be all, end all. Mcbush has. Mcbush said it was critical to have a life time of experience and be ready from day one. Then his first executive decision is to pick Palin????? You don't see the problem with that one? Come on, you are smarter than that.

No quotes at that link are attributed to Obama.

user-pic

Oh give me a break. You are hilarious and getting desperate. Quotes my friend. Any quotes? Any evidence? What a joke.

By the way, where's the red menace talking point? Why aren't you using that one. Cindy mcbush used it. I would think that you would be all over that one.

Because ALL of us colored folks must think that.

Ha!

You know there are no O quotes in that. Come on, now.

Valium, Wallace...Valium. Talk to your doctor. And beware of potential side effects, such as coming to your senses.

user-pic

Yep... for SFCWallace, panic is setting in....

"But really, all of that stuff doesn't do any good if the people of Alaska's heart isn't right with God."

Huh? Can anyone translate this into a clearly-written, grammatically correct sentence?

user-pic

Sure. As long as you toe the republican line and help big oil and the fat cats increase their wealth, you are "right with God." It doesn't matter how you accomplish that goal, just as long as you help reach it. Lie, cheat, steal, do what ever is necessary and you will be "right with God." Hope that helps.

user-pic

Translation: 'All my work doesn't matter if you are not Christian, because you're going to hell.'


(by the way,it took all I had not to add the word "bitches!" at the end of the quote.)

It's foreign policy via The Blues Brothers
"We're on a mission from God"

Don't you just love it that that kind of carrying on is what they call "worship"?

Pray for our military men and women who are striving to do what is right. Also, for this country, that our leaders, our national leaders, are sending them out on a task that is from God.

Scary. Truly frightening.

http://thepajamapundit.com/

I just love how Republicans want to turn the "war on terror" into a religious war:

http://www.thepersonalispolitical.com/2008/07/does-mccain-advocate-jihad-against.html

We could just change up our foreign policy and work on eradicating poverty and illiteracy in "developing" countries, which would do a hell of a lot more to reduce acts of terrorism. But hell, let's just turn this into a global war between the two largest religions, that has always worked out just super in the past!

user-pic

I don't like militant atheists any more than I like militant xians, but there's one thing I really have come over many years to believe whole heartedly. We human beings need to leave religion alone - we don't do it well. All that it becomes is a tool of power and it's a very powerful tool indeed - the one that really manipulates people.

I'd love to see humans acknowledge that we just aren't grown up enough to handle religion - but if we acknowledged that, it would probably mean that we had grown up enough.

Now that there's FUNNY, I don't care who ya are!

If humanity were old enough for religeon, they would call it something else.

I do agree that people can't handle religion, but they also can't handle reality, which is why they turn to religion. I say base our morality and actions on human empathy and compassion. Base it in reality.

But militant atheists? I don't recall ever hearing of a religious war started by atheists, or of atheists killing others in the name of not-god, or claiming divine right because they were supposedly ordained by not-god.

user-pic

Well, I meant militant in terms of proselytizing. I've been preached at vehemently more often by atheists than by Xians - no lie.

Ahhh, yeah. I hate when people preach to me, so I don't do it to them, unless they do it to me or others, then they just have it coming. Religion should be a personal thing, affecting your own life, and nobody else's. It is harmless like that. When people force their religion onto others, either in the form of proselytizing or by crafting it into public policy, that is when lines are crossed, and that is when I push back.

Its like international relations--the world hates us being we won't keep our opinions and priorities to ourselves, we try to push our will on the rest of the world. We are the fanatical evangelicals of the world. The Canadians, on the other hand, are just like the chill religion who are accepting and just believe what they believe and don't try to convert anyone, and no one hates them.

"Can't we all just get along??"

Powerful stuff, Rodney, but no one's listening.

user-pic

Well, I meant militant in terms of proselytizing. I've been preached at vehemently more often by atheists than by Xians - no lie.

Ahhh a paradox worthy of Descartes! All I know is me and my 15,000 best friends had a ball at the (too short) Obama rally in Milwaukee. Yes my karma cup runnith over.

As an aside, I am beginning to believe my crackpot theory that McCain is secretly working for Obama may have some merit...

user-pic

I swear - it makes the only sense out there - that he's throwing it for Obama -

otherwise - wow - this really is the asylum.

I had briefly entertained the idea that McCain knew he was going to lose this time around and just picked Palin in order to leave her well positioned to run in four years, but even that seems hard to credit anymore. It really is hard to explain why McCain does much of what he does of late.

Yeah, your comment makes me think of my ex-father-in-law, who is now deceased. He was always a hoot, doing things that would get a laugh. But as he got on in years, his behavior got odder and harder to make sense of. He'd empty the dishwasher as soon as you put dishes in it (although they hadn't been washed). He'd pick safety pins up that were laying around and pin them on his shirt. He'd wander around aimlessly. I remember one Memorial Day when we were going to cook out and he went outside to clean the grill with paper towels and windex.

I'm sure you know what I'm describing here. Dementia.

The brain is a marvelous organ. My late father was a medical research specialist who could consume HUGE amounts of alcohol and not show any outward effects--people didn't have a clue that he was intoxicated, even when his BAC was .27% (we knew, because we ran the analyses). He could speak publicly, drive coherently, in general, function.

The next morning, he wouldn't remember a God damn thing he'd done. (We'd show him video tapes, and he STILL couldn't remember,) Unfortunately, he died before we could complete the research. He was truly interested in this anomalous behavior.

My point is, McCain can also appear to be perfectly lucid, but could very well have a cerebral anomaly that causes him to have major mental missteps. He won't release his medical records, so we'll probably never know if he's psychologically capable of handling the job of CIC, and that scares the HELL out of me.

#include crackpot.h
I tell ya McGasbag is scuttling his own campaign! He used up all his Courage and Valor(tm) in Viet Nam and is now so cowardly he can't admit defeat and let down all his supporters. Instead he's realized that Obama is right and he (McGoofball) is the wrong man to lead the country and mounted a guerilla anti-campaign against himself. This self-immolation will drive enough undecideds to Obama's column in November that it will more than compensate for the race-based anti-Obama vote.

