« The Official TPM Tally: The McCains Own Eight To Eleven Houses | Home | New McCain Ad: "Celebrities Don't Have To Worry About Family Budgets" »

Pundits And Writers Start Hitting McCain For Non-Stop P.O.W. References

As all you regulars know, the McCain camp's constant evocation of his P.O.W. past as an all-purpose shield against any and all criticism is a singular obsession of this blog.

So it's gratifying to see that pundits and writers at the news orgs are really starting to turn the screws on McCain over this.

Newsweek's Howard Fineman, for instance, says that the McCain camp is in danger of "trivializing" McCain's sacrifice.

"I think they are going to it way too many times," Fineman told MSNBC, adding that "you can't help but have admiration and respect for the guy" but that "it's become a crutch in the campaign."

"I think he is in danger of trivializing it," Fineman continued. "By the time they get to the convention in St. Paul, there might not be much of it left to use."

Ouch. Time magazine's Ana Marie Cox was even harsher, writing that the constant P.O.W.-past spewing is "weird" and "bordering on irrational."

"It's a head-spinning non sequitur, designed to distract us from something mildly troubling with the assertion of something impressive," Cox wrote of the McCain team's use of the P.O.W. stuff to deflect criticism of the houses gaffe.

"It does seem like they're flirting with Giuliani/9-11 territory here," opined Politico's Ben Smith, "in which a subject that seems utterly immune to humor, used as a first resort, suddenly becomes a running joke among your political enemies and your late night comic friends."

Another way to put this is that if you print too much currency, it devalues it. The McCain campaign is cranking out all these bills with a little "McCain as P.O.W." logo on it and is trying to use them to buy their way out of every controversy that comes along. Pretty soon the McCain team's money won't be good anywhere.


186 Comments

| Leave a comment

This seems to be coming at just the right time.

If POW becomes a late-night punchline, that's all she wrote.

yeah, this is a great way to point out that mccain keeps playing the POW card, without obama saying it.

Clinton Creates “Whip Team” 4 Convention

You people just don't get it.

McCain sacrificed for this country. He's a former POW, fer crying out loud! And you may not know this, but he suffers from PTCRHMHIOD, or Post Traumatic Can't Remember How Many Houses I Own Disorder. It is a horrible affliction that has broken the marriages of former POWs with the multi-millionaire liquor-heiress wives that own 10+ homes and a jet.

I weep for him...

LOL....nicely done.

user-pic

Okay then.

I'm guessing that all those so-called "homeless" veterans aren't homeless at all. They're simply former POWs who are suffering from PTCRHMHIOD and have temporarily forgotten where their closest home is.

That explains why McLame votes against increased benefits for veterans. They already get a free divorce, heiress wife and multiple homes upon their return.

I didn't know.

user-pic

McCain can't keep claiming that what happened to him 40 years ago as a POW does count, while saying that dumping his wife and kids for Arizona Barbie 35 years ago doesn't count.

Can't really have it both ways.

PEACE

LOL, This is my first time on TPM, arrived hear via huffington post were I spend most of my time but I had to reply because I loved your comment but most of all I love your profile picture. Cracked me up!

Okay. That was LOL funny. And your picture just adds to the humor! Thanks for that.

If SNL was on the air, it probably would become a punchline by tomorrow night.

Damn fall TV season taking forever...

It's true. It's really all he has, and I really think the idiot thought it would work forever and ever. You could tell with her first response to the housing thing, it was obviously a reminder for the media to put its tail between its legs and remember its place. And after the media didn't, McCain freaked out and threw down the nuclear card, which of course was every bullshit, debunked old smear he had laying around, Rezko, Ayers, and I'm sure Wright is on the way:

http://www.thepersonalispolitical.com/2008/08/mccain-doesnt-even-know-how-many-houses.html

user-pic

Good. The Wright stuff is old news to everyone. As for the Rezko thing, there's no there there. And the Ayers thing is even more meaningless.

The only people who will care will be those looking for reasons to hate Obama. McCain can use this stuff to demonize Obama in the eyes of his base, and maybe fire them up to vote, but he won't win very many new votes.

As the recycled attacks used in the Democratic Primary fail, the McCain camp is going to be forced to move the October Surprise up into September. That will, of course, blunt its effect.

I'm waiting for the frustration of the losing campaign McCain is sitting on top of to get to him and trigger his temper in front of the media. You can already see from the very shrill tone out of the McCain camp that they are reacting to his anger. all of that is going to get worse, not better.

I predict that McCain will lose it where the media can see it. That's McCain, and he won't be able to avoid it as everything they try against Obama begins to look like trying to hit a pillow.

When we start to see the campaign hemorrhaging staff again it will be a good sign.. and probably indicate that he's making his staffer's lives hell.

He already brought up Ayres and Rezko - nothing to see here. If McC brings up Wright again, he might lose some votes. People got tired of Wright - thanks to InSannity on Faux Snooze. It became tedious and all played out.

McCain's supporters need to tell him to discuss the issues. Like how his Health Tax Credit will end up raising taxes on poor and middle class Americans.

see
http://www.nytimes.com/2008/08/22/opinion/22krugman.html?_r=1&ref=opinion&oref=slogin

and
http://digg.com/2008_us_elections/FactCheck_The_Truth_about_McCain_s_5_000_Health_Tax_Credit

Humor is the best weapon.

A former Vietnam POW has a powerful story about McCain's confinement and his early years at the Naval Academy. I urge you to read it.

Dr. Phillip Butler explains why he will not vote for McCain for president and points out that there were more than 600 American POWs in Vietnam who were tortured at one time or another. Like McCain, 590 received the Silver Star and Purple Heart. Like McCain, ALL OF THEM refused early release until those captured before them, the sick and the wounded were released.

McCain's sacrifice, while honorable, was not unique.

It's about time! We've been laughing about it here for quite awhile. I was wondering how long it would take the msm to realize how ridiculous its become. (Note: msm rather than MSM)

user-pic
... a subject that... suddenly becomes a running joke among... your late night comic friends.

