« Hillary Pledged Delegate: I'm Backing McCain! | Home | Gallup: Obama's Lead Narrowing »

Obama: If They Bring A Knife, We Bring A Gun

At a fundraiser last night in Philadelphia -- a unity event of sorts, featuring former Hillary-backers Ed Rendell and Michael Nutter -- Barack Obama vowed that he will not be passive in the face of political attacks: "If they bring a knife to the fight, we bring a gun."

Obama has to strike a careful balance between his promises of hope and optimism, against the pitfall of allowing himself to become a political doormat. One benefit of the long primary season is that he learned how to pull that trick off against Hillary Clinton -- and now he can do it against John McCain.

The McCain camp was quick to object: "Barack Obama's call for 'new politics' is officially over."


169 Comments

| Leave a comment

This won't be like all the other recent elections. And it isn't just talk. Barack Obama isn't going to take shit from McCain or his vile cronies.

He know what's coming and he's prepared.

Haven forefend!! Vile Cronies!! Obama will not take any shit from them. LOL

user-pic

Obama is sounding like a gang leader -- if we applied the same standard to his comments that he applied to Hillary's we would claim that Obama was encouraging the crazies.

user-pic

"Gang leader"? Oh, I get it, you mean "black." Because otherwise you'd be saying "general," or "sheriff." I'd say Obama's employing the Powell doctrine here. Please tell me in what Western the sheriff goes after the knife fighter with knives, rather than guns? Guns, in our myth, are the more honest, more honorable instrument.

user-pic

Last time I looked the Hell's Angels weren't black. Too bad that you see everything through the lens of race.

Obama is sounding like a gang leader

Like famed gang leader Sean Connery, you mean?

You know, the sad thing is that this is not true. He handled the Rev Wright stuff awesomely in your opinion I guess!

More importantly, I think that what really matters is how the MSM handles things. So far, at least from my end, does not look good for Obama.

I am thanking the lord that he is running against McCain, I think against someone less feable I think he would be in big big trouble.

user-pic

rzagza says:

"More importantly, I think that what really matters is how the MSM handles things."

Rather than "MSM", I would have said "the Corporate media", either way, you're exactly right. I've been waiting for years for some Democrat being interviewed LIVE on TV to attack the host for irrelevant, or 'gotcha' questions on comments made 30 years ago.

Obama should have said "If they bring a knife to the fight, I'll bring a HOWITZER."

rzagza, I respectfully disagree (and long for the day when we all don't have to be so goddamned "respectful" whenever we think someone's full of it, LOL! :-).

I honestly don't think it matters one whit that Obama's running against a dishonest, corrupt, feeble old fuck with a lot of baggage. That's not how it's done anymore.

They took the ne'er-do-well, entitled, dry drunk, "gentleman's C" son of a family of Nazi corporatists; a guy who not only could not produce soaring, uplifing rhetoric indicative of a great world leader, but who could not even construct a fucking English language sentence, for which he eventually became the subject of national ridicule nightly on Letterman.

And they re-marketed him as the Daddy who would keep decent, hard-working, white Christian Amurcuns safe and warm from those swarthy Muslims.

Why? Because he was the "guy you'd rather have a beer with" (the Pope himself, who died this past week, helped spread THAT one). It never even dawned upon the rubes that if Jesus personally saved him from the bottle... how the hell could you "have a beer with" the little son of a bitch? And The Stupids never even asked!

All this is to say, George W. Bush is the textbook case by which we now know that ANYONE, no matter how weak or inappropriate, can be market through corporate America by Karl Rove and co. as being any goddamned thing they say he is, regardless of how fictitious.

And then you get your 30% hardcore Stupids to vote for him; plus 10% "average" people who simply buy the bullshit, making it 40%; then you vote-suppress minorities and the elderly and Dems in general and simply steal numbers from the Dem column via punch cards and Diebold, to obtain the rest.

And that's how a "weak" Republican candidate sails on a sea of oil to the presidency. So, get off the complacency train, if you know what's good for you. This ain't over.

user-pic

Barry Champlain,

excellent post.

Are you joking? Obama wins in a landslide. What's not going well for him? He's winning women. Hispanics by a large margin. Independents. Republicans are holding their nose for McCain and aren't energized to vote or support him. L-A-N-D-S-L-I-D-E.

Bullshit.

Hey, its the "Chicago Way" - as Sean Connery so succinctly put it in "The Untouchables". Bring a gun to a knife fight indeed: http://youtube.com/watch?v=7g0RLyxP13o

My thoughts exactly. I love this town.

The Lord hates a coward

Ummm, but see the knife is the trap...sean connery's character gets mowed down by a tommy gun...

user-pic

Yeah, that did Capone a lot of good. You people invariably entirely miss the point. It's not the battles along the way. It's who's the last guy standing. And it won't be McOldGuy.

Yep. When I saw the headline I immediately assumed he was referencing "The Untouchables".

