« Election Central Morning Roundup | Home | Union Drops New Mailer In Battlegrounds Hammering McCain On Health Care »

In New Two-Minute Ad On Economy, Obama Frames Stakes Of Election

The Obama campaign goes up with his second two-minute ad in which he directly addresses voters on the economy:

The spot doesn't offer any new proposals on what do specifically about the current crisis, instead sketching out his broader economic proposals in an effort to deepen the contrast in economic philosophies between the two candidates.

"I know that that we can steer ourselves out of this crisis," Obama says. "But not by driving down the very same path. And that's what this election's all about."


68 Comments

| Leave a comment

strong

This is how real leadership looks and sounds like!

No gambles, no stunts, no lies, no contradictions!

And above all things: No drama!

I really love these "talking to the camera" ads. I think they make him seem calm and collected and Presidential.

So do I. He looks at the camera and explains facts. It's clean, with no unexplained photos or graphics that force the viewer to make inferences. Just the candidate. Very professional.

Couldn't agree more. He's calm, in command, presidential and reassuring while at the same time, clearly defining the issues and the differences. I'm glad they're sticking with this approach.

Nice. Not a McCain hit piece. Upbeat. Draws sharp contrasts, but does not attack character.

http://thepajamapundit.com/

user-pic

Isn't that the same 2 minute one from last week? I love it just as much!

His voice is warm, soothing, comforting. He provides reassurance. And that lets people listen to how he's going to take care of them and make things fairer for them.

Excellent ad.

Especially the part about taxes, since I hear the repubs want to brand him as raising taxes.

user-pic

Agreed. He looks and sounds reassuring and presidential--a stark contrast to McCain's angry, dour, erratic rants!

I was thinking about the voice thing yesterday, when I was listening (without looking) to a news item with clips from Obama on FTN and McCain on TW. I thought McCain's voice sounded high pitched and slightly hysterical. Obama's was low and calm, much easier on the ears and nerves.

user-pic

Drama Queen. Getting really good at it! Excitement rising.

Versus Obama's deep soothing ... bass? baritone? I'm not expert. But he uses his voice masterfully. That's why his speeches are so powerful. He has nuance. Phrasing. I think that's in-born. Someone with a voice like that would do well as a therapist. And a therapist, in some ways, is what the nation needs right now. (He's got a team of community psychiatrists consulting for the campaign... I love it!)

I have a memory from 1960. My family was going to a Kennedy rally, lots of excitement, big signs, but I couldn't go because I was too little.
Believe me, I get it. I take care of my inner child. The couple of chances that I have had to see Obama, I was there, up front, grabbing his hand. I hope that this country does not pass up this gift.

user-pic

And his wonderful eye contact when he does shake your hand.

Versus, look at Palin shaking hands here:

http://www.nytimes.com/2008/09/30/us/politics/30palin.html?sq=concern%20about%20palin&st=cse&adxnnl=1&scp=1&adxnnlx=1222786914-vgiDo6wsVdxcZOPNFcybrg

Bass, I think. But, what do I know - I don't even like fish!!!!!

He's a baritone, definitely. Not a bass. My guess is he could sing decently too.

Trying to think of a real bass to contrast for political junkies... think, say, Brokaw.

(He's got a team of community psychiatrists consulting for the campaign... I love it!)

That's amazing, and not all that surprising at the same time. Where did you hear about that, TheraP?

user-pic

From someone on that team. Late spring I was at a professional meeting. Subject was community psychiatry - by a psychoanalysis. As I listened to the presentation, a little light bulb went on in my brain: "That's the Obama campaign!" So I said to the presenter, "Either you are advising the Obama campaign, or they are channeling you." It was the former! Truly! I'm thrilled by this. It means their focus is on healing society. Not just getting elected, but healing.

user-pic

"by a psychoanalyst"

lol... Thanks. That's a wonderful story.

I'm sitting here in my warm-and-fuzzies feeling all warm fuzzy now. Makes me feel great to hear that story. As time goes by, I am more and more impressed with this man. My god, how we need such an approach. Can you imagine the implications for community based mental health?

btw, that was cool how you used the permalink to zoom me back up here...lol. didn't know you could do that. I always wondered what those were and what they were for. I get it now. :)

Actually, Obama kind of reminds me of Mr. Rogers.

But thank God, no sweaters. We don't need any reminders of Jimmy Carter's presidency either (in terms of tough economic times -- obviously, his post-presidency is an entirely different matter).

Maybe that's why Obama appeals to me. Mr. Rogers was good as gold.

And when Obama wins on Nov. 4, we can all join together to sing "It's a beautiful day in the neighborhood".

I pray to god Obama becomes our next President.

user-pic

So do I. Fervently!

This ad has been running on a very regular basis in Michigan. I'm in the Grand Rapids market.

It's the best ad of the campaign, imo.