Aargh.  I wanted to check out the late-night shows for humor bits from the stand-ups, but I forgot.  D'oh!

Anybody catch any of them and care to share?  Thanks!

Yesss!!! I've been saying for a while it was basically Noun, Verb, POW!! for McCain!

I love it when the media catches up :P

user-pic

Man I tell you what, if I were a POW I would:

1) Rob a bank
2) Kick a puppy
3) Poop on a cop car
4) Expose myself to an entire troop of Girlscouts
5) Force myself on a nun

But it would be okay, 'cause I would be a POW!

Beware the tipping point: Noun. Verb. POW.

Paging Joe Bide, Paging Joe Biden, please report to Denver.

http://pufferfish.typepad.com

user-pic

What a difference a day makes.

And McCain just came out with another "celebrity" attack on Obama, but it rings totally false, check it out:

http://strategy08.wordpress.com/2008/08/22/what-a-difference-a-day-makes/

John McCain talking about family budgets? LMFAO.

Now that truly is incredible.

Oh boy, the timing on this ad really sucks!

The response ad is writing itself as we speak.

Has McCain never played pool? Seems w/ every shot that he takes, he just opens himself to a counter attack. He's playing a losing game...

When you got no sound policies, all you can do is . . . attack. Sorry. That all McCain has.

How dare you say McCain is saying POW to much... he was a POW for god sakes.

You're right. And he doesn't like to discuss being a POW, either.

user-pic

Yeah, its a good things that he doesn't mention his POW status, becuase it doing it would diminish the fact that he is in fact a former POW.

Look, the fact that he serve his country is admirable. But if status as a former POW were a criterion for leadership, how come the military itself doesn't give it special status when considering its general officers for promotion?

I suppose a pun would be out of order about now.. "POW" right in McCain's Kisser!

"And he doesn't like to discuss being a POW, either."

Yeah, Obama forced him to. LOL

Ben Smith continues to say this though:

There are also -- unlike with Rudy's performance on 9/11 -- no serious attacks on the substance of his imprisonment. So there's a question of how mockery that involves his years as a prisoner of war -- as in the graphic from a Kos diarist below -- is going to be taken. Joe Biden and Jon Stewart successfully turned Rudy/9/11 into a joke. But I'm not sure McCain's experience is in the same category, or that he's used it the same way.

He's a total McCain apologist.

But I'm not sure McCain's experience is in the same category, or that he's used it the same way.

No Ben, he hasn't. It's even worse the way he uses it, since it is mostly evoked to distract from his personal hypocrisies. In any case, it's still a tic, not an argument, and it's high time the slow-witted media caught on to it.

No kidding. Politico is THE place for McCain and Hillary apologists. It's all garbage.

user-pic

Why don't we list all the times McCain has trotted out the POW excuse? Of course, his there is his inability to remember the number of houses he and Cindy own, and there was his entry of Cindy in a topless beauty contest. I know there are a lot more. Please add to the list.

The DNC or Moveon or someone needs to start a "POW Refernece" meter.

Or better yet, someone needs do design some "POW cards" that can be handed out in nice, collectible packs.

user-pic

ninevolt,

...someone needs do design some "POW cards"....

Scroll down a bit here....

http://www.dailykos.com/storyonly/2008/8/21/193943/988/378/572203

Calling Keith Olbermann...

There's a list of 20 at DailyKos.

P.O.W.: Pimps Own Wife

There was a huffPo article yesterday that went over some times that I forgot. McCain used it when Elisabeth Edwards challenged his healthcare plan, commenting to the effect "I know how foreign healthcare feels like", then there was the shot at Hillary Clinton and her Woodstock Museum pork spending saying "I missed Woodstock, I was tied up". Even recently McCain used it to defend his IPod list of ABBA, saying "my taste in music was stunted when I intercepted a surface to air missile with my place".

Of course then you have his campaign using it to defend the "cone of silence" issue saying you have to trust him because he was a POW, and yesterday using it to defend his many houses gaffe with the "He only had one house for five and a half years".

*with my PLANE, not place.

yes, even though the abba song came out after his release.

user-pic

I'd really love to see some former POWs come out and blast him for cheapening their sacrifices for his political gain. I seriously doubt most former POWs have used their service as an excuse for mistakes or bad judgment in their lives.

user-pic

Except Gard was never a POW. I want to see former POWs line up and say, "Enough, John McCain!"

Here you go:

http://www.military.com/opinion/0,15202,164859,00.html?wh=wh

The story, "Why I Will Not Vote for John McCain," by Doctor Phillip Butler begins:

As some of you might know, John McCain is a long-time acquaintance of mine that goes way back to our time together at the U.S. Naval Academy and as Prisoners of War in Vietnam. He is a man I respect and admire in some ways. But there are a number of reasons why I will not vote for him for President of the United States.

Butler needs to be paid to do a couple of commercials to amplify two huge parts of this article: McCain at the Academy, and McCain selling out to Bush for his shot at the Presidency.

Imagine...a Swift Boat - now with truth!

user-pic

Thanks! Now let's put him in a TV ad and run it nonstop.

Ask and ye shall receive AGAIN:

http://tinyurl.com/62h6l2

It should be obvious that the men who suffered along with John McCain are not taking too kindly to his lifelong quest to mine gold from the pain. They GET it. They ain't happy.

This former POW had the same experience as McCain, as did many. But unlike McCain, he chose to spend his life working to END war.

Doc's Butler's major beef is that McCain chose to CAPITALIZE on war. A peace advocate now, he found the way McCain uniquely exploited what they all went through to be somewhat distasteful and opportunistic.

His judgment on this can't be trivialized. You can't criticize Doc Butler for speaking out... because... HE WAS A POW!! :-)

(Disclaimer: But of COURSE the GOP will attack Butler, if Butler's comments ever grow legs! You can just see the frickin' PURPLE BAND-AIDS, now! Well... not this time, baby. This time we attack the Swiftboaters, and we stop when they're DEAD in the water!)