He has been amazingly deft at handling attacks. He doesn't usually strike first, but if attacked, his responses are very accurate, focused, and effective. McCain's attacks often seem like flailing by comparison. Imagine this same talent in Obama dealing with foreign policy issues, including attacks of any kind. His response is well thought out and targeted to be effective. By comparison, Bush's campaigning and foreign policy were similar: overkill attacks where the ends justified the means.

It is the way of the Barakarate! Master.

It is BarAkido.

user-pic

Well said.

That's good. Whatever else we do, it is imperative that McCain's views on choice and family planning become as familiar to every American as a McDonald's jingle.

Carpetbagger has the story a bit different, that the repubs are putting the words of a supporter in Obama's mouth...

http://www.thecarpetbaggerreport.com/archives/15876.html

Well they can cry me a river, cry me a river, I'm bringing a gun to their knife fight too . . .

user-pic

Seems to me the jury is still out on whether or not Obama will effectively respond to the Republican slime. He sure didn't punch back with Hillary and he has done little in the face of the opening doses of slime the past two weeks.

I hope he means it because that is the key for Democrats winning the White House: Americans do not respect wimps! When they come at him, Obama has to stand up and break out a case of whoop ass on those assholes. That will seal the deal if Obama actually does it. My fingers are crossed.

user-pic

Excuse me? What he did with Hillary was brilliant - he started using Bill's words against her. His campaign does that again and again - Barakarate.


He was a gentleman with Hillary - he didn't campaign like a Repug like she did.

ROFLMAO!!

Wait, that was snark, right? You aren't serious, surely...

user-pic

He knew that the key to beating Clinton was to get under Bill's skin and psyche him out. Worked brilliantly, and bloodlessly. Why do the hard work when a few words will get the other side to do it for you? And he's already doing it with McStooopid, getting him to keep yelling "You kids get off my lawn or I'll get out my shotgun!" like a raving lunatic, and everyone sees it. By the time he's done with him, I might actually feel sorry for St. John.

Kovie, well stated. McCain's top thug is LIE-berman and Traitor Joe couldn't get elected dog catcher in Connecticut, only Fox News quotes this tired old hack any more.


"Gentleman"???

Being an Obama support means you're automatically delusional but that one really takes the prize.

Funny.

No, pathetic.

No, sad.

He's from the Southside of Chicago - where whoop-ass is produced. I'm not worried one bit.

Yeah! The whoopass cannery is located at Garfield and State. McCain has no idea what he's up against.

No....he's not "from the southside of Chicago"

He's from Honolulu...Where poi is produced.

Be worried.

He's lived in the south side of Chicago longer than he lived in Hawaii. Freaking Indonesia when he lived wasn't exactly a picnic either.

Barack has learned more than enough street-fighting in his travels to take out McCain, who is a much weaker opponent than the democratic challengers Braack has already dispatched.

You haven't been paying attention have you? Obama has been tearing McCain up on everything from Iraq to the economy and Social Security. He has proven himself to be very good on the offense.

And it is pretty naive to try to draw a conclusion on his ability to fight from how he approached going after Hillary, because Hillary was A FELLOW DEMOCRAT, and unlike Hillary, Obama didn't feel it was appropriate to go after a fellow Democrat with the knife.

user-pic

I hope you're right, but frankly, if you think he has been tough on McCain I have to wonder about what you think is tough. Also, you must remember that they haven't even begun their slime campaign and they have no shame whatsoever. We'll know by Labor Day. Any conclusions at this point are way premature.

Exactly, you don't fire off you big guns early. Measured response is the way of Baracakido. It's going to be fun to watch the repugnantcons ratchet up and get creamed at every turn. It's going to come from Barack and it's also going to cone from the 80+% of we the disaffected living here in the trenchs the neoconniving slime have driven America into.

. . . it's also going to come from the 80+% . . .

Comment from a post on TPM on November 2nd, 2008:

"Also, you must remember that they haven't even begun their slime campaign and they have no shame whatsoever."

What we are seeing now is what we will see more of later. It may be re-packaged, coated in new shades of Sh*t. The Obama campaign has put in place a demonstrated mechanism for dealing with the crud. It strikes me as though a new fear mongering technique being tested out by Repugs is the threat of depths they have yet to stink (I mean 'sink') to....

user-pic

I love it.

And of course McLame argues: damned if you don't and damned if you do.

So, did he expect Obama to just take anything he throws? Or his shadow campaign of 527s throws? Dream on McLame.

Humanity_Critic just beat me to it--soon as I read the post I knew exactly where it was from--great movie--still enjoy watching it on cable--that McCain bunch needs to watch more movies AND bravo for Obama. This is the way I used to run campaigns when I did them (though none any where near this level but the principle is the same).

Finally - some bite.

Chicago politics is exactly what we need right now to cleanse our public offices of the Bush administration - and everyone who benefited under it.

McCain's smarmy rhetoric is nothing like he was in 2000 when I voted for him against Bush.

He lost every bit of my respect after he put his arms (and policy positions) around G.W.Bush.

Any man that can tolerate Bush's company after the disgusting smears against his family is a coward - regardless of wartime service.

