« CNN: McCain Picks Sarah Palin As Veep | Home | Obama Campaign: Someone With "Zero Foreign Policy Experience" Is "Heartbeat Away From Presidency" »

Who Is Sarah Palin?

McCain's surprise choice of Sarah Palin is a gamble that picking a solid conservative and non-Washington insider with a bit of a reformist record will outweigh the clear downside: That choosing someone with only two years in high office as back-up president undermines attacks on Obama's alleged lack of commander-in-chief readiness.

By any reasonable measure, Palin's resume should render it all but impossible to argue that Obama is too inexperienced for the gig of leader of the free world.

Palin has been in higher office as Governor of Alaska for exactly half the time Obama has been in the Senate. Before that, she served only two full terms in the City Council, from 1992 to 1996, before running for mayor of Wasilla.

To put this in perspective, Wasilla had a population of only 7,738 people as of 2004. By contrast, as TPM's Eric Kleefeld calculates, Obama's State Senate district had roughly 210,000 people -- about 27 times the number Palin repped in lower office.

Nor has Palin been tested in the grueling arena of national politics. She'll be forced to face off in a debate against Joe Biden, who's been in the Senate nearly 20 times as long as Palin has held higher office; Biden is well known to diplomats in world capitals.

On the plus side for McCain, Palin brings some much-needed "estrogen to the ticket," as one Obama hand remarked to us.

She's the sweetheart of Alaska: Attractive, young (44), a hockey mom, feminine and strong (beautiful and a member of the NRA!). Palin could appeal to a generation of women who respect strength and independence in women, but don't necessarily identify with the feminist movement. She has also managed to achieve higher office while coming across as someone who puts family before career.

There's a powerful maternal narrative, too: In April, she elected not to have an abortion when she discovered that her baby had Down's Syndrome. And for good measure, she also has a son in the army named "Track" who's set to deploy to Iraq.

The selection of Palin, of course, is also a bid for the disaffected Hillary vote, though it's unclear how disaffected that vote is now that both Clintons have offered full-throated endorsements of Obama.

Palin is also a sign that there was never much to the speculation that McCain would choose someone with indy cred. She's a solid conservative who will thrill the right-wing base.

Palin is strongly anti-abortion, and only makes an exception on abortion for the life of the woman -- excluding even rape and incest. One area where she has deviated somewhat from the conservative line is gay rights, having vetoed a bill to ban domestic-partner benefits for gay public employees.

Palin also supports the teaching of creationism in public schools, under the name of "intelligent design."

Palin also has some reformist cred that could resonate with McCain's history. In 2006 she was elected governor after running on a "clean government" platform and has shaken up Alaska by targeting corruption in local government. But she's recently been dogged by a scandal over her firing of her public safety commissioner, allegedly because the commissioner refused to fire her former brother-in-law, a state trooper, who has been involved in a nasty and long-running dispute with the Palins.


375 Comments

| Leave a comment

Palin's pictures in Vogue earlier this year:

http://www.parentdish.com/photos/alaska-governor-sarah-palin/690775/

user-pic

O sweet Jesus!

O thank you thank you thank you~!


user-pic

The McCain camp has clearly lost their minds. In one fell swoop, they have completely undermined the only argument they ever had against Obama—that's he's not ready to be CinC. Not that I agree. I mean who is besides a general, perhaps. But on McCain's terms, she is far less qualified than Barack. Plus, I have to imagine that are plenty of white working class republicans who don't much like the idea of a woman being in that position at all.

user-pic

The McCain camp has clearly lost their minds. In one fell swoop, they have completely undermined the only argument they ever had against Obama—that's he's not ready to be CinC. Not that I agree. I mean who is besides a general, perhaps. But on McCain's terms, she is far less qualified than Barack. Plus, I have to imagine that are plenty of white working class republicans who don't much like the idea of a woman being in that position at all.

I've read that this cover shot was photoshopped by a Palin supporter. I haven't found the real photos myself.

Killjoy.

Sorry dude. I hope I'm wrong, but we know she did pose for Vogue so the real ones have to be out there somewhere.

If I were Cindy, I would be getting a bit nervous having this beau around my man. He has a track record, after all.

Here's a link to the Vogue photos: not too interesting.

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/08/29/sarah-palin-mccains-vp-pi_n_122389.html

Ah well...the negligee and flyaway hair was more fun. :)

Big hair. The base will love her.

user-pic

She had a photo spread in VOGUE?

How doesn't that make her a celebrity?

This story needs to be passed around and talked about quickly. She was FOR the bridge to nowhere before she was against it. This should be big!