This is pretty close to what you're looking for and it's written for military.com, not for one of our lefty blogs, so it's good for emailing to all of your conservative friends (if you have any).

Oops, should've refreshed the page before I posted that...didn't see it was already posted above.

It is disgraceful to accuse John McCain, a man who was shot down, imprisoned by the savage Vietnamese and tortured for his country, of referencing the fact that he was shot down, imprisoned by the savage Vietnamese and tortured for his country too frequently when all he has done is respond to difficult questions posed to him as a candidate by noting that he was, in fact, shot down, imprisoned by the savage Vietnamese and tortured for his country. I mean, after all, the fact that he was shot down, imprisoned by the savage Vietnamese and tortured for his country is germane to every single question posed, whether that question is one of policy, character, emotional fitness for the office, mental acuity, personal wealth, ethics and dealings with lobbyists, womanizing and adultery, or even how many homes he has, because he was, after all, shot down, imprisoned by the Vietnamese and tortured for his country.

But please don't ask him about it, because it is a well known fact that he is very reticent about discussing, or even referring to the fact, that he was shot down, imprisoned by the savage Vietnamese and tortured for his country.

user-pic

Hey, NCS! Can ya tell us what McSame did back in the 60's?

Very astute...and hilarious!

Well played!

perfect.

Bada Bing!

And it's only August. This is one example, imo, of why we should appreciate Obama's talent for pacing his campaign, rather than tearing him down for not launching major attacks everytime McCain sees a cloud he doesn't like.

So true.

And if the McCain camp only has Wright-Ayers-Rezco up their sleeve, those items were done to death in the primaries.

They're SO six months ago!

Well...once they use those up, I suppose they could imply there's a Michelle saying "Whitey" tape out there somewhere. And then, if that doesn't get traction, they could jack up the terrorist alert a few times.

Maybe, the Repubs need a new play book?

CarolBG, my first thought on that... and I know this sounds a bit radical, a bit weird... is that the Republicans just might start espousing actual policies that the American people actually favor.

When you got nuthin', it's always a good tactic to open up a bag of rats and spill them into the room. People scrambling around insanely often tend to forget what they were there for.

This is generally, in the United States of America, known as "an election" :-)

user-pic
...the Republicans just might start espousing actual policies that the American people actually favor.

HAHAHAHA!!

Thanks Barry; now my stomach hurts and I have soda all over my monitor.

Excuse me while I go dry my eyes...

Finally. The POW overkill it's starting to get noticed. The same thing with Giuliani & 9/11.

McCain was a POW? I hadn't heard that.

Veteran to McCain: Stop Devaluing our Service

We obviously honor and respect McCain’s service and the five-and-a-half years of horror that he went through at the hands of the North Vietnamese; but it’s not an excuse for everything. He has already used it to explain away his infidelities in his first marriage. He’s used it to defend his healthcare plan. He just the other day used it to deflect accusations of having skirted the rules of the Saddleback forum.

It’s time for the Senator to stop cheapening the war experiences of thousands of vets and his fellow POWs, and his own as well, by stretching the boundaries of logic to make his POW status a wild-card rebuttal to all accusations or an answer to all difficult questions.

user-pic

STOP IT! HE WAS A POW. LEAVE HIM ALONE.

That YouTube video will be priceless.

There's an easy explanation why the tipping point is now: I think we saw McCain go windsurfing yesterday with the how-many-houses thing.

At this rate I hope they don't announce the VP choice til Sunday - the MSM are getting worked up to a feeding frenzy right now and it's glorious to watch!

Oh thank god. Finally!

so the buzz now is all over about McCain's vp being mittens. hmm? is this just a diversionary tactic like that lousy ad Halperin The Tool is touting at the top of the page as if ti was the first time this comes out?
But if it isn't---just imagine how fun things are going to be. Loves it.

Thing is, it was the media who cloaked McCain in his POW armor, and it is now they who accuse him of abusing it now that it has become electrically charged.

Yep. We call that being "hoist by his own petard".

You live by the media, you die by the media.

user-pic

You made me look up "petard". It means fart.

A petard was a small medieval bomb used to blow up gates and walls when breaching fortifications. In a typical implementation, it was commonly either a conical or rectangular metal object containing 5 or 6 pounds of gun powder, activated with a slow match used as a fuse.

From wikipedia

user-pic

Actually, I think it's "péter" that is French for "fart," but Shakespeare almost certainly meant to pun it that way, and in fact used the spelling "petar".

It's about time. I've started referring to McCain as "the Sacred POW" every time in other online forums.

I like "Senator 894" myself. Gotta hit him for his utter lack of intellect. But I like "The Sacred POW", too. :-)

user-pic

What's 894?
I'd say McCain's a 404-file not found

McCain's graduating rank at Annapolis... 894 in a class of 899.

user-pic

What's 894?

I'm guessing that's a reference to his class rank at the Naval Academy, except that I thought there were 800 in his graduating class, not 900.

To be fair, his low rank may not have been academic so much as it was disciplinary, though it is also true that he reportedly did not apply himself very much to subjects that did not interest him (mathematics, for example).

user-pic

slb,


894 is the number of keys needed to open the doors in McCains houses.

user-pic

I still like "King POW"..

user-pic

"you can't help but have admiration and respect for the guy"

Howard, get serious, this is the kind of questionless mind set that they want from us.
I know tow former POW's quite well. One turned into a sleazy ex-wife beater who milked the VA and his minor disability to mooch off the system while he sold crank.

The other is a devoted family man who works hard in his own lawncare business for the past 40 years, despite a bad hip and a negligent VA.

Being a POW is no kind of qualifier, the character of an individual is deeper than their POW story, and while it certainly has made some men better, it is no guarantee of quality.