I challenge anyone who is under 50 to remember a time when we've had a Democratic candidate who was capable of being this clear, convincing, even charming when he's being serious. The reason that Obama has had my vote for so long is that I have believed and continue to believe that he is the single best Democratic politician to come along in my lifetime. We can only hope that ads such as these pull those 1 or 2 percent of the uncommitted and "independent" voters. We can only hope, even more deeply, than he can use this persuasive ability to swing the democratic party back in the direction of being, well, democratic (the Clintons have always been far too centrist for me).

Where is this ad going up?

user-pic

Battlegrounds for sure. Because they are really hard hit economically. And a 2 minute talk like this is worth every penny in battleground markets.

user-pic

It's been up in Northern Virginia for a few days, at least, maybe longer.

user-pic

Obama is slowly closing the deal - a year and a half of being cool, collected and patient is paying off. There is still five weeks left and alot will happen between now and then, but things look good now.

I really don't see rough waters ahead. I think McCain has shown himself up to be a gimmicky fraud, flim-flam man of sorts. And a *really* bad decision-maker. Obama, though, is wise, thoughtful, Presidential.

Easy pick.

user-pic

Yes, he's written his own political obituary here. And it's not pretty. Any sane person can see the lies, the narcissism which puts the nation and the world at risk, the out of control old, old man - which picks a floozie for a Trophy ... to draw attention (and then can't stand she's getting the attention). Political suicide before our very eyes.

I decriptor "flim-flam man" fits McCain to perfectly.

"My friends,..."

a year and a half of being cool, collected and patient is paying off

That's because Obama's the one who knows the difference between strategery and tacticalities.

user-pic

Wish those words could be slipped into the pile of Palin flashcards!

I agree this is a great ad. Well done, clearly laid out, and calming. I would however, love to see him expand a bit more on his ideas on camera to those of us who haven't had the time to read his whole plan. That's on me, but I'm willing to bet I'm not alone here.

user-pic

What I see is what we'll get more of when he's president. He'll calmly help us all tighten our belts and work for the good of All citizens.

user-pic

Give us some examples Obama. Tell us a couple of stories about people that are suffering because of this economy.

The economic crisis also limits whatever value Rev. Wright ads would've had. They would seem just so OT to the voters who want answers and leadership about what is happening right now today.

This is really good, calm, strong stuff. But I'm afraid in this blizzard of the bailout collapse this might lack the detail that Americans are craving right now.

Hm. I dunno - I see your point, but I'm sick of the details at this point. Makes me wonder if others aren't as well. Between learning what a CDO is, and what a monoline does, and why CDSs, and MBSs put together spell h-o-l-y f-u-c-k-i-n-g s-h-i-t w-e'r-e so s-c-r-e-w-e-d, I think I can skip the details for while now.

It makes me feel a whole hell of a lot better to think that somebody who thinks the creators of "creative destruction" ought take nice big drink of it themselves could actually be calling the shots real soon here.

user-pic

Both Obama and McCain say they want the bailout to pass. Obama sought to bring this about by calling Paulson and the leadership. McCain sought to bring it about by talking to his conservative members who were the folks who had to vote.

user-pic

In a functioning team, different people have their jobs. Corralling votes in the House is not the job of a senator, even one running for president (especially when a president of your own party is on the same side of the issue.) Earlier in the process, Republican House leaders openly mocked the idea that McCain had any influence there.

McCain was grandstanding and trying to take credit for a process he had little to do with (a couple of days ago he hadn't even read Paulson's initial three-page proposal.) Then when he completely failed at the one job you claim he was doing, he didn't take any responsibility for that, and instead tried to blame it on Obama.

Do we know what states this ad will be going up in? I live in Georgia now so I probably won't be seeing it unless it is a national cable buy.

user-pic

The worst part of this crisis AFAIC, is that no one trusts or believes the administration so everyone is taking positions on it based on what they know and it may not be what Bush knows.

I know that's getting to me.

When things get like this the most a candidate can do is tell us what his philosophy of economics and governing is cause I don't think anyone really knows the situation until they get in the White House. It gets harder and harder to be specific about things when you don't really know what to expect. Especially in a crisis.

The lack of trust here between the executive and the legislative is killing us right now.

I've begun to think that the problem with The Little Boy Who Cried Wolf is that, in the story, only the little boy suffers for his lying. Perhaps future generations will rewrite the story in light of our modern political experience: i.e. The whole fucking town gets eaten alive because of the little boy's lying ways.

In response to your other comment, the problem with anyone trying to declare policy and plans relative to this ongoing clusterfuck is like trying to get the pilot of an airliner that is going down in a flaming death spiral to calmly announce which alternate airstrip he intends to set the plane down on.

It's great being in Northern VA. You see all these ads and hear tons of radio ads. Most of the 527 ads also. The Palin wolf one. The McCain cancer one, which is kinda gruesome. Just saw the moveon.org ad last night trying to pin this bailout bill on McCain/Bush economic policy.