Here's what she told the Anchorage Daily News on October 22, 2006, during the race for the governor's seat (via Nexis):

Q: Would you continue state funding for the proposed Knik Arm and Gravina Island bridges?

Palin: Yes. I would like to see Alaska's infrastructure projects built sooner rather than later. The window is now - while our congressional delegation is in a strong position to assist.

http://blogs.tnr.com/tnr/blogs/the_plank/archive/2008/08/29/did-palin-really-fight-the-bridge-to-nowhere.aspx

This is better. Alaska reporter who provides an valid reasons why Palin is apart of the Alaska Corruption Club.

http://mudflats.wordpress.com/2008/08/29/what-is-mccain-thinking-one-alaskans-perspective/

Andrew Halcro website also has the birds-eye low-down on Pallin and her abuse of power in Alaska. Check it out.

She was against the bridge in her CNBC interview as a “reformer” but was telling the folks back home that it was a great project.
http://www.andrewhalcro.com/the_cnbc_interview_the_flips_the_flops

Halcro’s version of the whole sordid story about the firing of Monegan and her attempts to cover it up, tamper with witnesses and evidence.

http://www.andrewhalcro.com/why_walt_monegan_got_fired

user-pic

Check out Wasilla city hall where Palin served as mayor.

http://www.cityofwasilla.com/ftp/tour/cityhall/Tourviewer_cityhall.html

user-pic

Check out Wasilla city hall where Palin served as mayor.

http://www.cityofwasilla.com/ftp/tour/cityhall/Tourviewer_cityhall.html

Who said no? You can't make a choice this tragically wrongheaded unless you are out of time and out of choices. So who was the number one pick who said no?

user-pic
So who was the number one pick who said no?

Everybody who watched Obama last night.

You just killed it. :-)

user-pic

I had been thinking they might have been planning on a woman all along, or at least for some time now, and that's part of the reason they were thumping the "Obama should have chosen Hillary" meme. It's about the only think that could put any real spark of newness into their campaign. But I imagine the woman they were thinking of was Kay Bailey Hutchison (hmmm, that would have been interesting -- and all-Senator race). Someone posted here that she wouldn't be interested -- she and McCain were not exactly chummy, and besides she wanted to run for governor of Texas. Maybe the McCain camp thought they could pursuade her and failed?

Thre are other prominent Republican women, but I guess Liddy Dole would have been considered too old, Lisa Murkowski has her own scandal problems, and the other Republican women in the Senate aren't conservative enough. Same problem with Christie Todd Whitman. Beyond that, the choices get pretty thin.

We're going to find out very quickly if she's ready for primetime. But I just can't see how she's ready to take over at a moment's notice. And the difference with experience is that the American people are picking the presidential nominee. The VP is picked by one person. McCain's pick, while possible rallying social conservatives, just doesn't seem to take the first rule of veep selection seriously: Do no harm.

http://pufferfish.typepad.com/

I think you don't attack Sarah here, you attack John McCain's judgement. Really, of all the candidates to be a heart beat away from the presidency, he thought she was the best candidate? VP choices aren't about the VP, (who seriously votes based on the VP?) they are about the judgement of the presidential candidate.

user-pic

Yup. McCain's first presidential decision? A swing and a miss.

As the GOP might put it, this is is "cynical" purely political choice.

user-pic

No doubt! All the talk about how picking the BP (whoops, that is supposed to be VP, but I'll let it stand because Palin is owned by big oil) being the first choice a candidate makes and shows thier leadership potential, that talk wasn't just about Obama, was it?

user-pic
But I just can't see how she's ready to take over at a moment's notice

Remember when we were speculating about Obama's VP pick?  Fitness for office hardly ever came up.  It was all about horse-race plusses and minuses.

Tell ya what:  I'd pick her in a heartbeat over Spiro Agnew or Dan Quayle.  (Yeah, I know, that's not saying much...)

user-pic

Remember when we were speculating about Obama's VP pick? Fitness for office hardly ever came up. It was all about horse-race plusses and minuses.

Actually, no it wasn't. Some of us {ahem!} voiced objections to suggestions of Tim Kaine and Mark Warner primarily on the grounds that they had no experience in national politics or foreign policy, and part of the argument for both Biden and Richardson was their considerable experience in foreign policy.

Shoot, I was looking forward to seeing Biden go after Mitt Romney. I'm afraid the VP debate is going to end up so one-sided that Biden will have to pull punches to try to avoid Palin winning the sympathy vote.

user-pic

"But I just can't see how she's ready to take over at a moment's notice."

That's a moot point. McCain/Palin will lose by 10 to 15 percent.

user-pic

Her personal narratives doesn't matter...people don't care about all this sympathy vote on "POW" and "Down Syndrome" kids.

user-pic

You got it! She's a woman with 50 kids, one's disabled - POW!