Looking at how McCain got his start in politics by en4tering at the top, enabled and financed with his mistress-turned-wife's-father's alcohol-fueled fortunes, I also question his political bonafides.

He has never been a state legislator, or state anything, he never ran for th3e local school board or even for mayor or dog catcher, he never served on a street-level voter registration campaign.

The only street McCain is comfortable with is K-Street.

So lets not make his POW status anything to respect, in its own right.

It is the man, and not his wartime imprisonment story, that we need to judge.

user-pic

Well said, sir!

McCain was not a POW. He was a "enemy combatant" who was given "enhanced interrogation." Whats the issue?

http://www.reuters.com/article/pressRelease/idUS131178+14-Mar-2008+PRN20080314ho was

P is for Pathetic
O if for Out of touch
W is for WTF?

The celeb thing has lost its legs too. It's not Obama's fault that he is popular, but it is McCrusty's fault that he doesn't know how rich he is.

I thought POW stood for Prisoner of Washington DC.

I could careless about McCain's POW service.

user-pic

It's scary how viciously they reacted to the Democrats ridicule of his lack of knowledge about how many homes he owned. What if the Democrats had perpetrated a serious attack? What would they have done then?

Just a week or so ago, John McCain was laughing off an attack on Barack Obama and was saying it was just a "joke". Now, when the table is turned, we get this reaction from the McCain camp. What's the matter - they can't take a joke?

The hot-headed and heavy-handed way they reacted to this story may be an indicator of how he would react in a national crisis? They came after Obama with their eyes closed and their machetes slashing whatever was in front of them. Their reaction to the Obama ad was rather scary in a way.

user-pic

Yep. McCranky should just lighten up. Sit back, relax, and enjoy the ride.

I was struck by exactly the same time, and was even thinking about blogging about it. I really wasn't expecting the full-blown Donald Duck tantrums over a pop this light. Its clear that their frustruation at their inability to crack McCain's ceiling is getting to them.

McYukYuk did not keep his sense of humor. He turned into a regular McCrank. Tweren't funny being the attackee, now was it?

I found this article uniquely interesting. Dr./Mr. Butler seems to strike the correct balance in addressing the obvious strategy by Mr. McCain and his campaign:
http://www.alternet.org/election08/95825/i_spent_years_as_a_pow_with_john_mccain%2C_and_his_finger_should_not_be_near_the_red_button/

All I know is...

I had damned well better not see Barack Obama "DENOUNCE" Doctor Philip Butler for his "deplorable" comments! NO, BARACK. NOT THIS TIME, BABY. ZIP IT!.

I mean, it's bad enough he already tossed what could have been his secret weapon against all this ignorant jingoism, Wesley Clark, under the Straight Talk Express..!

Meanwhile, as the abused POW card continues to lose its ability to trump, Obama gets to keep honoring McCain for his service, regardless of day-before-yesterday's tantrums by the armchair strategists.

user-pic

Well, ain't this a nice way to start Friday and I saw that Franken has pulled ahead of Coleman, too.

GLOATgloatGLOATgloatGLOATgloatGLOATgloatGLOAT!!!!!!!!!!!

Yeah I love this.

Hadn't seen that poll. Sweetness, indeed. :-)

McCain, a war hero who was held prisoner by the Vietnamese for over 5 years, has a lifetime of foreign policy experience, not including the over 5 years the war hero spent as a POW in Vietnam. John McCain, former POW and war hero, also happens to be a war hero who was held prisoner by the North Vietnamese for over 5 years.

McCain was a POW. He doesn’t like talking about it

I've made a (messy) request to start a list of all the times the McCain has used his POW past to rebut criticism in the hope that everyone will finally see how embarrassing his use of it really is.

What's important to understand is that it not only cheapens his heroism, but that of others who suffered the same horrendous fate.

Visit the post and add to the list here: McCain Campaign List of Rebuttals involving POW Past

user-pic

What does McCain have to sell except his POW story and McCain/Feingold?

When the newsies start going negative on his POW story, the comedians can't be far behind.

And, courtesy of McCain's joint committee with the RNC - that's designed to circumvent the caps in McCain/Feingold - he can't even sell THAT bill of goods anymore. :-)

Great stuff.

McCain has overplayed his hand.

Once the late night comics start mocking you, it's over.

The house gaffe was coffin nail #1.

Could POW-excuse as joke be next?

user-pic

King POW chcken?

user-pic

Wow, this is bad. Because Ana Marie Cox was such a staunch McCain supporter before all this...

user-pic

Lol.

user-pic

SFCWallace,

lame, lame, lame.

McCone is an idiot warmonger, and his Rove operatives are as dumb as their leather slave master Karl.

POW. More like KABOOM!

It's a petty example, I'm sure, and he is not officially a McCain campaign staffer, but on 8/12, Hannity repeatedly cited McCain's POW experience as the "extenuating circumstances" that explained why McCain's marital infidelity and leaving his injured first wife didn't disqualify him from the presidency, but John Edwards' did.

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=fx3aaOyVU5A

user-pic

It's time to bring back Wesley Clark. It was a mistake to throw him overboard. He was the one person speaking the truth that needed to be said, in my opinion. It could prove the fatal mistake of the Obama campaign? Do they need to see anymore about where the McCain campaign is willing to go in their attacks. I'm John McCain and I approve this message.

This would be a perfect time to bring back Wesley Clark. Barack, give him whatever he wants, apologize until you're blue in the face, then take the leash off of him and let him go after Senator 894.

Just about to say the same thing.

Maybe we have Wesley Clark to thank for initially jumping on the POW grenade. Just saying...

Kos

Not that Kos

Don't take ANYTHING the McCain people do at face value. Clark planted seed of the whole POW/eligibility issue. He was "chastised" and put under wraps. The seed is now beginning to bear fruit, and Clark will reemerge after the convention. Because everybody will have talked the POW thing to death, Clark's original action will be a moot point.

