« "Lipstick On A Pig" Author Was McCain Flack Who Defended Him Against Gorilla Rape Joke Charge | Home | Suggested Push-Back On Lipstick-Gate »

CBS Faults McCain Ad Featuring Katie Couric As "Misleading"

CBS News has waded into the back-and-forth of the presidential race, rapping John McCain's use of Katie Couric in a new Web ad released today as "misleading."

In the ad, which hits Obama over the "lipstick" nonsense, Couric is made to look as if she's talking about Sarah Palin when she decries sexism in American life, but in fact it's a clip of her talking about Hillary.

Apparently Couric isn't pleased about being used as a stage prop in a fashion designed to falsely suggest that Couric is endorsing the McCain campaign's phony complaints about sexism. CBS spokesperson Leigh Farris emails over this statement:

"CBS News does not endorse any candidate in the Presidential race. Any use of CBS personnel in political advertising that suggests the contrary is misleading."

And Ben Smith reports that YouTube has taken down the original ad at CBS's request.


95 Comments

| Leave a comment

Newsflash: the media are all stage props.

user-pic

Now really!

These people may not be journalists, but they play them on TV.

Robert

CBS does more than what Obama's done so far.

How do you figure?

user-pic

Right. Because he can make them take down their ads. And he'd look so tough if he sued them for libel (which he could legally do, especially about the sex-ed ad). Wake up.

Obama can't sue anyone for Libel - he's a public figure.

What the McBush campaign wants is for everyone to talk about their digusting youtube stuff - that way they not only create a diversion, but they also get that disgusty ad some free ad play.

So far MSM is playing along, but they are getting PO'd with the way they are being played. It's going to bite McBush in the ass pretty soon, IMO.

There's nothing worse than having the media PO'D about your candidate.

They'll back off soon, but it will be too late.

But what else can they do? It's obvious they have absolutely no new ideas and just want a third term EXACTLY like Obama says.

Obama can't sue anyone for Libel - he's a public figure.

What the McBush campaign wants is for everyone to talk about their digusting youtube stuff - that way they not only create a diversion, but they also get that disgusty ad some free ad play.

So far MSM is playing along, but they are getting PO'd with the way they are being played. It's going to bite McBush in the ass pretty soon, IMO.

There's nothing worse than having the media PO'D about your candidate.

They'll back off soon, but it will be too late.

But what else can they do? It's obvious they have absolutely no new ideas and just want a third term EXACTLY like Obama says.

user-pic

Anyone, including a public figure, can sue for libel. It is more difficult for a public figure to win, but Carol Burnette showed it can be done against "The Enquirer".

Another straw on the camel's back that is the MSM's tolerance of McCain et al fucking them up the ass at will.

And Ben Smith reports that YouTube has taken down the original ad at CBS's request.

It's a pity that YouTube isn't the only place where you can see it (ahem, TPM?). It's also rather lame that the Dems are relying on media outlets to do the right thing. That worked great for President Kerry.

user-pic

WTF do you want Obama to do?

He can't have videos removed from YouTube any more than I can. Only the copyright holder - in this case CBS - can do that.

He threw this steaming pile of pig-barf back in McCain's lap this morning.

I swear, some of you wouldn't be happy if Obama went after McCain with an aluminum baseball bat.

(Not that I advocate anyone going after McCain with any type of baseball bat, for any Secret Service agents who may be reading.)

user-pic

McCain still has it up on his website, though.

user-pic

I think the McCain campaign has really overplayed it's card with the media. It's gone way overboard, attacking, swinging wildly.

While most democrats are starting to panic, I think what we're seeing is the real time implosion of the McCain campaign.

They didn't vet Palin, and now she's so popular with the base they can't dump her. But all the real scandals would turn swing voters, so all they can do is obfuscate, obfuscate, obfuscate. They are hoping for an Obama meltdown, which as we all know won't happen.

And the pres is turning on them.

Word.

I am also mystified at the panic, not surprised, since the media has most people focused on the horse-race/polling aspects.

Let Obama be Obama; he's not Kerry or fill-in-the-blank with any other Dem campaign that lost.

Sage observations by both del moi and Buckeye.