I've seen this in above ad a few times on T.V. but I'm pretty sure it was cut to 1 minute. At least it felt like one minute.

user-pic

Doesn't that say something, mike? That he can talk for 2 minutes and it feels like one - you get so drawn in, so soothed.

I love that voice. That calm, reassuring demeanor. Can't wait to have a president I WANT to see and hear.

I know the first two-minute Obama ad was running in PA, just outside of Philly in a very Republican-leaning area. This is where my sister lives, a life-long Republican herself, and she was impacted strongly by the first ad. She said it was genuine, direct, and very presidential. She decided to vote Democrat for the first time in her life this election (1 out of 7 elections); not due entirely to this ad, but rather, a disdain for McCain and his campaign. This ad should be just as effective as the first, in my opinion. And put out just at the right time.

I meant to add. This ad felt a lot like the T. Boone Pickens ads we've been flooded with. He references his plan on the internet similar to how Pickens does.

I wonder if that is where he got the idea.

Obama will be the only possible president today who can -- on inauguration day -- tell us that we are in for some really hard times AND give us the inspiration, the hope to face the hard times directly.

It reminds me of both Bush and Reagan. Bush told us that we needed to keep on shopping after 9/11, that we didn't need to sacrifice for our upcoming struggle against organized terrorism, that the tax cuts recently passed were necessary for the so-called war's success.

Reagan, who faced a situation probably worse than today's, took the economy down much too hard to stop inflation, and offered little (as I recall) in the way of hope. I remember being considered lucky in '84 that I was able to get a conventional 30-year mortgage at 13.5% interest with nearly 40% down.

Both walked only half the walk either neglecting action with words or words with action.

Good ad. All the things you all say, seconded.

However there is one line he uses when he talks about the economy, which I've also noticed at other times: "...what we have instead is the pain trickling up."

I know what he means, but I can't help thinking - every time I hear that line - that folks might think he's talking about the pain that has trickled up to the uber-rich, rather than the pain that has trickled up to the middle class from the uber-poor.

Sigh. I guess it's just a small thing, but after the last few decades of lies, twisted bullshit, half-truths, and Rovian mindfuckery I'm a little sensitive about leaving live ammo around for the droolers to fire back at us.

user-pic

Well, I think his point is that the suffering of home-buyers in the mortgage meltdown wasn't addressed, and that "trickled up" to destabilize the whole economy (which isn't exactly right, but it's a lot better than writing off all the mortgage borrowers and just trying to save the banks.)

"strategery and tacticalities"

I love it. I hope you don't mind if I use it? :-)

Thanks. No trademark issues here. Of course, I stole strategery from Will Ferrell. And I was mixing the targets of my snark. Of course it is easy to confuse Bush and McShame.

lol... tacticalities - a great riff on the idea, though.

A simple question: Since the market is a non-thinking construction and therefore is not designed to regulate itself, how do you regulate against greed?

A simple question: Since the market is a non-thinking construction and therefore is not designed to regulate itself, how do you regulate against greed?

You can't, any more than you can regulate against lust. But just as with lust, you can regulate against rape, molestation, and sex toys - ok strike that last one - you get the idea though.

Lust doesn't have the potential to ruin the country (in my book!).

But since the market can't regulate itself and greed is great according to Gekko, doesn't that mean that the market encourages greed? And if it does, then doesn't that mean that the market is inherently and ultimately dangerous or anathema to the common good?

Sorry, maybe I was being too tongue-in-cheek in my response. What I was trying to say was simply that since obviously we cannot effectively regulate against human weakness, we must instead regulate against concrete abuses that stem from these weaknesses.

HusseinTenaX said: "The worst part of this crisis AFAIC, is that no one trusts or believes the administration so everyone is taking positions on it based on what they know and it may not be what Bush knows."

I agree - if bush is pushing so hard for 'his' bialout, then it seems like there must be somthing wrong that is not getting told; i wouldn't trust him very far, not after the last eight years.

This ad has been running heavily in central Ohio.
It's an excellent ad.

This is a great ad....he comes off very sincere, presidential, relatable.

He clearly explains his tax plan and importantly explains that seniors makine less than 50,000 a year will pay no income tax. I don't think that has been emphasized enough in the swing states of Michigan, Pennsylvania and Ohio. That will matter to the critical senior vote.

This is the way all political ads should be; stop with the scary voice-overs, flag-waving backgrounds, and soft-focus soldiers/mothers/babies and let's hear the candidates talk directly to us.

I hope the Obama people get the message that this is their most effective way to make people realize that he's a calm, intelligent, sensible, and above all, honest man who deserves to be President.

Notice how the open doors and door hardware frame and keep the view focused on Obama's face. Very clever.

Notice how the open doors and door hardware frame and keep the view focused on Obama's face. Very clever.

Leave a comment

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address