Pretty interesting that McCain's family smear mentioned something to the effect of an illegitimate black child - and Michele Obama was called a 'baby mama' on a national cable news ticker.

Strange how similar themes repeat themselves in political campaigns. I think these are the 'old politics' everyone is tired of.

Telling people to shove it up their ass when they present themselves like one never gets old.

user-pic

Be careful what you wish for. Mayor Daley has a lot of the same personality flaws as Bush. He's the son of a previous chief executive, dictatorial, inarticulate to the point of aphasia and ruthless.
And Obama needs his help.

user-pic

Amen. I wish more people were aware of that story from 2000, which probably seems like ancient history to many. It would resonate with a lot of people to know that McCain took that racist crap directed at his own wife and child, and still hugged Bush -- literally and politically. Says a lot about McCain on a character level.

Oh right, like the McCain campaign was all set to have a campaign on the issues and now this is throwing them off course, right?

Also, after reading the quote by Obama, I assumed all of the newspapers would have the headline "Black politician threatens to kill us all!!!"

user-pic

Unfortunately, this might be true. People can't get over their racial stereotypes in some places.

Are you one of those "people" ?

I honestly believe that one of the major reasons that Democrats have done so poorly in the presidential elections of the past 30 years (Clinton years excepted) is that they have all too willing to apologize and back down when the Rethugs bring the slime. People may not like Rove/Atwater smear tactics, but they will watch nonetheless to see how the victim responds when attacked. And they will make some fundamental, if unconscious, judgments about them based on their response. So, it's about god-damned time that we had a guy in our corner who didn't take it lying down, didn't turn the other cheek, but rather brought the pain to the perpetrator. Hallelujah. It feels good, doesn't it?

user-pic

I totally agree. The Repugs on the other hand, don't apologize for shit,or at least, I haven't heard many apologies from 'em.

I'm tired of our guys being so damned polite. And I am not worried - Obama has done a better job of campaigning so far than I have seen maybe ever.

"Maybe ever".

Wow. Even better than Mondale, Dukakis, Gore or Kerry?

Impressive.

user-pic

Also, well said. Love your name too.

republicans are a bunch of babies. LOLLLLLL

Race-baiting and white guilt may have worked in the Dem primaries. Republicans don't fall for that shit. I hope the New Democrats have something else up their sleeves.

They don't huh? LOL.

Are you high?

It's what they live & breath.

user-pic

ROFLMAO!!

Wait, that was snark, right? You aren't serious, surely...

Yep he must be joking. "fairy tale", "shuck and jive", and "it took a president", those were all concerted efforts by the Clinton's, when Hillary enjoyed 50%+ black support, to paint Obama as the "black candidate" before the SC primary.

user-pic

They do. I read a few weeks ago that the Obama campaign had hired a researcher. And since McCain is carrying a LOT of baggage and has many things he would rather not be public, he must be worrying. My instinct is that Obama will not make the first blow. He no doubt has plenty of ammunition for that "gun" though.

user-pic

Everything you need to know about McCain: When he crafted a campaign finance reform provision to forbid rides on corporate planes, he added an exemption just in case the corporation that owned the plane was owned by a his wife - or another family member.

Now, if the plane were owned directly by the relative, this wouldn't be much different than a ride in the car. But a corporation is a separate legal person, no matter who holds the stock. McCain is corrupt to the core. He'll be a laughing stock by the end of this. He's another Bob Dole, but without the basic personal integrity.

Good. It's about time he went to war with this neocon-wannabe, flip-flopping, serial adultering scumbag.

Should they respond to the nut case Larry Sinclair? The guy fails a lie detector test and still makes speeches and smears. Stomp him.

This is pretty lame, but I guess this is all the Republicans have. Obama uses a common analogy about fighting fire with fire, and they call it fearmongering and act like he threatened to shoot McCain, the idiots took it literally.

Yet, oddly enough, we weren't supposed to take "Bomb bomb bomb bomb bomb Iran" literally...

You black

A black man(future prez?) making gun references while black youths all across the nation are dying because of guns is TASTELESS.

I can't believe you just said the word "gun" while black youths all aross the nation are dying because of guns.

user-pic

I can't believe you said "gun" when people all over the country are dying because of Republicans.

The GOP would love to have Barack ignore their transgressions, but it ain't happening. Also get another avatar, you insult black people everywhere.

user-pic

You must be an idiot. If you don't respond with some force, people conclude that you are a pussy, and that's that.

Obama's response is EXACTLY correct. The guy has great political instincts.

user-pic

Repukeliscum trolls like you should go away.

You're just a racist troll.

Black, white and brown youths all across the nation are dying because of guns, so don't racialize the issue.
The United States is a society with deep figurative and literal attachment to the gun. Obama's alleged reference - if true - was likely meant to inject some "pop" into the political dialogue, some welcome evidence that the "new" Democrats aren't going to take shit from the bullshitters on the right wing.
While the reference might be unfortunate to some of us, his intended figurative meaning is not so unusual in American dialogue. That being said, I wouldn't be surprised if this turns out to be some Republican dirty tricks - ie putting violent words into the black man's mouth.

user-pic

Another racist troll surfaces.