"Clearly this guy has way too much time on his hands. What does he do for a living again?"
-ed

Asking congregants to pray for the successful organization of a proposed natural gas pipeline.

Channeling Josh from West Wing: Lady, the God you pray to just got a tax break for his oil company.

http://pufferfish.typepad.com/

Assembly of God is the church that brought us Jimmy Swaggert and Jim Bakker.

user-pic

And 4 Texas mothers who murdered their own children because they believed Jesus wanted them to.

The Assembly of God scares me to death.

How could she sit in the pews for all those years while that psycho - hey, wait a minute.

user-pic

I hope everyone prays for the new gas line tonight. I'll certainly keep the participating corporations and lobbyists in my thoughts and prayers throughout the day.

"A thirty billion dollar project that's gonna create a lotta jobs for Alaskans and will have a lot of energy flowin through here. And pray about that also. I, I think Gods will has to be done in unifying people and companies to get that gas line built. So pray for that."

user-pic

I hope everyone prays for the new gas line tonight. I'll certainly keep the participating corporations and lobbyists in my thoughts and prayers throughout the day.

"A thirty billion dollar project that's gonna create a lotta jobs for Alaskans and will have a lot of energy flowin through here. And pray about that also. I, I think Gods will has to be done in unifying people and companies to get that gas line built. So pray for that."

user-pic

apologies for the double post

"Put your hand on your Tee Vee. Gawd will put that new car right IN your driveway..."

...the church says Palin ceased to be a member there in 2002....

So is she a member of a church now? Which church?

BUWAWQ!

Should it come to light that she does not go to church, well, throw another rotten tomato into the air for grandpa to juggle.

So it's God's fault that we went into Iraq?

user-pic

I actually recall seeing something somewhere that she belonged to a more fundy church than Assembly of God. I know its hard to believe, but I recall reading it.

She is supposed to belong to a Pentacostal denomination, just John Ashcroft. Her family is reported to have converted to that denomination, from Roman Catholics, when Sarah was twelve years old.

D'ya spose they have snake handlin' and pizen drinkin' up yonder in Alasky?

user-pic

Does this mean we get to start talking about Rev. Wright and Obama's adhearence to the Black Separatism doctrine?

user-pic

Like you guys haven't been making the allegation and planned on doing more ads. Problem is that these are her words and her actions. You are just making crap up. Big difference.

user-pic

So Republicans made up that Obama was a member of Wright's church for 20 years?...and that Wright was Obama's mentor? ...and that Obama could no more disown Wright as he could disown the entire African American community?...that part?

user-pic

It is like trying to argue with jello. Obama's church is not a black separatist church. So what about the reverend wright, he is old news. Again, anything directly attributable to obama, of course not. It's them darn facts that you selectively ignore.

"I'm an Alaskan, not an American. I've got no use for America or her damned institutions."

I guess someone needs to ask Mr. Scott Palin about that quote by the founder of the AIP. Kind of takes the sting out of Wright, doesn't it?

liberation theology is not separatist.

maybe you're thinking of the palin's affiliation with the alaskan separtists...

Wally, the squiggly red line below a word means there's something wrong with it, and you should correct it in order to appear that you have a nominal command of the English language. If you don't see squiggly red lines, you're either colorblind or need to subscribe to Firefox.

user-pic

I hope everyone prays for Sarah's new gas line tonight. I'll certainly keep the participating corporations and lobbyists in my thoughts and prayers throughout the day.

"A thirty billion dollar project that's gonna create a lotta jobs for Alaskans and will have a lot of energy flowin' through here. And pray about that also. I, I think Gods will has to be done in unifying people and companies to get that gas line built. So pray for that."

Folks:

Aren't the Far Right Fundies, such as Sarah Palin, always telling us that life is sacred, and that each child is created by God.

That being the case; then why are they now saying: Sarah Palin's pregnant daughter just made a mistake!

Think about that a moment. Those that are always claiming that the words and actions of God are supreme, are now telling us that when Bristol Palin became pregnant, she just made a mistake.

Which is it; God created this baby, or was it just the mistake of a teenager.

Do you see the doublespeak that those sanctimonious lunatics try to pass off as divinely inspired wisdom!

user-pic

Personally, I like the hypocrisy of all life being sacred, but once the child is born they can screw themselves. No governmental assistance, no level playing field economically, etc., etc. Everyone for themselves once the child is born. As far as they are concerned they could starve to death, but just make sure that that child is born.

Also, throw in the death penalty, which makes no sense as well. All life is supposedly sacred, right? Yeah, right.

It is really, really disgusting.

user-pic

"No governmental assistance, no level playing field economically, etc., etc." Ever heard of WIC, Food Stamps, Welfare, Medicaid...?

user-pic

You are kidding right? I take it you don't have any children.

And what percentage of right-wingers would gladly throw all of that out? How many of those who scream about the sanctity of life complain when taxes are raised to pay for those services?

user-pic

You mean all those entitlement programs that the Republicans have attempted to dismantle/destroy?

Wally, you're doing what McCain's doing: digging a rhetorical hole deeper and deeper. Nobody's going to throw either one of you a rope.

Game Over

I'm pro choice, and opposed to the death penalty, but there's no hypocrisy for somebody who is pro life and pro death penalty.

They believe that the fetus is a human child and that it is as innocent as it is possible for any creature to be. It deserves to be protected. On the other hand, they believe that a murder is not innocent and so not deserving of society's protections.

In terms of assistance programs, I think they would tell you that they believe that government bureaucracy is inherently inefficient and that it is better to help these people through other charitable giving. Particularly when you're talking about some branches of Christians, they tend to give a lot.

I don't agree with most of the positions they take most of the time, but I don't think it helps to characterize their positions. Doing that only solidifies partisan boundaries. It strengthens feelings on the left but makes it impossible to discuss things in good faith with people in the middle or to the right.

I'm pro choice, and opposed to the death penalty, but there's no hypocrisy for somebody who is pro life and pro death penalty.

They believe that the fetus is a human child and that it is as innocent as it is possible for any creature to be. It deserves to be protected. On the other hand, they believe that a murder is not innocent and so not deserving of society's protections.