Clever.

user-pic

John McCain: He is a Prisoner of Wealth.

user-pic

I think we should be careful in not going overboard attacking McCain for this. Let the media do the pushing, I mean he really was a POW and while that's no excuse for some of the crap he's pulled it's also not really appropriate to make all kinds of jokes about it (like "POW" = "Prisoner of Washington")

I know you just want to it back at the guy over his attack ads against Obama, but the point here is to win the election, not too make the other guy feel bad.

The real point here is putting the McCain campaign on the defensive.

We're part of the echo chamber in the left blogosphere. We need to make this meme so loud that the MSM picks it up. This requires constant repetition and amplification.

To hell with McCain's feelings. It's time he got hit in the mouth with his own hypocrisy.

Exactly. The problem isn't that he was a POW - that's not what we mock. What we mock is his using that as a catchall excuse for any personal failing or ridiculous policy proposal. The vast majority of postings here and other places I visit know the difference, but every so often I see a poster who doesn't.

I think the media is finally catching on to the McCain ruse, but let's not give them any excuse to jump back onto his bandwagon and feel sympathy for him.

user-pic

There's only one person that can make John McCain stop say POW..POW...POW...

And that is General Wesley Clark. It's too bad he was thrown overboard. He was the one person that was speaking the truth about McCain. That being, that POW status does not automatically qualify anyone for the Presidency.

Judging from the McCain attack ad on Obama yesterday, the Obama campaign may rue the day they did not keep General Clark in the stall. They attacked him unmercifully because of what he said. The Obama campaign misread it.

Please cite the "unmerciful attack" on Clark by the Obama folks. Please provide details of Clark being thrown under the bus.

John McCain was a POW?! I had no idea!

I hadn't heard that anywhere!

Good article written by a former POW on WHY he won't vote for John McCain. Good one.

http://www.military.com/opinion/0,15202,164859_1,00.html

user-pic

Good one, indeed. Thanks.

"The Tortured Saint". Gives it those religious overtones.

(Although to be fair, the fundies who would appreciate the personal tie to God Almighty Himself would probably find some revulsion at the mention of "saints". I have it on very good first-hand authority that, as religious as they like to come off... they really hate CATHOLICS. Not a damned clue why.)

user-pic

they really hate CATHOLICS. Not a damned clue why.)

It goes back to the 16th century.

P.O.W, P.O.W, P.O.W. : McInane, McInane, McInane!

To paraphrase Patton,

No bastard ever won a war by getting shot down for his country. You win a war by shooting the other dumb bastard down for his country.

user-pic

This is an argument for Biden. Obama needs someone with foreign policy credentials, gravitas, experience...AND...a horrible personal tragedy to take toe-to-toe with McCain and his endless maudlin tales of captivity. Biden: "Hey, John, you wanna talk suffering, anguish, pain? I'll see your broken shoulder and raise you a...." well, I'm not going to say it and neither will he, but you get the idea. Biden can and will put a cork in McCain's only claim to sainthood.

user-pic

David Brooks says much the same thing in his column today. (I have to wonder at the world when David Brooks starts making sense, but he's been doing that more and more lately...)

Agreed. Plus he has more street cred on Iraq than probably any other politician in Washington, with both real technical expertise and a son who has served. The latter helps with the "Bittergate" crowd, as does his working class roots. I shudder when I start agreeing with David Brooks about...well, much of anything, but I agree with him (NY Times this morning) about Biden as a good VP choice.

There's a list of 20 at DailyKos.

Please stop referring to McCain as a prisoner of war. He was a combatant detainee.

And he wasn't tortured. He was given enhanced techniques of conversation.

It's time for Orwell to get his revenge.

user-pic

Hamdan for president. After all, he's a POW too.

user-pic

Umm...hello? Hamdan isn't a POW, he's an "enemy combatant"! Huge difference because...you see...he. Well he just is!

If they can keep calling him "Barack Hussein Obama", we can keep call their guy "John Sidney McCain, III" - just like Thurston J. Howell, III.

user-pic

It is outrageous to suggest that John McCain, a former Prisoner of War, is overusing his status as a former Prisoner of War.

I kept expecting to see SFC in this thread, with his repugnicant trollbook....all this borderline disrespect kept him quiet i guess. but then, he surfaced. guess we'll see ya later sarge.

user-pic

I wish the Dems would bring up Max Cleland in this context. Now there's someone who sacrificed far more for his country than McCain ever did. And what did the GOP do? Gave him the smear treatment, naturally.

There's plenty of people who sacrificed more than McCain and didn't come home to dump their wives and marry a zillionairess. We need to remind people that McCain is not the only one who ever sacrificed for his country, and that he came out of it pretty good in the end.

The mantra that McCain doesn't like to talk about his POW experience needs to be exposed for what it is.

Just some random rambling: The clip of McCain declaring (while looking sternly at his cue cards) "I don't question [Obama's] patriotism. I question his JUDGMENT . . ." (Wild applause from the ditto audience) made me wonder: Does a man who damned near got booted out of the Senate for his involvement in the Keating/S&L scandal, or who steadfastly opposed the MLK holiday, or who was an ardent proponent of invading Iraq -- at the expense of taking care of business in Afghanistan -- or, who is generally assumed to have gamed the rules by listening in on Obama's Q&A last Saturday have any real standing to question someone else's judgment? I don't think so.

Lets face it, beyond the POW experience, there's nothing particularly compelling in John McCain's biography. The most newsworthy event in McCain's twenty-five plus years of political life is his involvement in the Keating Five scandal. We are often told that he's a maverick, but strangely there's nothing to actually support that myth.

McCain has never provided great political leadership. He's never inspired the public to get involved. There's no eloquent speech that McCain has given on some grand issue. There's no moment in his political history where he went out on a limb to help the little guy, or some wise piece of legislation with his name on it that we all give great thanks for. How do we know these things? Because if there was a whiff of these things in McCain's past, the media would be telling us about them ad nauseam, and McCain would certainly have them in his ads.