I think that's wishful thinking. These sickening ads and tactics have worked in the past and they're working now -- just look at the polls trendlines over on the right and see how the lines for Obama and McCain are merging. Obama and his campaign need to hit back hard. It may be too late, but unleashing the 527s to do what they SHOULD have been doing for the past month is a step in the right direction.

We're still looking at convention bounce polls. WHo knows what they will be at the end of the week? Let's wait and see. My own guess is that they might be ableto hold their own against Obama .. but not against O AND the press.. if McCain keeps narking the press off it's curtains for them.

user-pic

Just so typical of Obama to be so pure that he issued a blanket renunciation of 527's and then went back on it the moment it became to his political advantage. Quietly so he wouldn't lose the credit he had for renouncing them unilaterally.

He did the same on telecom immunity and on public funding -- there not even giving himself the cover of even trying to negotiate with McCain.

The defective strategy involved makes you wonder how his statescraft would work: grand pronouncements followedd by the recognition that he was going to be in a fight any way?

He doesn't seem to leave himself much rhetorical room for Plan B's.


I wonder if you aren't correct. It sure seems like a lot of shit being slung in what, *three days*?

Lies upon lies, the "sex ed" ad yesterday, lipstick today, yada yada...

The media sharks are smelling blood, perhaps?

"I think the McCain campaign has really overplayed it's card with the media. It's gone way overboard, attacking, swinging wildly."

I agree with that. I also hope that lOTS and LOTS of people start showing up at Obama rallies with posters of PIGS + LIPSTICK!!

They can look just like Palin as far as I'm concerned. If the shoe fits.....

user-pic

Better they show up at McShamefaced's rallies -- with the ability to duck Republican brown-shirted thugs who are sudden fans of mooseburgers.

user-pic

No self-respecting press WOULDN'T turn on an asshole who attacks them, and tells them they can't interview their unqualified VP candidate because she will be exposed for what she is: a corrupt, unattractive, nasty, vindictive, air head.

user-pic

What a great fucking day to be a Democrat!

McLame pissed of Katie Couric? Little Mary Sunshine? Holy Shit!

He's gone insane. He's letting the fundies tell him they can win the election for him and he's totally turned on his one big winning hand: The Press.

I am in heaven!

They awakened the sleeping giant. Maybe, to use a cliché, this is the tipping point for the MSM. I personally have little use for Couric, but I recognize the fact that a lot of people watch CBS News. This could be heat of reaction the Democrats need to make this campaign finally go exothermal.

user-pic

Heck, I might even watch Katie tonight. You on the east coast must be watching her now. She say anything about this B.S.?

user-pic

What an outrage!

Ms. Couric needs to be told in no uncertain terms to clam the hell up and follow her RNC-dictated marching orders, like any other respectable member of the MSM.

Robert

Katie Couric is a tool for the Right Wing attack machine - footage at 11:00!

Pufferfish


The lipstick on a pig comment was not about Palin, it was about McCain. How about a McCain faced pig with lipstick?

Its on the front page...well, minus the McBush face...

user-pic

What am I missing here? The Ad was supposed to have been taken down by YouTube but I clicked on the link above and the ad played.

user-pic

CBS was just pissed off that McInsane did not pony up his portion of the payola . . . Entertainment Department attorneys are real pitbulls . . . with or without lipstick.

This is what in chess is called a power play, on my own view I think Obama played it wisely in referring to the "lipstick on a pig" remark, you see that on hockey too, it is also called rope-a-dope, if the Obama campaign knew he was losing they would have replaced their senior advisors, but Obama camp knew that they like to play with stupid phrases so he put it out there, McCain camp takes it out of context, Media gets fed up with all the lies, and at least there will be more scrutiny on McDepends and Ms Alaska(Bimbo) at least word is that they are liars is out there.

user-pic

Not rope-a-dope. Head fake.

http://www.blah3.com/article.php?story=20080910005333109

Vintage Jordan.

user-pic

Pay attention to what Obama does - he is a hustler, par excellence, in my opinion.

I do not get why people get so spooked and think he's weak = good god people! You really think a weak man could become the first African American candidate? Please stop!

In the first place, Barack Obama, Joe Biden and David Plouffe are smart.

I do not think the same can be said of McLame, Cindersarah or McLame's campaign people.

This is just Rove revving it up and it's going get them fucked up, ultimately.