THis is the perfect response by Obama. Americans do not elect pussies to the presidency. Obama must show that he has the macho ability to win the office.

Peoples' Nasty Boat Songbird People for Truth - on patrol

This summer we won't get caught windsurfing while the enemy deploys

I think a lot of people forget the Obama is a politician from chicago, and he has to know how to play the game and win. Also people keep forgetting that Hillary Clinton is a girl. He couldn't attack her like he can a man so of course hes going to go much harder against McCain. And people seem to forget that Obama isn't a typical democrat, hes not scared to be tough and at the same time be new and fresh, which is why a lot of independents like me who like the toughness of a republican would appreciate someone like Obama. Hes tough, smart, and savvy.

http://sensico.wordpress.com/

The fact that there was no substantive differences between the two meant that the dynamic of the campaign forced the candidates to define themselves almost exclusively on personal differences.

That is a very, very difficult game to play for Barack Obama ...but having done that, Obama, with ample stocks of policy ammunition, will be able to rain a hell of fire on McCain.

If they put one of yours in the hospital, you put one of them in the morgue

user-pic

I find it interesting that people on this thread keep bringing up that it's supposed to indicate something good that Obama is a politician from Chicago when that is one of the primary weaknesses of his that the Republicans will be exploiting in the fall. It will start with Rezko but won't end there. They will do all they can to paint Obama as a quintessential corrupt politician from Chicago and those guys don't have very good reputations around the country ya know. That's actually a big, fat negative to most suburban voters who will, after all, be deciding the election. Perhaps Obama will deftly go after the enemy in response to their character assassination and innuendo, but it really remains to be seen. When you look dispassionately at what we have seen in the primary season there's simply no evidence to indicate one way or another how Obama might "push back" so to speak, if at all. I pray he takes off his coat, rolls up his sleeves and really goes after them hard, but I will believe it when I see it. We've not seen a Democratic candidate do that in many, many years until it was too late. Personally, I think our side should not be waiting, but instead should be going after McCain hammer and tong right now to start putting them on the defensive, but I don't see that on the horizon. Perhaps it is, I just don't see it yet.

user-pic

Yeahbut. The Repugs never seem to remember that people who live in glass houses shouldn't throw stones. And McCain lives in a house of glass. He should be very careful what he or his minions say, or he will find himself living among shards.

user-pic

If you think that Obama didn't "push back" during the primaries then you must have been hiding under a rock or something. Not every counterattack involves a big fat club or an obvious display of aggression. Obama is, whether by nature or design, a master at passive-aggressive counterattack and mental games. He did it to Bill and Hillary, and he's doing it to McCheesy. Don't be so dense. And please be more inventive than to employ the tired and lame "Ooh, I don't know, I'll believe it when I see it, and since I haven't seen it, it hasn't happened". That's SO 6 months ago.

user-pic

I wish I were as easily impressed and naive as you seem to be.

I actually am in politics and have quite a bit of experience duking it out with the forces of evil and successfully so. Obama's fighting back, if you can call it that, thus far has been mild at best and it is quite clear that the only way to fight them successfully is to fight back ferociously, not passive agressively or any other milder form of counterattack. My only point is we haven't seen much fight out of the Obama camp yet, it's nice that he says they will fight but Kerry said that too.

Being from Chicago is a much bigger liability to him in the general than it was in the primary season for reasons stated above and for those who think that the fact that McCain lives in a glass house is of any concern to the Republicans, what planet have you been on the past 30 years? They don't give a damn about that in large part because of the pathetically limpwristed response so many Democrats typically "push back" with. That is why they regularly bitch slap Harry Reid and Nancy Pelosi and the congressional majority. That is why Bush defiantly tramples the Constitution and breaks any law he wishes: because the national Democrats, as a rule, don't fight back. Saying he will bring a gun to a knife fight is nice and I pray Obama does that. I'll believe it when I see it. Haven't seen anything even resembling that level of counterattack from the Obama camp to date.

user-pic

It doesn't occur to you that you win the fight if you get your adversary to self-destruct? Obama maneuvered Clinton into a position where she couldn't help but destroy her campaign. Yet he did so in a way that didn't totally wipe her out, owing that it wouldn't have served him to anger her supporters by fully humiliating her.

He's directly said that he won't similarly hold back for McCain. He'll be sure that the public perceives McCain to have attacked first, and dishonorably. Then he'll be sure that when the dust settles, McCain will be horizontal, Obama without a nick.

user-pic

I've yet to see a single instance in which someone landed an major blow on Obama and he didn't respond convincingly. So far the GOP hasn't been able to make ANYTHING stick on him, and god knows they've tried. Wright, Ayers, "Whitey", Hussein, Muslim, Osama, Madrassah, bittergate, etc. Sure, this cost him some against Hillary, but his OVERALL numbers have not gone down. And Appalachia will not determine this election, as it's too spread out over states that he either won't win anyway, or can win by making it up in other parts of those states.