Is there any wonder why McCain gave up so quickly in trying to present his own biography and instead has devoted most of his ad time attempting to damage the biography of Barack Obama?

"Flirting" with Giuliani-9/11 territory?? I don't think McCain is flirting anymore. I think he's knocked it up, put a ring on its finger and run off to the cheapest Elvis chapel in Vegas with it.

Hopefully Obama won't have to touch this at all - he'll let the media do it for him. But then again, this IS the famous "liberal media" we're talking about.

Now may be the time to bring back Wesley Clark. In this environment, his assertion that being a POW doesn't qualify one as CIC would seem to be quite effective now.

I was just talking to my 23-year old son (who is starting law school this semester) about the POW card that McCain is always pulling, and he said that the young people do not care about something that happened in the 1970s. I have three children who will be voting for Obama in November (18, 22, 23) and can't help but think that the polls are underestimating how many of the young people are going to turn out and vote for Obama, and the same for African-Americans. There is going to be a bigger turnout than this country has ever seen in the general. I just wish we could see Obama's strategy, but I know it is precise.

So, he can't use POW as a defense anymore and he can't call Obama an elitest anymore,...I think there done!

McCain was a POW? Really? Damn!! I didn't know that!
Someone outta let his campaign people know they should be getting the word out more!

user-pic

It's been uncomfortable to watch McCain reach; I used to think well of him. Now it's embarrassing.

Fineman captured a big part of the problem: trivialization.

And FWIW, for a lot of voters, VietNam is as distant as the Battle of Normandy or as the Norman Conquest; they don't understand what McCain is talking about with respect to VietNam. Sad, but that's what I've seen.

Fundamentally, how on earth does this tell anyone who he'll appoint for Dept of Energy, Transportation, DoJ, yadda yadda. People tend to say that Americans don't care and can't follow details. To some extent that's true. But a lot of people's jobs depend on how well government functions, and I think people would be receptive to some blueprint our outline about HOW either McCain or Obama would govern.

"I was a POW" was compelling in the 1980s, but basically Bush and Rove killed that Golden Goose back in 2000 in N.C. Relish the irony.

"PTCRHMHIOD, or Post Traumatic Can't Remember How Many Houses I Own Disorder" aside, Has it been pointed out that he has said he cannot talk about the experiences of torture as a POW.

Honorable a self-sacrifice in war may be, do we want a psychologically wounded man at the helm?

Further, he is often confused and unable to speak clearly about current happenings. This makes me wonder how he would decide where to send the bomb of retribution.

I find this frightful. Perhaps we better return to building bomb shelters and teaching the children to hide under desks.

Good post, Greg.

What really is starting to piss me off, is how often the MSM continues to protect him, even while they are acting exercised by his POW pronouncements. Just take the last two days transcripts from the left leaning Keith Olbermann show:

Countdown with Keith Olbermann – transcript, August 20, 2008

OLBERMANN: Last point and briefly, I‘m doing this out of order but it‘s either do it out of order or ask you to wait 20 minutes to answer one question. If either presumptive nominee suddenly revealed he did not disagree with the idea of reinstating the military draft, what would happen to the numbers that we‘re seeing in the polls tonight?

TODD: Well, look—already, you would see numbers move probably among young voters, but let me just go here and give McCain the benefit of the doubt on what he might have thought he was agreeing to which is—he has been a big advocate on the national service front, as has Obama as a sort of mandatory service in some form that you see a lot of politicians take. So, it is possible that that‘s what he was talking about.

Countdown with Keith Olbermann – transcript, August 21, 2008

OLBERMANN: How many houses do the McCains have?

FINEMAN: Well, am I under oath?

OLBERMANN: Do you have a staff to get back to me?

FINEMAN: Yes.
We‘ll, we reported in the magazine last year seven; now, there are some reports on the Web of eight. People have looked through lots of real estate records and so forth. I didn‘t count them all. I‘ve been in a couple of them and I was at the ranch in Sedona, by the way, before that redo. I was there I think in 2001. There was no swimming pool. The thing that, I think, got McCain tripped up is that, I think, legally, he probably doesn‘t really own them per se, himself. When he married Cindy, he married into a family empire of, at least now worth, at least $100 million. Those houses are probably mostly in her name. So, he doesn‘t really pay attention to the details, which, in its own way, is almost more damming than knowing how many houses you have.

Thanks Greg - only a matter of time before this was picked up, which is great.

Wonder if Biden has another line like the one he used on Rudy "9/11" Guiliani?

I read somewhere that according to the current administration policy, one could question weather he was really tortured versus just enhanced interrogation . . .

user-pic

IT'S THE LOBBYISTS STUPID!

Yes the housing gaffe was pretty good and the POW bazaar should be pointed out at every occsion but did you see McCain's complete hypocrisy about the "Birds of Prey" lobbyists that he would NEVER allow to operate in his camp or in his administration. He tries to pretend he doesn't know his entire campaign is run by lobbyists and that he is every lobbyists "pet senator on a leash". Can he be that dumb or have the lobbyists been so effective that he does not realize it is their policies and positions he stands for?

This got a pass because he said it the same day as the housing comment. "Are you kidding?" should be the MSM's reaction because it is so glaringly obvious that lobbyists run McCain while he condemns them and their activities publicly. He is actually condemning himself and dems should be all over his
stupidity.

McCain would rather start a war than lose an election...even if it's only a cold war.

user-pic

The McCain camp would explain to you, real s.l.o.w.l.y that what happened to him 35 years ago is a direct result of what happened 40 years ago. He isn't responsible for anything after his imprisonment.

"I think we should be careful in not going overboard attacking McCain for this."

Uh, excuse me, but who made you the boss of us? Are you the duty hall monitor or something?

"He is someone who purports to campaign as a man of the people, but who resides in a whole series of wealthy million dollar chateaus and mansions," said Bush campaign spokesman Terry Holt in the summer of 2004. "It's just one more contradiction and example of him being out of the mainstream with America."