In terms of assistance programs, I think they would tell you that they believe that government bureaucracy is inherently inefficient and that it is better to help these people through other charitable giving. Particularly when you're talking about some branches of Christians, they tend to give a lot.

I don't agree with most of the positions they take most of the time, but I don't think it helps to characterize their positions. Doing that only solidifies partisan boundaries. It strengthens feelings on the left but makes it impossible to discuss things in good faith with people in the middle or to the right.

user-pic

liam - I've told you - fundamentalists don't do paradox or irony.

They don't compute. I"m not kidding - they couldn't believe every word in the Bible, otherwise.

user-pic

I agree they don't compute. What really sticks in my craw is that they don't follow the bible literally or even conceptually. For instance the example of the 4 texas women that you pointed out. How could that happen? It's directly contrary to everything in the bible. Or how about the concept of screwing the poor, or stealing or a host of other things. It annoys me to no end, but I can safely say that they do not follow the bible, virtually at all.

user-pic

How the hell did that happen?

Sorry for all the weirdly placed posts.

*sigh*

You know, Josh, I'd throw a nickel in to buy a server for you -

But they DON'T follow the whole Bible literally. Just the parts they like -- which are mostly about smiting the people they don't like.

user-pic

"Do you see the doublespeak that those sanctimonious lunatics try to pass off as divinely inspired wisdom!"
Hello, kettle this is the pot...it's getting dark in here, you sanctimonious fuck.

user-pic

Ok, so doesn't that mean the IRS should be investigating this church? Should they now not be paying taxes?

user-pic

She isn't saying that the war in Iraq is a mission from God. She is saying that we need to pray to make sure that our leader's are right with God in their decision making. She also doesn't say that what our men and women in uniform is doing is right, she is saying that they are striving to do what is right.

There is nothing wrong with a Christian leader praying before they make a decision. There is everything wrong with a Christian leader praying about a decision after they make it.

PS - Palin stinks as a VP choice. McCain might as well have chosen Lynn Spears. But I think that the characterizations of her statement are wrong.

Really a strained reading Jorge...."But really, all of that stuff doesn't do any good if the people of Alaska's heart isn't right with God."

What the hell does that mean. What happens if their hearts aren't right with God?

user-pic

Yeah, I find I agree with you. I'm an atheist, and I think Palin was a horrible choice for lots of reasons. But this doesn't sound any different from what a million other politicians say - including Bush.

They don't endorse candidates but praise Bush and tell the congregation that if they vote for John Kerry they will go to Hell.


Oh please...

Women and Republican party frankly are a Oxymoron. In fact, other than the Rich White Old Fat Bastards, the rest and the G.O.P are paradoxical.

Women and minorities should be certified dumbfucks to be allowed admission into the G.O.P.

I guess, we can throw our concerns out of the window, Jesus has saved all of us already.

user-pic

Women, minorities and gays and lesbians who are GOP are deeply disturbed people IMO.

As are Unitarian GOP - I actually met a woman who told me she was a Unitarian Repug - I said no you aren't. You are either/or.

LOL!

And the train wreck continues.......

First reporter to ask McCain if he believes we're in Iraq doing God's work gets a cookie.

user-pic

I'll double that offer. I only wish. Now that would be an awesome question. Can you see mcbush now? Too funny. Maybe he could get his staff to get back with them on that one.

I don't think it matters that she's not a member of the church anymore, it was she directly making these statements. She could have made them anywhere, doesn't matter.

Andrew Sullivan, if you're reading this, apparently you were looking in the wrong place for her thoughts and views on foreign policy.

A very special week-long appearance on Oprah, yes. The Oval Office, please, no.

I wonder if she will throw herself under the bus.

Gosh, I am no more eager to see her in office than any of the rest of you folks here, but I am hard pressed to see what is so awful about any of those statements. Admittedly, I do not spend a lot of time praying for gas pipelines, but other than the frivolousness of such a prayer, I am hard pressed to see what might be so objectionable as to merit that oy vey. There are a million good reasons not to want to see this woman in line to the presidency but these quotes are not on that list.

user-pic

I have a huge problem with this puppy:

"Pray for our military men and women who are striving to do what is right. Also, for this country, that our leaders, our national leaders, are sending them out on a task that is from God. That's what we have to make sure that we're praying for, that there is a plan and that that plan is God's plan."

I have a problem with the quotes attributed to Bush claiming that he invaded Iraq in response to God's promptings. This, however, looks less overtly nutty to me. To pray that our servicemen are doing good instead of bad and that our leaders are keeping them there for good reasons instead of bad one (which is what I take her prayer to mean) strikes me as an eminently sensible prayer to pray. Mind you, I do not think that the reasons that we are there are good reasons, but I find it hard to object to someone praying for it to be so, for whatever little my $0.02 are worth...

user-pic

I agree a general statement to pray for the troops and that sort of thing makes sense and isn't problematic.

However, I interpret what she said like what the king has said, that you pointed out, that we are doing God's work by invading a country and killing hundreds of thousands of women and children and that this is what God wants us to do and that this is a religious war and the like. That's how I interpret what she said. I don't interpret it in an innocuous way at all.

Methinks the "Oy Vey" hints at the troublesome nature of her all too willing blending of her policies and her religious beliefs. None of us have a problem with a religious person in office (most prefer it, of course), but she shows some tendencies toward Fundamentalist Christian theology that make many very nervous.

Bush hasn't done a heck of alot for their cause either, I might add. It would be nice if our God Given Mission worked out for once.

And think of it, Greg - think of it.

Don't you see a problem with our Nation's Leaders sending our troops out to invade other countries on a mission from God? You don't see any problem with that?

Sure, I agree, dear Carol. As I said to the redoubtable Michael A above, I find the "God told me to do X" line disquieting. I guess that I am not convinced that the Palin quote at issue here really parses out as "God told me to do X." It seems more like "I pray that X, the thing that we are doing now, really is what God wants us to be doing and that if it is not, we will stop doing X and starting doing whatever it is that God really wants." I do not find that particularly disquieting.