You know, although I never had much use for him, Reagan was also someone who never really fought back dirty, not openly and directly at least (he was a master at similarly passive-aggressive dogwhistle politics, of course). Instead, he made his opponents underestimate him as first (like Obama), then made them look like fools (Obama) while getting people to like him (like Obama). That's part of why he praised him, in a purely polical sense. Many Democrats seem to have this idea that to win, we need to come out swinging and breathing fire. Well, that was the message sent out by the Edwards and Clinton camps, and we all know how that worked out.

There is a time for open fighting, and a time for finesse and tactics. Most times, it's the latter. And that's precisely what Obama's doing. I think that people who don't buy it are either RW concern trolls who are trying to get Dems to doubt themselves, or lost in the wilderness Dems who are still stuck in the 60's and want to man the barricades and take down the man or something.

Sheesh.

Love this comment. Very astute analysis. Obama has the potential to give McCain a serious ass-kicking in November if he simply follows the game-plan he evidently laid out a long time ago. Barack plays chess while McCain thinks the game is checkers.

user-pic

Wow, can you employ any more lame cliches in one comment? Naive, limp-wristed, bitch-slap, "I'll believe it when I see it", "I've been doing this for 300 years", blah blah blah. You're clearly not a Democrat and all I see here is concern trolling that is intended to psyche out Dems and make them doubt themselves. Old tactics, used to work, won't this time, because it's transparent, and this time based on willful dishonesty.

I.e. because Obama was "limp-wristed" and didn't "bitch-slap" Hillary (nice to see you get in both homophobic AND misogynistic slurs right there--why did you leave out the $400 haircut?), he's a wimp. Um, and WHO won the primaries, has the overwhelming support of his party (Reagan Democrats are not Democrats and any poll that includes them is faulty by design), and has been beating McCain consistently in all the polls? Yeah, real wimp.

Try and establish invalid premises elsewhere. They don't work in the reality-based part of the blogosphere. So far I've seen Obama slam down McCain so hard I almost feel sorry for the old guy, except I don't, cause he's a dishonest asshole who fully deserves to be trounced. The best warriors know that you use the weapons and tactics suited to the task, and you don't need to fire off your big guns when it's not called for, which so far it hasn't been. Show me one instance in which Obama failed to return APPROPRIATE fire to an attack, as opposed to the knee-jerk overcompensating sort of attack that you seem to feel would prove his manhood or something? It's Repubs who do that, and it's finally bitten them in the ass.

I'm not saying that Obama WILL win, but to say that he's in big trouble because he's not Karl Rove is, well, something that pretty much speaks for itself.

It's a metaphor and an epic line from a classic movie - Republicans trying to make any sort of political hay about gun crime and such just expose themselves as desperate fools.

user-pic

Yep, it's a metaphor. Obama is saying he won't be pushed around and I'm glad to hear it.

Jesus, did they pick up Hillary's Obama playbook on E-Bay? ("Surefire Plan for Victory! Only used once!")

First its attacking Obama for being "inexperienced," then its loudly demanding more and more debates, now its piously lamenting his abandonment of the politics of hope everytime he smacks 'em. It's like last January, except this time the opponent is shorter, balder and has no grasp whatsover of policy details.

Well, summer's the time for repeats...

This is going to be a long march to the election if they're just going to recycle everything, though.

Hey gonna vote for Obama in November but to be honest, what has always bothered me by him is his language of "new kind of politics" and Broderesque bipartisanship.

So, in my mind I don't think that:

"piously lamenting his abandonment of the politics of hope everytime he smacks 'em"

really depends on where you are coming from. If Obama is going to just respond vigorously to attacks, then this does not necessarily deviate from his "new kind of politics". But, if he has shown during the primaries, and even against McCain, where he is unleashes his surrogates, but stays semi-neutral himself, then he's gonna reap what he sows.

user-pic

Zactly!

Obama knew he couldn't go after Hillary because in her first Senate race the male opponent ran an aggressive campaign against her and she got all the women in an uproar over it. It seemed like a lot of times he was being dared to do it. McCain is a different story though. After years of the Republicans pushing the Democratic candidate around, it's time for them to be pushed back.

Obama as the General Election Candidate: "Wanna Rumble?"

Quote from a fundraiser, yesterday I believe, in Philly:

“If they bring a knife to the fight, we bring a gun,” Obama said. “Because from what I understand folks in Philly like a good brawl."

Any comments from you guys?

I think it's fab...and the beginning of "Barry" poking his head through the shroud of "Barack."

This is the kind of Trumanesque rhetoric that's going to bring more and more "average folks" onto his bandwagon.

My(non-partisan)Blog: http://ProteanPerspectives.blogspot.com

I say that it is about time for a Democrat to stand up to the bullying tactics that the GOP has tended to employ since '68. At this rate, Obama won't need as fearsome an attack dog as Jim Webb.

All I've got to say is....

"Stand back from the pillar of fire that's gonna rain from on high when Barack unleashes all his oratorical powers and smites the transgressors who dare...transgress the sanctity of his marriage."

Gotta love it! :

www.huffingtonpost.com/john-ridley/do-they-really-want-to...