The misfortune of getting shot down does not a hero make. Medal of Honor winners are usually very careful to avoid describing themselves (or allowing anyone else to describe them) as heroes. Usually they say something along the lines of "The real heroes are the guys we left on that island." McCain, who finished near the bottom of his Annapolis class, was a screw-up as a Navy Airman. He smashed up five planes, all told, and there are allegations about his role in the explosions and fire aboard the USS Forrestal that killed over 100 sailors. For this former member Keating Five to be prating about his distinguished service in war and in the senate is ridiculous. He's a dangerous man to have such power, especially as it becomes increasingly plain that his mind is not all it could be.

Too rich AND
Too senile

The double edged sword that keeps on cutting

To quote Bush: "Some people call you the elite. I call you my base."

Or a popular bumper sticker:
"There are two kinds of Republicans: millionaires and suckers."

Senator McCain’s constant reference to his time as a POW has become completely obnoxious. It is bad enough when he talks about it or makes references to it himself; it is even worse when members of his campaign staff use it because you have to wonder if he even knows they’re doing it. He is allowed to wear his decorations, his staff is not.
What I find particularly disingenuous is the fact that his use of his experience as a constant excuse or shield. belittles the sacrifices of all of the other service members who also fought in Viet Nam. With him, it is all about him. Has anyone heard him talk about the rest of the military? Maybe he forgot the rest of us and he believes he was there by himself.

During the last few days I saw a quote on these boards that I am going to co-opt. (I am sorry, but I don’t remember the name of the person who posted it.)

“A veteran is someone who, at one point in his/her life, wrote a blank check made payable to The USA for an amount of "up to and including my life." - unknown

There are very many of us that wrote that check. McCain is just one of the group. His blank check was cashed as a POW. There are many others who paid a great deal more.

2,594,000 personnel served within the borders of South Vietnam ( I January 1965 - 28 March 1973)

Another 50,000 men served in Vietnam between 1960 and 1964

Of the 2.6 million, between 1 and 1.6 million (40-60%) either fought in combat, provided close combat support or were at least fairly regularly exposed to enemy attack.

7,484 women served in Vietnam, of whom 6,250 or 83.5% were nurses.
Total killed: 58,253 (including men formerly classified as MIA and Mayaguez casualties).

WIA: 303,704 - 153,329 required hospitalization, 50,375 who did not.

Severely disabled: 75,000, 23,214 were classified 100% disabled. 5,283 lost limbs, 1,081 sustained multiple amputations.

MIA: 2,338

POW: 766, of whom 114 died in captivity.
Senator McCain is just one of them, and he lived

What really gets to me is McCain's "Cross in the sand" story...which he has repeated so often...
..taken from The "Gulag" by Soul-sa-knee-shun.
(Unless of course, there were TWO crosses in the sand ...TWO POW's that were 'losing hope' and THEN...
A guard comes over and with a stick comes over and makes a cross...)
McCain enthused over that book...took it to heart as it were...

user-pic

The primary honorarium for John McCain used to be "Senator", but his campaign wants people to call him "Prisoner of War" John McCain, since the elected Senate position appears to offer much less street cred.

I personally think he gets serious street cred for being both, but he'll always be Senator McCain to me.

user-pic

Since McCain doesn't like to mention his POW status, I think we liberals (being the generous lot we are) should take up a collection and buy the guy a sandwich board to wear (just like they do in front of Liberty Tax in April), one that says 'P.O.W.--but I don't want to make a big deal out of it.'

I think it would look spiffy on him at the convention.

I haven't seen anybody else mention this, but forgive me if I'm repeating a point already made in this long string.

James "Who Am I and Why Am I Here?" Stockdale was a Vietnam POW. That didn't seem to pave the way to the Vice Presidency.

Besides which, John Cindy McCain III is a double POW: Prisoner of War and Prisoner of Wealth.

Oops! Did I write "Cindy"? I meant to write "Sidney." So easy to slip on that one!

The man accused of sending a threatening letter to John McCain through McCain's Colorado headquarters office talked to 7NEWS Reporter Tyler Lopez in an exclusive interview Friday.

* * *

On Thursday, McCain staffers at the Centennial office notified the Secret Service that it had a "threatening letter" against McCain and the letter contained some type of white powder.

BUT SEZ THE LOCAL GUY:

"Our guys did not find any powder. There were maybe a couple of grains of something inside an envelope and they had to kind of work to get a sample," said Andy Lyon of the Parker South Metro Fire Rescue Authority. "It was described to me as maybe they found a couple of granules of something. It tested positive for protein, what was described to me as a weak positive. Well, protein could be a protein shake."

http://www.thedenverchannel.com/politics/17267476/detail.html

If this is another Rove attention-getter like the bug supposedly found in his office (but universally believed to have been paced there by Rove hisself) in 1986, I gotta say he's losing his touch.

MCCAIN DOES NOT SPEAK FOR THE CAMPAIGN.

MCCAIN DOES NOT SPEAK FOR THE CAMPAIGN.

OK! Now that we have all gotten totally sick of McCain as "THE POW", lets address this constant "my friend" thing.

Please old man, I am not your friend nor will I ever be your friend and if by some strange quirk of fate you manage to weasel your way into the White House, I don't want your friendship, I want your leadership.

Does this give anyone else nightmares of Tricky Dick saying "my fellow American"?

Thank you!!! I cringe everytime he uses the term "my friends". In my book you only call people you know your friends. I've never met the guy and certainly don't consider him a friend of mine. He probably uses it thinking it makes us feel all warm and fuzzy --- NOT!

My experiences with people who call you "my friend" is you're not.

Meghan McCain is also down with the POW POW POW from this GQ blog article:

http://men.style.com/gq/blogs/gqeditors/2008/03/caps-font-var-1.html

Indeed, John McCain is nobody’s idea of ideologically consistent, and it’s tempting to interpret his daughter’s progressive positions as evidence that life in the McCain household isn’t exactly a revival weekend at Bob Jones University. But Meghan sees her father’s politics as common sense.