Have some appreciation for the man's ability to do something very elegant with all this and quit making him into something he's not. He's not weak - a weak man hits out. A strong man deals from a position of strength and that's where Obama is.

Hustler?

Sorry for the double-post. I expected my reply to Economides would be attached below his question ("Hustler?"), instead of which it single-streamed at the bottom of the comments, so I thought it simply never got through. Eeek.

So now Reply works? Economides, please see below.

And people miss another tidbit: The wingnuts were even trying to go after the line about fish wrapped in newspaper starting to stink, as if that were a reference to Saracuda's nickname!!

Isn't that hilarious. Rotting fish = Sarah Palin.

It just smacks of desperation. Hopefully McBush is overplaying his hand...

user-pic

Man - talk about planting ideas in people's heads that weren't there to start with!

They are shooting themselves and each other in the feet now.

user-pic

BUT . . . But . . . But . . . Rotting fishies stink from the head . . . Is Palin a hermaphrodite?

user-pic

It's elementary school-level stupidity/whining:

"Mommy! He called me a ROTTING FISH! And that's WRONG 'cuz I'm a tough macho POW! WWWWAAAAAHHHHH, SNIFF, SOB!"

Beyond desperate into "What do we do NOW!?" territory.

Greenwald has a good piece on this ridiculous controversy:

http://www.salon.com/opinion/greenwald/2008/09/10/pigs/

No doubt mccain though with good reason he owned couric after she dubbed in an answer to cover up his Anbar gaffe.

No doubt mccain though with good reason he owned couric after she dubbed in an answer to cover up his Anbar gaffe.

Sick burn!

user-pic

Sheesh! Talk about being taken out of context. What they did with Couric's quote is pure deception.

user-pic

Pure deception: it's what they do, Jeff.

CNN-Time Polls:

Michigan: Obama 49, McCain 45
Missouri: McCain 50, Obama 45
New Hampshire: Obama 51, McCain 45
Virginia: McCain 50, Obama 46

Geha:

When were these polls released?

Joe

user-pic

Katie Couric is worse than a stage prop. The media have made themselves worthless. Down with infotainment. Up with journalism in pursuit of the truth.

Praise The Lord! I've read the entire exchange and not a single Obama fan blamed Hillary!

"This is what in chess is called a power play, on my own view I think Obama played it wisely in referring to the "lipstick on a pig" remark, you see that on hockey too, it is also called rope-a-dope, if the Obama campaign knew he was losing they would have replaced their senior advisors, but Obama camp knew that they like to play with stupid phrases so he put it out there, McCain camp takes it out of context, Media gets fed up with all the lies, and at least there will be more scrutiny on McDepends and Ms Alaska(Bimbo) at least word is that they are liars is out there."

"Not rope-a-dope. Head fake.

http://www.blah3.com/article.php?story=20080910005333109

Vintage Jordan."

Also for those soccer fans, remember the Spain 1982 Worldcup
Brazil, Argentina, Germany were the favored ones to win,
but Italy ate their lunch playing the "catenaccio" or padlock,
they just defended piled all their people on defense, opposite teams defense got tired, played all their moves, and when most of their team was on offense, wham! italy went forward and beat them all...!

Every time I think of Palin now I think of a pig with lipstick..weird.

My fiance just says she looks like a Lenscrafters model.

I can't stop laughing.

My fiance just said she looks like a Lenscrafters model.

I can't stop laughing.

user-pic

O my gawd! That's perfect. One of those in the ads that are inserts in the Sunday newspaper -

I'm dying - LMAO!

user-pic

Its the number 15 soft focus filter that gets to me.

Days after the 35W bridge collapse John McCain connected that $233 million with the tragedy that claimed 13 lives in Minneapolis.

“Maybe if we had done it right, maybe some of that money would have gone to inspect those bridges and other bridges around the country,” McCain said at a campaign stop in Ankeny, Iowa on Aug. 4, 2007. “Maybe the 200,000 people who cross that bridge every day would have been safer than spending $233 million of your tax dollars on a bridge in Alaska to an island with 50 people on it.”

http://www.minnesotaindependent.com/8052/mccain-connected-35w-bridge-collapse-to-palins-pork

user-pic

O wow!


hee hee hee!

(though it's not easy to hee hee about that bridge collapse or anything to do with it -)

Lawd have mercy.