She certainly said that, but then she went further:

Pray for our military men and women who are striving to do what is right. Also, for this country, that our leaders, our national leaders, are sending them out on a task that is from God. That's what we have to make sure that we're praying for, that there is a plan and that that plan is God's plan.

She prays that our military men and women strive to do what's right. That's great.

But, then she goes on to pray that our leaders are sending our troops on a task from God. THAT'S where she strays into dangerous grounds. And then she goes on to say that we have to be sure that "our plan is God's plan." Well, that could be open to interpretation, but given the preceding entreaty, I interpret it as a "mission from God."

You know, I've spent my share of time in Protestant churches. It's simple enough to pray that God keep us safe, grant us wisdom, etc, etc...without venturing into language that portrays our international military endeavors as God's plan.

You know, what do we, mere mortals, know about God's plan for us?

She certainly said that, but then she went further:

Pray for our military men and women who are striving to do what is right. Also, for this country, that our leaders, our national leaders, are sending them out on a task that is from God. That's what we have to make sure that we're praying for, that there is a plan and that that plan is God's plan.

She prays that our military men and women strive to do what's right. That's great.

But, then she goes on to pray that our leaders are sending our troops on a task from God. THAT'S where she strays into dangerous grounds. And then she goes on to say that we have to be sure that "our plan is God's plan." Well, that could be open to interpretation, but given the preceding entreaty, I interpret it as a "mission from God."

You know, I've spent my share of time in Protestant churches. It's simple enough to pray that God keep us safe, grant us wisdom, etc, etc...without venturing into language that portrays our international military endeavors as God's plan.

You know, what do we, mere mortals, know about God's plan for us?

She certainly said that, but then she went further:

Pray for our military men and women who are striving to do what is right. Also, for this country, that our leaders, our national leaders, are sending them out on a task that is from God. That's what we have to make sure that we're praying for, that there is a plan and that that plan is God's plan.

She prays that our military men and women strive to do what's right. That's great.

But, then she goes on to pray that our leaders are sending our troops on a task from God. THAT'S where she strays into dangerous grounds. And then she goes on to say that we have to be sure that "our plan is God's plan." Well, that could be open to interpretation, but given the preceding entreaty, I interpret it as a "mission from God."

You know, I've spent my share of time in Protestant churches. It's simple enough to pray that God keep us safe, grant us wisdom, etc, etc...without venturing into language that portrays our international military endeavors as God's plan.

You know, what do we, mere mortals, know about God's plan for us?

user-pic

Sorry Kash, but ask yourself a question - what if you truly believed that an abortion was a murder? Now, I'm not asking you to adopt that POV. I'm just asking you to play method actor and see what it would be like in your heart of hearts if you believed that an abortion was the same as murdering a 1 day old baby. And you know that happens almost a million times a year. If you in your heart of hearts believed that a million babies were being murdered every year in the US, what would your politics be like?

"If you in your heart of hearts believed that a million babies were being murdered every year in the US, what would your politics be like?"

Which begs the question of why we'd want such a person in the White House.

Ding Ding Ding! Give that guy a prize!

Jorge: I was not only refferring to abortion rights,but equal pay rights, human rights, right to be an individual detached from any organzied belief system.

But to answer your specific question- why should your Jesus be better than my Jesus?

She's a kook.
Fini.

I have to say I felt like I would vomit when I read that she is a lifelong member of the Assembly of God church. I apologize now if I am offending someone but the tensions and paradoxes of religion and belief can be very stressful for me at times. In american we are free to believe as we choose when it comes to religion and spirituality. We must have leaders that can represent that freedom and protect it.

The one fundamental spiritual concept that I was given as a child raised in a christian science church was in big gold letters up on the wall of the Sunday School I attended throughout my childhood that said "God Is Love". My experience being raised in that religion was terrible but those three words as a foundation were a guiding principle.

I went to an Assembly of God church a few times when I was 16 and experimenting. The day that they told me that I had to be 'saved' and that once I was the other people in my life who weren't saved would go to hell.... I had to look at them and say I don't believe in a God like that. I later had another experience of one of my best friends from college parting ways with me after college over this very issue. She went to an Assembly of God church and was 'saved' and then the fact that I would go to hell was so painful for her that she could not longer be in my life.

This paradox and tensions of all of the different beliefs regarding spirituality and religion in our country really calls for leaders who can hold them broadly and fairly.

All of this is important because in the last 8 years we have expereinced and adminstration taking on executive power and promoting Christianity suggesting that we are a christian nation founded on christian values. I am an american and I am not a christian. My spiritual views are more esoteric and it's only important to say I rely on the religious and spiritual freedom that our country offers.

I have learned during the Bush years of the efforts to christianize our military (this came out due to persecution of those who are Jewish in the military). When the recent conflict between Georgia and Russia happened both McCain and Bush stated that we should help Georgia because they were a new democracy and a 'christian nation'. This concerned me greatly.

I respect everyone's right to practice religion freely. And to support this right we must have leaders that will honor, respect, and protect that freedom. We must elect leaders who can do this. On this issue alone Bush was wrong for the job. McCain is wrong for the job (he has now embraced relgious extremism he once rejected) and Sarah Palin is not qualified for the job. She would impose her religious ideals on america.

user-pic

To clarify - life long Democrat and Obama contributer. But I'm also a deacon in a southern baptist church and sleep next to an ardent pro-lifer every night. The charicatures by both sides are counter-productive and do nothing but make it impossible to bargain in good faith in order to achieve what is all of our goals - reducing the number of abortions in this country to as close to zero as possible.

Hm, what you say sounds right to me, Deacon P, but I gather that you and I are distinctly in the minority on this point.

I am with Jorge P. on that Iraq comment. It is not the hubris of "we are on a mission from god" but "hopefully what we are doing is right" the way I read it.

Probably best to not press that angle.

But she has more than Obama...

user-pic

Holy hell, that pastor is making a religious argument for drilling in ANWR.

"There were some things about the natural resources, about the state. There were some things about God wants to tap into to be a refuge for the lower 48. And, I believe Alaska is one of the refuge states -- come on you guys -- in the last days. And hundreds and thousands of people are going to come to the state in the last days and the church has to be ready to minister to them. Amen?
So could you pray as her pastor, and your my covering (?) too because you started this church back in the 50s, could you please pray for our governor, and for what she's basically requested."