What the heck happened to my link?

I would love to have seen Obama say this. He sent a clear warning to the GOP. Obama reminds me so much of JFK.

Folks, you gotta read this if you haven't.

McCain: "It's tough to be proud of (America)"

http://www.politico.com/blogs/jonathanmartin/0608/McCain_doesnt_pick_up_on_Michelle_Obama_joke.html

So much for all that hay they were planning to make on Michelle...


This probably deserves it's own blog. It was an obvious gimme set-up question that McCain didn't pick-up on.

Obama and co. certainly won't make an issue of this because it will only highlight Michelle's initial remark but can use it for defensive purposes down the line.

Good point. Keep it in the quiver for now.

Remember that McCain is a bottom one-percenter: he ranked 894th out of 899 in his graduating class at the Naval Academy. While he was likely merely an incurious and inattentive student rather than outright stupid, he is probably nonetheless the dimmest Republican Presidential candidate since Warren G. Harding in 1920, and it is not surprising for him completely to miss the point of even a teed-up softball question.

It certainly will not be the last time that McCain completely misses the point of a question during the campaign. His age-related cognitive decline appears to be accelerating.

Where will a decline from the bottom one percent take him?

I grew up in the shadow of Chicago and I don't think Obama being from there is particularly significant. The history of politics in Illinois is rooted in corruption more than anything else. Our last governor is in prison at this very moment.

More to the point, Obama saw what happened to the Dukakis and Kerry campaigns when they ALLOWED themselves to be defined by their Republican opponents.

I accidently hit "send" on that before I was finished. Anyway, my point is, one of Obama's great strengths is that he can learn from his own mistakes and equally important, he can learn from the mistakes of others.

All he has to do is lay out the truth of neocon failures in an incisive way with a twist of wit. Applause and cheers.

A Democrat who actually has the potential to give back harder than he gets is an utterly new sort of politics. Especially if he can buck everyone up and give the impression that its a group effort and not just the tough guy looking out for all his little nerdlet pals.

user-pic

I like it.

And yes all he really needs to do is run lots of ads of Republicans talking to their own. Cue the scary background music. Voila.

Or possibly Barack-Fu.

user-pic

I think Obama was a little equivocal.

He should have said, "If they want to thumb-wrestle, we will employ NEWCULAR weapons."

And then added, "The streets will flow with the blood of the nonbelievers!"

Ah, maybe that's why he's the nominee and not me.

One thing's for sure, they will not swift-boat him, regardless of the Press Club's heartfelt admiration for and loyalty to McCrazy.

I think the word is, "obliterate".

Well for once it's great to see a democrat who will confront and even attack the fascists rather than do the usual turn & run thing!! Now if the dems will only get out and vote or better yet take advantage of absentee voting!!

Maybe some day we'll have significant others aside from republicans who turn out in large numbers to vote - that's of course how they win, no big secret, they are no majority but hey they do get off their asses & vote.

In his speech on race, he quotes William Faulkner.
http://www.themillionsblog.com/2008/03/obama-and-faulkner-quote.html
And now, he's quoting David Mamet.

As far as I'm concerned, that's two for two.

08AMA

user-pic

In case you didn't know:

Mamet's new work: Why I am no longer a brain-dead liberal
By David Usborne 13 March 2008 Independent
The left-wing literati of London and New York were surely in a stew last night after one of their leading and most loyally liberal lights, David Mamet, confessed that advancing years have given him a greater appreciation for things conservative.

David Mamet: Why I Am No Longer a 'Brain-Dead Liberal'
An election-season essay

by David Mamet
March 11th, 2008 Village Voice

user-pic

He was in Pennsylvania--a state that he lost in the primary--flanked by at least one high-ranking (former) supporter of Clinton (Rendell).

Quote:

He warned that the general election campaign could get ugly. “They’re going to try to scare people. They’re going to try to say that ‘that Obama is a scary guy,’” he said. A donor yelled out a deep accented “Don’t give in!”

“I won’t but that sounded pretty scary. You’re a tough guy,” Obama said.

“If they bring a knife to the fight, we bring a gun,” Obama said. “Because from what I understand folks in Philly like a good brawl. I’ve seen Eagles fans.”

Endquote, bitch.

So there's the context and the full quote that was entirely f---king absent from this report, thank you very much, Eric.

To be honest, I don't see how the context changes anyhows, other than that it insintuates that Philadelphia sports fans are belligerant doucebags!

gonna be a butt kickin

more like a butt whoping, I think

nope, gonna be a butt kickin, gonna pull his pants down and kick him all the way across the turnip patch

user-pic

It is about time the Dem's brought some hard ass testerone into the battle.

user-pic

Oh, and BTW, I am aching to see those townhall-style meetings that McInsane keeps whining for. 5, 10 whatever. Little Mac is going to get his butt KICKED. Decisively. Unlike Mac, Obama can speak off the cuff; he has tons of data available at all times. That's the difference between being both prepared and highly intelligent (Obama) and being slightly senile and coached. I really really want to see Mac lose his cool. He's famous for it.