She's been a stooge of the Censored Bull-Shit network's push for McCain for a while now.

She just noticed?

Every time I think of Palin now I think of a pig with lipstick..weird.

user-pic

OK, here's a strategy, I don't think Katie Couric would do it, but I'm sure the Wilson sisters of HEART would. Since the McCain camp seems not to care about using the intellectual property and implied endorsements of other people, AND they have a fixed amount of money to spend between now and the General Election - all that is needed is for HEART or anyone else whose celebrity has been used without their permission to get lien put against the McCain campaign for $87M until the end of the campaign.

user-pic

Maybe somebody with a better understanding of intellectual property could correct me, but I don't think Heart could actually sue the McCain campaign. It's customary for political campaigns to stop using songs when they are asked, but I think it's more to avoid the negative publicity than for legal reasons. Once you've created something, as long as people compensate you properly by paying the royalties, they can play it wherever they like.

Katie Couric's thing is different, since it's pretty clear they are quoting her out of context, as well as using her image without her permission.

user-pic

Actually, McInsane owes Heart for the play. Let's 38 million viewers times . . .

user-pic

Jackson Brown is suing BOTH McShameful AND the RNC for use of one of his songs without permission of the copyright holder: Jackson Brown.

"So there, Mr. Monday Morning Quarterback. So there, Mr. Wheelchair General." -- Firesign Theatre.

In the abstract, anyone can sue anyone for anything. Even if one isn't guilty of the charge, one must defend against it. And defense lawyers cost a lot of money too. However, McShameful and the RNC certainly didn't ask Liberal Jackson Brown for permission to use his music to advance their anti-Liberal campaign.

Our entire MSM is conflicted. Nepotism.
Revolving White House/MSM jobs. Deregulation for
Rupert Murdoch. Totally Corrupt

Delmoi:

I wish you were right, but to assume most Americans are as well-read or intelligent as our group is incredibly wishful thinking. My parents live in Texas and they still think Obama is a secret Muslim. Scary but true. The polls and trend lines are against us now and these attacks, ridiculous and unsupportable as they are, are working.

Joe

Well, I hear ya but think about it: wouldn't matter *who* the Democratic nominee is, there will be some kinda ridiculous slander against them. As for the ads working? Sure, on some folks. That crap has been flying in American politics since (at least) the early 19th Century.

It is also possible that Americans are more fed up with it than usual...

user-pic

The standard for Worst Mud-Slinging in a US Election Campaign has been:

Tommy Jefferson v. Johnny Adams/Johnny Adams v. Tommy Jeffrson.

Ooooh! what they SAID about each other! Sally Hemmings anyone?

user-pic

Very lame statement by CBS. They shouldn't have bothered if that's what they were going to "do" about it. What they did sends a clear signal to the McCain campaign that it's well worth their while to pull that kind of crap, for all it will draw, if it draws any criticism, is the mildest slap on the wrist which no one will pay any attention to. Which I am sure is exactly what their people knew would happen when they decided to pull this.

user-pic

Ok Joe - then what is your point? Why are you here telling us that Obama is losing? Why?

What's the objective?


Hussein:

Trying to get everyone rallied, I guess. As an Obama supporter and longtime Democrat, I am sick to my stomach reading the news and seeing the polls trend toward McCain. It's like the movie "Groundhog Day" and we are back in 2000. No way Gore loses to an asshole like Bush Jr. But he did. Been angry for 8 years now and hoping, praying, we don't get screwed again.

Joe

Hussein:

Trying to get everyone rallied, I guess. As an Obama supporter and longtime Democrat, I am sick to my stomach reading the news and seeing the polls trend toward McCain. It's like the movie "Groundhog Day" and we are back in 2000. No way Gore loses to an asshole like Bush Jr. But he did. Been angry for 8 years now and hoping, praying, we don't get screwed again.

Joe

Hussein:

Does that answer your question? Hope we can pull out of this and get back to leading in the race.

Joe

user-pic

Well, I think we're leading it now.

user-pic

Lame response by CBS. They shouldn't have bothered if that's what they were going to "do" about it. What they did sends a clear signal to the McCain campaign that it's well worth their while to pull that kind of crap, for all it will draw, if it draws any criticism, is the mildest slap on the wrist which no one will pay any attention to.