When the rapture arrives, with lava consuming the faithless hordes, the three horsemen submitting the sinners to an eternity of suffering in hell fires, with only the chosen few left to enjoy 1,000 years of peace and prosperity with Jesus on earth, the concern over gas prices just MIGHT vanish.

After all, the rapture may solve the gas crisis altogether. In concert with the mass eradication of sinners and dramatic reduction in earth's population to the chosen few, we should see some noticeable dip in oil demand curve.

Are you saying there's a bad pastor featured in this election?

Speaking of paradoxes: Lincoln's Second Inaugural Address acknowledges both sides asking for divine guidance...

user-pic

I remember that most clearly of anything else I recall about the address.

That was so earth-shattering - what a perfect thing to say. Especially in that kind of war - civil.

Such a tragedy in our history - we had to start out so very badly with slavery and native genocide.

*sigh*

user-pic

Does anyone know what books Palin wanted to ban?

No one - from what I've read - seems to know. Might be a job for TPM Muckraker.

user-pic

To Jorge and To roo - Stuff a Sock in It.

I'm sure you would love to have us shut up - if you don't like the conversation - leave.

Pray ... that our leaders, our national leaders, are sending them out on a task that is from God.
You have a problem with my interpretation of that statement? If so, please articulate it.

If not, explain how it would help to mischaracterise it.

Here's the thing, Roo. God does not speak through our Leaders. Bush would have us believe otherwise, but it just ain't so.

I wouldn't have a problem with anyone praying that the good Lord give our Leaders wisdom. But, to in any way suggest that God has given our Leaders a task is wrongheaded - it implies that they are somehow divine.

The decision to invade Iraq was made by George Bush and his administration. God didn't tell him to do that. Did he pray about it? He says he did. Did God answer him and give him the go ahead? Bush will tell you that's the case, and his fundamentalist supporters buy that story. I don't and anyone who tries to sell that storyline is dangerous and does not belong in a leadership position in our government.

My opinion.

That was my point. She is saying that they should pray that the mission is godly. I.e., "hopefully this is the right thing to do". Not that they should pray because the mission is godly.

It's interesting that in 2002 Palin ran unsuccessfully for the Lt. Governorship. Is it mere coincidence that she severs ties with the fringe groups she belonged to the same year she mounts a Statewide political campaign?

"Obama, a leader God has blessed us with at this time"

Intertwining of politics and religion (c) Nancy Pelosi, 2008. All rights reserved.

Any quotes from Dems that we are doing G-d's work in Iraq?

But but but...

If you believe G.O.P. Nancy is trying to save the world Jesus saved once, so she's the second coming of Christ and therefore has monopoly on the intentions of GOD.

Oh man, that'll really put a dent in Pelosi's chances in 2008.

Wow. Devastating. Keep it up, Lalo!

(Of course, in reality, the distance between saying on the one hand that we are blessed by God with Obama and on the other hand hoping we are on a mission from God in Iraq are slightly, just slightly different.)

I knew someone would say this!

Ah, immflamation of the brain!

:-)

Standing up for Pelosi is not usually much in my repertoire. But I think she is here just reflecting her Christian idea that all good things are a gift from God. It's not the same as saying that the person is uniquely anointed by God to smite the infidel and convert the country.

user-pic

Jorge - Southern Baptist Convention or not?

There's no need to pick on Jorge here. He makes a reasonable point.

user-pic

Um, Tena. I've been on this blog supporting Obama since day one. Are you really saying that because I respectfully disagree with some of the comments in this thread and start a discussion that I should "stuff a sock in it" and leave?

How can we possibly debate that as a progressives we have the intellectual higher ground when we can't have a civil discussion about the issues? You really confused me with your post.

Jorge, in response to your original question, I would say that the GOP has cynically played the religious right for 30 years now. They really don't want to overturn Roe because this would lose them a wedge issue. So instead they string the religious right along, giving them only token symbolic victories.

The religious right is not and has never been the power of the GOP. They are only the patsies of he GOP. The GOP is and has been for 140 years the party of business interests. That has never changed.

user-pic

No - I'm tired of being told repeatedly on these boards that there are subjects we just can't go there with - because something about them is politically incorrect. I don't believe political correctness - I think it's hooey. So if we are talking about something you think is not right - don't be in the conversation.

Southern Baptist Convention? Or not?

It sometimes seems that Tena has two only sides, blunt instrument, and serrated edge. But at heart and in practice she is a mensch, proven over hundreds and hundreds of thoughtful, reasonable discussion (with some vulgarity and anger mixed in at times, hey its the Intertubes! If we can't vent here, where can we?). If you have been around here long enough as you say, you should know that you have to get through the tough exterior to see the soft center of Ms. Tena Hussein X.

p.s. I love you Tena, and have since the 1st day I read your posts. You represent your views so incredibly smartly and fiercely and I have learned much from your legal and female perspective. (I am just a neophyte lawyer with none of your experience and never will have experience as a gal). Thanks for being around, and not ever backing down.

And Jorge, IMO, the goal should be to give women educated choices about their lives, which WILL reduce abortions to near zero. It is not helpful to have some soundbyte that sounds good for both sides, but really blows right past the issue. Conservatives may care about reducing abortions to zero, but their actions show all they care about is overturning Roe, and reduciong LEGAL abortions to zero. If they succeed in overturning Roe, they will be fulfilling not a dream of zero abortions, but a dream of reducing all abortions to the dangerous, back alley and prohibitively expensive kind.


user-pic

Thank you - you're very sweet.

Yah, I get fierce. No offense, but having your intimate life under discussion for about 8 years has gotten really old. I don't even have to worry about that shit anymore - but I'll damned if I will let anyone tell me or any other woman that we have less of a privacy right in our own bodies than men do. That makes me crazy.

That has made me crazy since I was 13 years old - it really pisses me off.

I'm not always such a bitch. But this subject brings it out - and it does a lot of women who have been through this fight - we saw it with Hillary.