A surprisingly poor choice of words.

user-pic

Perhaps. I figure Obama is using off the cuff colorful yet belligerent imagery to assure the audience that he's tough. It's good to hear a dissenting voice though.

By the way, your avatar is inducing an Eraserhead quality dis/comfort. Sweet lucid dreams.

Best bring two guns, a sawed-off shotgun and an Uzi.

Obama, you make me proud to be a democrat right now! It's about damn time we had an intelligent man running.
Didn't McOld get the NRA endorsement? Didn't Huackabee make a job ducking gunfire in one of those meetings?

McCain is in for a good ass whooping!
Let's make sure we volunteer to register people. Obama has to win!!

Black man with a gun.

Nice stereotype right there.

Politics as usual. First it's decry the influence of money whole spend and taking in the largest sums in history.

Now it's "new politics" that include reference to attack and counter-attack with lethal metaphors.

Meet the new boss, same as the old boss. Won't get fooled again.

Black man with a gun.

Nice stereotype right there.

Politics as usual. First it's decry the influence of money while spending and taking in the largest sums in political history.

Now it's "new politics" that include reference to attack and counter-attack with lethal metaphors.

Meet the new boss, same as the old boss. Won't get fooled again.

user-pic

Black man with a gun? I'm thinking state trooper or Texas Ranger. What kind of boogeyman is living under your bed?

Money in politics? I'm glad it's the first time lowly me has been able to contribute. I hope it pays off.

Lethal metaphors? Now I really feel unsafe. Bomb bomb bomb bomb Iran.

It's all in your head fogu2.

Fogu is afraid of Black people.

user-pic

Either that, or afraid his candidate is going to lose ... >:-}

My candidate already lost.

Yours will next.

Ha! Playground humor. :)

user-pic

Maybe he should paint his toenails pink and recite policy papers in iambic pentameter. That always wins us elections.

Bored now.

user-pic

Where are all you RACIST TROLLs coming from? What is this, International KKK OUT day or something?

Black guys in the US, you racist ass, are allowed to have guns same as whites. They're also, you racist troll, allowed to use sensible metaphors.

Black man with a gun.

Nice stereotype right there.

___________________________________________________________________

Yeah. YOUR stereotype.

Yes, Fogu, obviously Obama was referring to little Annie Oakley - Hillary as VP candidate is a done deal.

user-pic

Politics as usual. First it's decry the influence of money whole spend and taking in the largest sums in history.

No, not "money." Lobbyist money. MY money and YOUR money are still good.

Now it's "new politics" that include[s] reference to attack and counter-attack with lethal metaphors.

Oh, pookie-bear. Is this the first political campaign you've had an interest in?

user-pic

Obama needs to establish himself with the voting public as the Alpha Male v.s. McCain. What he's doing and saying here is the right thing to do and say.

Let the Republicans complain. In fact, the more they complain the better. They do not look tough compalaining about the big bad mean Democrat.

Alpha males don't complain; they attack.

user-pic

Heh, didn't Howard Wolfson say the same thing after he naively thought that he'd baited Obama into abandoning his campaign of hope and thus knocked him off his pedestal? Yeah, that worked. And now McCain is trying the same thing? Man is this guy stupid.

Or maybe he just wants us to think he's stupid, bwahahahahahaha!

user-pic
And now McCain is trying the same thing?

Its yet another thing McCain has in common with Bush. If something is proven not to work, you keep doing it over and over again. The only question in this case is: which one of McCain's supporters makes money off of it.

user-pic

Yeah, that did Capone a lot of good. You people invariably entirely miss the point. It's not the battles along the way. It's who's the last guy standing. And it won't be McOldGuy.

user-pic

This was supposed to be a response to bravo6, who made the totally besides the point observation that the Sean Connery character in The Untouchables, who said this line, got mowed down. But the got Capone, which was the whole point of the movie!!!

To me it's clear what Obama is saying: "Cindy's, shall we say, history," is not "off the table."

the media's incessant and rabid attacks upon hillary will make their colorist and racist atacks upon michelle obama even worse!!!

oppressions are contagious...

and the race card has yet to be fully played by the republikkkans!

fyi
alicia banks
OUTLOOK
aliciabanks.blogspot.com

"The Lord hates a coward." Connery says.

That's to all of us. Buckle up, boys and girls. We're about to go up against a fighter pilot and street brawler.


user-pic

Now Joe Lieberman and Norm Podhoretz can commiserate about how the scary black man threatened them

yeah i saw the mccain video on
http://sensico.wordpress.com/ mccain is kindof a hypocrite and so is his wife for going after michelle on the issue.

What a brilliant statement. The VRWC will be parsing that one for a week or remain stonily silent. Either way we win!

user-pic

McCain the dimmest Republican Presidential candidate since Warren G. Harding, FMArouet21? I'd probably reserve that characterization for the incurious, incompetent, inflexible, and inexcusable George Dubya. At least if you explain stuff to McCain he gets it. It has to be explained, but there you have it. This is as opposed to Dubya, who is steeped not only in an incuriousness as vast and deep as a rock canyon wall, but who cannot and will not accept any perception different from his own.