Which I am sure is exactly what McCain's people believed would happen when they decided to pull this. Just another negligible cost of "doing business" for these frauds who sell themselves as change agents who are going to bring an end to all that ugly nastiness in Washington...

Ditto the "take-a-deep-breath" thoughts. The McCain Campaign is thinking and acting tactically (like a fighter pilot) and swinging wildly. They've overreached on the dishonest rhetoric and the whining about "unfair attacks". The Obama Campaign is playing out their strategic game plan (like a Commander-in-Chief) and looking cool and un-flustered. As long as Obama and Biden don't look rattled and desperate, McCain is the one who will look weak unfit to command.

user-pic

A "fighter pilot" who crashed five planes during training?

user-pic

A "fighter pilot" who crashed five planes during training?

Ditto the "take-a-deep-breath" thoughts. The McCain Campaign is thinking and acting tactically (like a fighter pilot) and swinging wildly. They've overreached on the dishonest rhetoric and the whining about "unfair attacks". The Obama Campaign is playing out their strategic game plan and looking cool and un-flustered (like a Commander-in-Chief). As long as Obama and Biden don't look rattled and desperate, McCain is the one who will look weak unfit to command.

I don't know what campaign you've been watching the past few weeks, but it's been pretty obvious that the Obama campaign and DNC have been flustered and off their game for a while now.

user-pic

O Jesus!

I think that's nuts. I don't think Obama flusters. In fact, I am pretty damn sure Obama doesn't fluster.

IIRC, today was the day when some wiser folks than I said we could *start* to look at the polls again-and maybe not even til the end of the week. We're still in the dead cat bounce...

"I don't know what campaign you've been watching the past few weeks, but it's been pretty obvious that the Obama campaign and DNC have been flustered and off their game for a while now."

Really. Well, I'm watching the campaign where the Republican is being called dishonest, dishonorable, unstable, whiny and evil by mainstream journalists. Now that's change you can believe in.

user-pic


That's the one I'm watching, too.

Here's some of the incoherent drivel that the McCain camp is being forced to spout:

"The more the New York Times and The Washington Post go after Sarah Palin, the better off she is, because there's a bigger truth out there and the bigger truths are she's new, she's popular in Alaska and she is an insurgent," Feehery said. "As long as those are out there, these little facts don't really matter."

Who's flustered?

user-pic

Sarah Palin is popular in Alaska?

Um . . . and wants Alaska to secede so she can claim to be popular in the only state that matters?

And she's an "insurgent"? Then perhaps Bush should send a "surge" of troops to Alaska to put her down for being connected to al Qaeda.

user-pic

Golly. Any chance that Karl Rove slapped this ad up for his peeps?
Looks like Rove. Smells like Rove.

See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hustling

You walk into a pool hall, see just a single pool player solitairing with indifferent skill, and decide to play him a game.

"Let's make it interesting," he says, "and play for cash." You agree, figuring on easy money.

Amazing how much better he got, once you were in it for the money.

Friend, you were hustled.

Hustler: one whose tactic is to hold back at first and let others underestimate him, until they have foolishly made themselves vulnerable.

See http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Hustling

You walk into a pool hall, see just a single pool player solitairing with indifferent skill, and decide to play him a game.

"Let's make it interesting," he says, "and play for cash." You agree, figuring on easy earnings.

Amazing how much better he got, once you were in it for the money.

Friend, you just got hustled.

Poor John McShame. He can't win without a woman to show him the way, and even then he has to cheat. He's such a .... well a .... republican!

user-pic

Why doesn't CBS do what several rock musicians are doing: sue for copyright infringement when thier properties are misused, as in this instance they are used to lend credibility to a lie?

user-pic

Jackson Brown is suing BOTH McShameful AND the RNC for use of one of his songs without permission of the copyright holder: Jackson Brown.

"So there, Mr. Monday Morning Quarterback. So there, Mr. Wheelchair General." -- Firesign Theatre.

In the abstract, anyone can sue anyone for anything. Even if one isn't guilty of the charge, one must defend against it. And defense lawyers cost a lot of money too. However, McShameful and the RNC certainly didn't ask Liberal Jackson Brown for permission to use his music to advance their anti-Liberal campaign.

Leave a comment

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address