“My dad was tortured in prison; he doesn’t overreact to things. So if he starts freaking out, you know it’s time to freak out,” she says. “And I think he’s freaking out about the environment. He’s like, ‘I’m genuinely worried about climate change; it’s happening right now.’ ”

user-pic

"My friends, I was a P.O.W. Did you know that? I do. They captured me during the Korean War. No, it was World War I. No, it was the Peloponnesian War. Oh hell, what does it matter?

"But, my friends, I have a message for America's kids, which means everyone because I'm older than you are. Just about all of you, anyway. Now what was I saying?

"Oh yes, I remember: Kids, get off my lawns!"

Barry Champlain @ 12:29 PM posted: "...the Republicans just might start espousing actual policies..."
Doubt it very, very much. They were given that oppotunity in 1948 (see "Turnip Day" session, May 26, 1948).
After the Republicans had spent the primaries attacking Truman and talking about all the things they were going to do (some of which Truman supported); President Truman called a special session of the Republican-controlled Congress and, basically, allowed the Republicans to cut their own throats, electorally-speaking. The Republicans refused to pass any legislation, preferring to wait until after the elections.
They said "Trust us" and the voters said "No". My personal belief is that the special session sealed the Republicans' loss in November. During his campaign Mr. Truman used their intransigence to good effect in many of his "whistle-stop" speeches.
I really don't think Republicans have learned anything since; they are certainly not acting as if they had. I also think the voters are going to respond just as in 1948, perhaps even more resoundingly.

user-pic

For context, take one of today's inhabitants of Guantanamo or Abu Ghraib and 40 years down the road, make him president of [your choice of muslim homeland country]. McCain's war history has always said as much to me about the Vietnamese as it has said about John McCain.

user-pic

How dare the press call out McCain, a prisoner of war, for playing the prisoner of war card? After all, he was a POW. It's not like he ever talks about it or anything. Did I mention he was a POW? While he was a POW, he had lots of time to think really Deep Thoughts about the economy, national security, and how broken Washington is, except when closet Christian Vietnamese guards (you know, the ones who were guarding all the POWs, which included John McCain, who was a POW) came out and drew crosses in the dirt in front of POW John McCain while he was a POW. Just like Solzhenitsyn, sort of, who said a remarkably similar thing happened to him in his very famous book, but it happened to POW McCain first, or something. By the way, POW McCain would never use his POW status for political gain. That would be dishonorable and unbecoming of a former POW like John McCain.

McCain has been doing the same thing Obama tried to do. Obama tried to use race to shut down any criticism. "I don't look like those other guys."

But now McCain has been using the POW malarkey to shut down criticism - and he's been getting away with it. Why isn't Obama being as direct about shutting that down as McCain was with him?

You mean that there were OTHER Americans incarcerated as POWs in North Vietnam? Imagine that!

I was wondering...is there any truth to the rumour that John McPain was a POW?

I'm not a McCain supporter, but I don't see McCain himself using this POW line as a defence... it is mainly people within his camp. I know ultimately he licenses the POW defence and allows them to use it on his behalf, if he didn't, or if he objected to it, it would have stopped months ago.

It does offer him some immunity from criticism, particularly from vets and those who experienced the same ordeal, that he himself doesn't express having spent time as a POW as mitigating any poor judgement etc etc. But I think this is a two way street... either you talk about your experienceas a POW openly and allow the electorate to determine how they feel that shapes your personality and presidential judgement, or you stop exploiting it for political ends.

Anyone witnessing the Hannity & Colmes discussion over John Edwards affair making him unfit for public office, then immunizing McCain from the same criticism because he was a POW, while nonetheless hilarious, highlights how ridiculous this point has become.

Of course it cheapens what these men went through... when an experience like McCain's is seen as a political weapon, over an altruistic sacrfice for his country, people need to take a step back and put things in perspective.

That's the funniest Post Traumatic comment of the campaign. Loved it. And I'm a Vietnam combat vet.

The anxiety level among the Wing-Nuts must be elevated now that Joe Biden is riding shotgun. They know Biden's mouth can "inadvertently" get him in trouble and he is liable to blurt out things like:

"How does graduating 894th out of 899 in your class and crashing five jets qualify someone to be president?"

"Why is Clinton an "adulterer" but McCain is a "former POW?"

"Yes, I've seen a great number of people who were held prisoner with John McCain say that he was given special treatment. The difference is our party does not hire 527s to publicize it."

"Yes, I did hear that McCain made 32 tapes for North VietNam, but, no, I don't agree with your premise that he was a "collaborator."

It's nice to see that the MSM is finally beginning to understand that they should get their talking points from you. I mean, haven't they ever focused on the name of the site? Sheesh.

And why shouldn't they get their feed from you? They are just as unabashedly pro-BHO as this site.

And don't tell me Maureen Dowd has signed on! You mean she's proBama too? I never would have guessed!

Well, it looks like you've got it all under control. Keep up the good work.

One cautionary note, though. What if BHO only receive the support of voters who can actually define "meme"? Is that enough to win? Remember the wisdom of Pudd'nhead Wilson, who asked "Ain't we got the fools in town on our side? And ain't that a majority in any town?"

Stay tuned.

There also was a health care comment he made .. that becuase he was a POW, and didn't receive healthcare in Hanoi, he understood what lack of healthcare (for veterans) meant in this country.

The McCain (POW) camp addresses all charges and all policy through this prism, as is he is running on the "sumpathy" ticket and people should be sorry and vote for him!

There are many veterans who gave more ... their lives!

McCain seems to have capitalized on his sacrifices and come out rather well ... swapping his wife for a new model and taking advantage of connections! Becaue of his "ambition" to be president as he has admitted.

Leave a comment

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address