I have not seen anyone yet say outright that this is an affirmative action pick, which I would argue is precisely not going to endear McCain/Palin to professional women. Making the case for Palin as VP requires semantic and cognitive gymnastics -- it also requires that one make the election all about energy and abortion.

What can one say: Americans like to vote for underperforming incompetents. Intelligence? We don't need your stinking intelligence! We got a pro-life, pro-drilling, beauty queen right here!

will this effect the parnell/young recount?

That's "less than two years of experience" and no national portfolio at all.

Everybody should get on the pro-Hillary boards ASAP. Republican trolls masking as feminist Hillary supporters are pretending to be excited by this announcement and loving McCain for it.

This is such a bad choice for McCain that I can only think everyone else on his "short list" turned him down.

Thank you Grampy McSame.
She's a creationist too!

So the message is: Let the war on science continue.

Oh Goody, the feminists will love her. Someone in McCain's camp should be fired for this - and I think McCain should be first in line.

A friend made an interesting point- Thomas Eagleton redux? Hey, if McLame wants to withdraw her name, bring it on. Then it will be 1972 2.0

user-pic

I found myself wondering how Sarah Palin running for VP would affect the AK congressional election.  That made me wonder what ever happened in Don Young's primary.

Looks like it's still too close to call.  DY has a narrow 0.2% lead.  There's the hilarious irony of hanging chads and ballot challenges.

Life imitates art?

Is McCain that desperate? And stupid? I had this argument with someone recently -- I said there's no way he'd pick a woman, because who would he pick? It was Carly Fiorina or some unknown Alaskan. I said he'd never be dumb enough to pick the unknown Alaskan. I guess he did. At least it was a huge surprise. =P

Carly Fiorina would have been even worse for McCain; she has business experience, but most of it is from running HP into the ground.

user-pic

Quite a surprise. This was tailored to Hillary supporters and Hillary supporters only. She doesn't even bring a state (ok, maybe, since Alaska was almost in play).

Maybe the Republicans, after seeing the Democratic movies of Barrack's coming-of-age and Biden's challenges, figured they wanted a heart-tugging movie too.

She brings 3 electoral votes (already tied to the Republican), but does she bring anything new?

user-pic

First of all, I doubt that John McCain can even spell her name, let alone picking her as his VP. This is a Rove move. McCain has almost zero chance to be elected without tapping the discontented Hillary voters, so this is aimed at them. It is a message to women: you want a woman president? Here you go. Probably within 3 years. (And, even more malleable than little George was.)

I'm keeping my fingers crossed - surely she posed for Playboy?

If you have not done so, just for your own personal amusement I recommend that you go look at NRO's Campaign Spot and RedState.org to see how this pick is going over in a parallel universe. Truly mind-boggling...

user-pic

Tell us please - I ain't going over there.

It is worst that stated. But, good comedy! Something like green onions with tomatoes!

user-pic

"Has executive experience Obama can't touch. Leader of the biggest state in the union. A true reformer, not embedded with Chicago-style pols." Lots of similar harping

user-pic

Leader of the biggest state in the union.

Good Lord. "Big" in terms of square mileage and that's about it. The state probably has more bears than people. And the major source of employment there is government.

LOL! Those were good for a laugh. She's a fisherman and a hunter! That's honestly why they are excited! Lame!!

What planet do they live on? Truly breathtaking. Thanks.

We better be careful not to make her into a sympathy figure. Any criticism of her will be spun by the Republicans as sexism.

My advice: ignore her completely. Say nothing at all about her. Concentrate all your criticism on John McCain. After all, that is who we have to beat.

Leave Sarah to just twist slowly in the wind.

There is no upside into beating up on a women VP nominee. It would backfire, and I think that is what the Republicans are counting on.

Yeah, you hit the nail on the head, mate. Anyone who attacks her will be digging a hole that McCain will use to his advantage, just like his POW status.

user-pic

Could not agree more! That is why they picked her. She is vaccinated against all attacks by Dems because she's a young woman with a disabled kid - POW! Obama-Biden should just ignore her and focus their attack on McCain.

However, her selection may piss off Independent women voters - it looks like McCain just picked another attractive woman to help him out of a jam.
Sen. Kay B. Hutchinson (R-TX), when asked about Sarah Palin, said to CNN "I don't know her."
Might be some "mean girl" cattiness that could be exploited. Nothing is more irritating to women who worked hard to get where they are to have a pretty young thing get the prize.

Not if it's Hillary doing the attacking.

Yeah, you hit the nail on the head, mate. Anyone who attacks her will be digging a hole that McCain will use to his advantage, just like his POW status.