This is real live sensitive shit for women - this is our sex lives that these people are all up in and I want to stop.

user-pic

For those of you who don't know the joys of living in the bible belt and perhaps are not familiar with the Assembly of God church, we can sum up for you: Pentecostals who are allowed to cut their hair, wear makeup, and pants.

Other than that, they're pretty much Pentehostiles straight down the line, complete with the "speaking in tongues" and the whole nine yards.

user-pic

Tena,
Yep. Though I disagree with many of their political stances and have much more liberal view of how to interpret God's word in the bible.

However, in my small town in Georgia this church has the most active community outreach. The more liberal churches are more of social institutions with limited outreach. As a deacon, I am charged with caring for 16 families that include widows, widowers and single parents. We recently raised $16,000 to help a family dealing with a member having adrenal cancer.

It is an imperfect union and I make no illussions that the Southern Baptist convention often acts like an extension of the GOP. But how many Democrats do you know that can say that they get to stand in fron of a room of adult convervative southern baptists as a Sunday school teacher and preach the virtues of helping the poor, environmentalism and pacifism? All of which I have done over the past 3 months.

McCain/Palin answers A.I.P/Buchanan rumors...

http://news.yahoo.com/s/ap/20080902/ap_on_el_pr/cvn_palin_politics

Sorry, that should be "addresses" rumors...

"Answering" might take a while?

Then why does Buchanan say that the Palins were both prominent supporters of his Presidential campaign?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WZU9GGBI2jM

(See second half of video.)

Cafferty just spent about 2 minutes railing on Palin. He went down the list point by point of all the reasons she is an abysmal pick.

I love that guy.

I loved the "old white guy" line coming from Cafferty. Priceless.

user-pic

Frog,
I agree and have made that argument to my wife repeatedly. The point here isn't to convince anyone about anything, just to explain the POV of a certain group of people and why it is perilous to dismiss it.

This sums it up: http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2008/9/2/1613/27485/447/581295

I've had enough. Here's a side-by-side comparison, which I hope might be useful "talking points" for all you - go forth and multiply.

1980 - 1984
Obama: B.A. in political science with a specialization in international relations from Columbia University.

Palin: Wasilla High School, captain of the state-champion basketball team. Miss Wasilla, runner-up in the Miss Alaska pageant, also Miss Congeniality, although that is now disputed.

Him: Ivy League degree.
Her: tiara.

1985 - 1990
Obama: moved to Chicago; became a community organizer as director of the Developing Communities Project (DCP), a church-based community organization on Chicago's far South Side. During his three years as the DCP's director, its staff grew from 1 to 13 and its annual budget grew from $70,000 to $400,000, with accomplishments including helping set up a job training program, a college preparatory tutoring program, and a tenants' rights organization.

Moved to Boston to attend Harvard Law School. Selected as an editor and then elected president of the Harvard Law Review, a full-time volunteer position functioning as editor-in-chief and supervising the law review's staff of 80 editors.

Palin: Bachelor of Science degree in communications-journalism, with a minor in political science from the University of Idaho. Brief stint as a sports reporter for local Anchorage television stations; left to join her husband in commercial fishing.

Him: sterling legal education.
Her: sportscaster.

1991 - 1995
Obama: graduated magna cum laude from Harvard Law School; received contract and advance to write a book ("Dreams from my Father") as well as a fellowship at the University of Chicago Law School. Directed the Illinois Project Vote from April to October 1992, a voter registration drive with a staff of 10 and 700 volunteers that achieved its goal of registering 150,000 of 400,000 unregistered African Americans in the state, leading Crain's Chicago Business to name Obama to its 1993 list of "40 under Forty" powers to be. Appointed as a Lecturer in constitutional law at the University of Chicago. Joined Davis, Miner, Barnhill & Galland, a 12-attorney law firm specializing in civil rights litigation and neighborhood economic development. Active in several community organizations, usually as a board member.

Palin: member of the Alasaka Independence Party which advocates "Alaska First". Elected to Wasilla city council.

Him: Expert on our nation's fundamental legal principles.
Her: plotted to leave the Union; thinks Pledge of Allegiance was written by our founding fathers, doesn't know what a Vice President does.

1996 - 2000
Obama: promoted to Senior Lecturer in constitutional law at the University of Chicago Law School. Elected to the Illinois Senate. Sponsored more than 800 bills. In 2000, lost a Democratic primary run for the U.S. House of Representatives to four-term incumbent Bobby Rush by a margin of two to one.

Palin: elected as mayor of Wasilla (population 5,470), defeating the incumbent by a total of 616 votes to 413. Town budget, $8 million (3 millionths of the Federal budget), approximately 100 employees. Reduced property taxes but increased sales taxes. Fired the Wasilla police chief, citing a failure to support her administration. (He then sued Palin on the grounds that he was fired because he supported the campaign of Palin's opponent, but his suit was dismissed when the judge ruled that Palin had the right under state law to fire city employees, even for political reasons.) Hired a DC lobbyist to bring $27 million in earmarks to the city. Wasilla had zero debt when she entered office but she left it with indebtedness of over $22 million, including $15 million-plus for construction of a hockey center which was built on a piece of property that the city didn't even have clear title to, a matter that is still in litigation. Attempted to ban books from the city library.

Him: sponsored 800 bills.
Her: swayed 616 voters.

2001 - 2004
Obama: reelected in 2002 and became chairman of the Illinois Senate's Health and Human Services Committee.

Publicly spoke out against the invasion of Iraq BEFORE the congressional authorization in 2002, and then again before the actual invasion in 2003.

Wrote and delivered the keynote address at the 2004 Democratic National Convention.

November 2004: elected to the US Senate, receiving over 3.5 million votes, more than 70% of total.

Palin: elected president of the Alaska Conference of Mayors. Unsuccessful bid for lieutenant governor, coming in second in a five-way race in the Republican primary, receiving 19,000 votes. Appointed to the Alaska Oil and Gas Conservation Commission, served as chairman from 2003 to 2004 and also served as Ethics Supervisor. Resigned in protest over the "lack of ethics" of fellow Republican members. Exposed the state Republican Party's chairman, Randy Ruedrich, for doing party work on public time and working closely with a company he was supposed to be regulating. Director of Ted Stevens' 527 group.

Him: demonstrated the wisdom to oppose the Iraq folly before it even began.
Her: hasn't really thought much about Iraq - despite the fact that 17 Alaskans have died there

2005 to present
Obama: Sworn in as the fifth-ever African-American U.S. senator. Worked with Republican Senator Lugar to author and implement a program to locate and dismantle stray Russian WMD's. Designated by Senate Majority Leader Harry Reid as the party's point man on ethics. Worked with Russ Feingold to pass a major ethics/lobbying reform bill. Cosponsored, with John McCain, the Secure America and Orderly Immigration Act. Called for increased fuel efficiency standards (3 percent every year for 15 years). Assignments on the Senate Committees for Foreign Relations, Veterans' Affairs, and Homeland Security. Chairman of the Senate's subcommittee on European Affairs. As a member of the Senate Foreign Relations Committee, made official trips to Eastern Europe, the Middle East, Central Asia and Africa. Waged a tremendous battle to become the Democratic presidential nominee. Currently manages 2,500 campaign employees and a budget of $40-$50 million/month.

Palin: 2005: board member, Valley Hospital Association, which runs the Mat-Su Regional Medical Center in Wasilla.

Became youngest and first female Governor of Alaska, taking office in December, 2006. Received 114,600 votes. The population of Alaska is 683,478 and more than 50% of the state budget comes from oil revenues, not taxes as in other states. Gross State Product: $44 billion (including the oil revenue). Ranking 45 of 50.
Auctioned off the Governor's jet on eBay. Took on fellow-Republican Senator Ted Stevens to come clean about the federal investigation into his financial dealings. Promoted oil and natural gas resource development in Alaska. Helped pass a tax increase on oil company profits. Formed a sub-cabinet group of advisers to address climate change but does not accept that it is man-made. Objected to listing polar bears as an endangered species because it might hurt oil and gas development in the bears' habitat. Was for the bridge to nowhere before she was against it. However, Alaska kept the federal money. Denied her daughter was pregnant before she confirmed it. Supported abstinence-only education.Currently under a bipartisan investigation for abuse of power for dismissing Alaska's Public Safety Commissioner. Commander-in-Chief of the Alaska National Guard, but has played no role in national defense activities, even when they involve the Alaska National Guard. (The entire operation is under federal control, and the governor is not briefed on situations.)

Obtained her first passport in 2007 to perform visits to the Alaska National Guard in Kuwait and Germany. (Foreign experience so limited that a stopover in Ireland listed on her resume.)

Him: Impressive figure on the national stage who knows how Congress works and is engaged with foreign policy issues.
Her: small state governor for 21 months; "next to Russia", but that is just 1 of the 190 countries in the world she has never been to.

Conclusion: the word "executive" is not some kind of magic force multiplier when placed in front of the word "experience".

f'in brilliant. Press print.

Elitist!

(Being serious, nice chronology.)

Elitist!

(Being serious, nice chronology.)

I posted the following in another thread but I think it applies here too:

Do y'all hear yourselves? I'm usually pretty snide and snarky and try very hard _not_ to be serious in my posts here but I just realized what a poster in another thread (forgive me for not taking the time to find you and give you credit!) alluded to: We're comparing a presumptive vice presidential appointee to a Presidential nominee! We're framing our comparisons as between SP and BO and SP's hubby and BO's wifey. We shouldn't be so careless as to elevate SP unconsiously to the rank of Presidentail nominee (partly understandable since some of us have already given up McBain for deceased at least in our subconsious). Anyway, these comparisons and such are all still valid using SP and JB as sparring partners instead of making it about Palin vs. Obama. It's _not_ Palin vs. Obama it's Palin vs. Biden!

I posted the following in another thread but I think it applies here too:

Do y'all hear yourselves? I'm usually pretty snide and snarky and try very hard _not_ to be serious in my posts here but I just realized what a poster in another thread (forgive me for not taking the time to find you and give you credit!(* randy marsh in this thread * )) alluded to: We're comparing a presumptive vice presidential appointee to a Presidential nominee! We're framing our comparisons as between SP and BO and SP's hubby and BO's wifey. We shouldn't be so careless as to elevate SP unconsiously to the rank of Presidentail nominee (partly understandable since some of us have already given up McBain for deceased at least in our subconsious). Anyway, these comparisons and such are all still valid using SP and JB as sparring partners instead of making it about Palin vs. Obama. It's _not_ Palin vs. Obama it's Palin vs. Biden!

Well done.

Frances FitzGerald is my favorite writer for deciphering all-things-evangelical, and she wrote side-splittingly and insightfully about Jim and Tammy,a number of years ago in the New Yorker. Her collection of essays, "Cities on a Hill", gives you a lot about the history of evangelicalism in the U.S., and it provides useful context for evaluating the pathology of morally hypocritical, intellectually superficial and religiously preoccupied characters like Palin (and President Blutarsky, for that matter). None of which makes any of it any less infuriating.

This was supposed to be linked to something up-string. Que pasa?

user-pic

I keep saying this - typepad is crunk - it's chopped and screwed.

It's sipping sizzyrup.

user-pic

By they way, on the front page, it now turns out the Sarah's husband has quite a history with the Alaska Secession movement.

She's so outta here. LOL!

I thought this election was McCain vs. Obama, not Palin vs. Obama. Palin's the VP choice, remember?

And as far as hammering on politicians who mix religion with politics - then I'm assuming you're definitely NOT voting for Barrack Obama? I can't think of anyone who more often and openly mixes the two...

Why does Obama pussy foot around this?

Don't attack her personally...attack her record.

Why bother? The media is, for once, doing its job.

Why bother? The media is, for once, doing its job.

Why bother? The media is, for once, doing its job.

It occurs to me that McCain eviscerated virtually all of his attacks on Obama by picking Palin:

Experience? - most obvious
Judgement? - hehe
Extreme left? - take your pick
Crazy pastor? - Assembly of God
Patriotism? - AIP
"he's not one of us" insinuation? - seems normal now, doesn't he?

Worst pick ever.

user-pic

He did.

That's why this crazy theory that he is throwing it on purpose is around. This is so - I'm out of words.

I thought this election was McCain vs. Obama, not Palin vs. Obama. Palin's the VP choice, remember?

And as far as hammering on politicians who mix religion with politics - then I'm assuming you're definitely NOT voting for Barrack Obama? I can't think of anyone who more often and openly mixes the two...

I thought this election was McCain vs. Obama, not Palin vs. Obama. Palin's the VP choice, remember?

And as far as hammering on politicians who mix religion with politics - then I'm assuming you're definitely NOT voting for Barrack Obama? I can't think of anyone who more often and openly mixes the two...

Do y'all hear yourselves? I'm usually pretty snide and snarky and try very hard _not_ to be serious in my posts here but I just realized what a poster in another thread (forgive me for not taking the time to find you and give you credit! (* randy marsh in this thread *)) alluded to: We're comparing a presumptive vice presidential appointee to a Presidential nominee! We're framing our comparisons as between SP and BO and SP's hubby and BO's wifey. We shouldn't be so careless as to elevate SP unconsiously to the rank of Presidentail nominee (partly understandable since some of us have already given up McBain for deceased at least in our subconsious). Anyway, these comparisons and such are all still valid using SP and JB as sparring partners instead of making it about Palin vs. Obama. It's _not_ Palin vs. Obama it's Palin vs. Biden!

I thought this election was McCain vs. Obama, not Palin vs. Obama. Palin's the VP choice, remember?

And as far as hammering on politicians who mix religion with politics - then I'm assuming you're definitely NOT voting for Barrack Obama? I can't think of anyone who more often and openly mixes the two...

So how is it that her Party says Palin never supported Buchanan when Buchanan (in the second part of this video) says she was a prominent supporter?

So how is it that her Party says Palin never supported Buchanan when Buchanan (in the second part of this video) says she was a prominent supporter?

So how is it that her Party says Palin never supported Buchanan when Buchanan (in the second part of this video) says she was a prominent supporter?

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=WZU9GGBI2jM

First of all, I want it understood that this is a valid discussion about government, not just a discussion of private views. Governor Palin was not there as a private congregant or former member, but in her official capacity as governor. She was introduced as such, credited in the bulletin as a "guest speaker" as such, thanked for coming as such and given a thank you gift. This is legally, therefore, someone acting under color of state law, to use a civil rights phrase.

There were 3 different comments in this speech that dealt with religion. Of the 3, the first is probably the least out of line with American traditions but is getting the most attention. The second is in keeping with evangelical chrisitianity and emblematic of the problems of interjecting faith into governing, but is not facially intolerant of others. The third, however, suggests that the governor is endorsing a singular religious view for her state, violating the Establishment Clause. This is the one that should bother people.


The first - about ensuring that our missions overseas are part of God's mission - was borderline traditional politician speak (seeking guidance of the Almighty), although it gets into the scary area of holy war (and thus makes for knee jerk WTF reactions from liberals and knee jerk there's nothing wrong here comments from conservatives).

The second was what evangelicals pray for on a regular basis - Godly intervention in purely secular issues. This is the viewpoint, for example, that causes football players to claim God wanted them to win the Super Bowl, something that always makes me cringe. At some level, I understand the claim that its God's will that a sewage plant be built, or a road paved, or in this case that a pipeline be built must be the result of the speaker's conviction that they only follow God's will and/or that everything is God's will. However, in this particular setting, since the pipeline hasn't been built it suggests both the arrogance of knowledge of God's will in advance and that opposition to the project, no matter its basis, is also opposition to God. This creates the sort of wedge politics that makes compromise almost impossible and unduly demonizes anyone of conscience who doesn't fall in line with power. Still, as long as it was just her personal view this would be a matter of arrogance and a failure or judgment, but not completely intolerant on its face.

Its the third comment - that nothing secular matters if Alaska doesn't get "right with God" and encouraging the congregation to make that happen - that truly crosses the line. Getting "right with God" means, in this context, being a devout, evangelical Christian who has accepted Jesus Christ as their personal lord and savior. That is, the Governor of a state is stating that buddhists, hindus, jews, catholics, muslims, native non-Christians, agnostics and atheists are all standing in the way of Alaska getting "right with God" and must be made to see the error of their ways for Alaska to be doing God's work. That is nothing less than endorsing a singular religious viewpoint in violation of the Establishment Clause of the Constitution of the United States. This should scare everyone, even evangelicals, because it could just as easily be someone else's viewpoint that was adopted.

Politicians mainly claim to love God in this country. However, we don't elect them to do God's work, but to do the people's work. They have to be able to seperate what they think God wills from what the people want and need, especially given that the people's interpretations of God's will are as varied as the people themselves. Under Governor Palin's view, though - assuming she really means what she said - we should be living in a theocracy, with all secular concerns subserviant to the expressed will of God as understood by the orthodox/dominant religious viewpoint. That simply isn't right.


Leave a comment

Recommended Reader Posts

  • Unwritten...
    by stillidealistic
  • Two Dreamers, by Dorothea Lange
    by Rutabaga Ridgepole
  • Tsunami Wave: Will Wipe Out Republican Party
    by coonsey
  • OBVIOUSLY, YOU AREN'T A HUNTER.....
    by wvbiker
  • The Stupack Amendment played politics with women's lives and won.
    by J. Clarence
  • holly colorado
    by blumun
  • figures geometry
    by muberul
  • micropipette
    by muretol
  • short stories
    by lumacer
  • elemtary school
    by luborum



  • Resources

    The Palin Effect

    GOP Map Of Sleaze

    Tire Swinging

    The Final Debate

    World of Sleaze

    All About Sarah

    The Presidential Debates: Round 2

    The Vice-Presidential Debates: Biden v. Palin

    Critic or Cheerleader The Definitive McCain Iraq Timeline

    The John McCain John Hagee Timeline

    Masthead

    Editor-in-Chief
    Josh Marshall

    Reporter-Bloggers
    Elana Schor
    Eric Kleefeld



    Subscribe to this blog's feed.

    Advertise Liberally
    Share
    Close Social Web Email

    "To" Email Address

    Your Name

    Your Email Address