As for Barack bringing a gun, good. For years I've sat and watched the Dems backing off, equivocating, and being the polite kid trying to reason with the bully. Most Americans don't understand equivocation and mannered discourse. When someone gets up in an average American's face and disses him his opponent tries to give back as good as he gets. It's like what Jim Webb wrote about what he learned from his father. Never start a fight, but when you fight, even if you lose, make sure to mark your opponent so he'll remember that you marked him the last time he messed with you. Works for me.

At least if you explain stuff to McCain he gets it.

Until he forgets it. Or flips and flops over an issue as his appearances du jour require.

btw, the "knife .. gun" line (from The Untouchables indeed) has been used by that other Chicago politician, Rahm Emmanuel. Another D with balls.

Really tiny balls.

user-pic

Well, he helped deliver a Democratic majority in the House in Nov. 2006, so I am on record as being satisfied with the size of his testicles!

Lowered expectations. The perfect Obamanite quality.

user-pic

Nope. Controlling a branch of government is a *high* expectation, douchebag.

What Rahm helped deliver were Bluedog Democrats, the Bush enablers, and focused the party on compromise and sure things.

The Netroots crowd fought out the new turf, the iffy seats, put the unthinkable in play and won a few surprises. They've been marginalized this round - the Obama movement doesn't want competitors, the only game in town. We'll see how it plays.

Barack's remark reflects his political origins in the crime-ridden cesspool of American politics -- the South Side of Chicago.

It's the kind of thing one would expect to hear from Michelle, the street thug who became a Harvard-trained lawyer via affirmative action.

user-pic

Nice that you're so terrified of Michelle. Man, if the teenage black girls (i.e., before she went to Princeton) scare you, you really are a coward!

Also, while Chicago's had its share of corrupt politicians, they weren't from the South Side - unless you're thinking of all those famous blacks and Jews who've dominated Chicago's government all these long decades? Such as ... who?

You've got your sides mixed up. Historically, the most corrupt parts of the city were the down town and the west sides where the legendary Vito Marzullo regularly delivered 99% of his ward's registered voters for the Cook County machine. The Irish and Italians controlled the machine and "permitted" a few blacks at "the table." Obama's home, Hyde Park, is a bastion of good government types(googoos in machine parlance).

I worked several independent Democratic campaigns in Illinois and had some first hand experience in machine election day tricks. The Cook County machine aint what it used to be. I always got a kick out of listening to people complain about the Chicago machine. Downstate Republicans were just as crooked. I grew up in suburban Chicago. When I was a kid, my Mother wanted to vote for JFK in the primary...she was told that they didn't have any Democratic ballots. George Ryan, the Govenor who's now in jail, is a Repbulican from Downstate.

Obama finally shows his true colors. Tough talk, but the wrong words.

Say goodbye to Obambi! Love hearing a Democratic Presidential candidate quoting from The Untouchables! Finally!

Thug? Wrong words? Come on, some of you need to calm down, pay attention, and get in touch with your subjunctive side. He said "IF they bring a knife to the fight, we bring a gun." So it's NOT the end of new politics, UNLESS the repubs first "bring a knife" to the fight. If they don't, Obama's new politics (i.e., decent and effective advocacy) is in force. But IF the 71-year-old does decide to feebly flail a dull shiv around, in that case Obama will go him one better.
So is the American public going to get respectful dialogue, or gutter politics? The choice is McCain's to make (and I think you all know how he and his handlers will choose). Voila, the opponent's force is used against him. Which is, as the British like to say, Brilliant!
BarAikido, even. (hat tip AMK)

Keep using code words to denote "black" and "thug" and your fellow Republicans and "independents" like Traitor Joe will applaud you.

Oh, I get it, you mean "black."
Keep using code words....


Puh-leaze. Here we go again: You don't like The Dear Leader, you're a racist. And by God, we 'bots will take synthetic offense at any word you use, to prove it.

Freakin' kool-aid drinking racists.

Freakin' kool-aid drinking losers.

user-pic

So when McCain gets all in a tizzy when Obama surrogates use the word "confused" to desbribe him, and cries "ageism," isn't your candidate also playing the code word game?

user-pic

desbribe = describe

Connery's quote,courtesy of IMDB http://www.imdb.com/title/tt0094226/quotes

You wanna know how to get Capone? They pull a knife, you pull a gun. He sends one of yours to the hospital, you send one of his to the morgue. *That's* the *Chicago* way! And that's how you get Capone. Now do you want to do that? Are you ready to do that? I'm offering you a deal. Do you want this deal?

user-pic

McCain needs to get smarter trools.

I think he has shown that he's very prepared for anything, his tactics are smart, not blatant in your face defense but sharp and stealth offense. He definitely learned from the Wright debacle and the whole Hillary thing.

user-pic

If only he would sound as tough against Iran and North Korea as he does against McCain. Maybe if he promised to bow up on Mahmoud Ahmadinejad like he did on Joe Lieberman he'd have a chance.

user-pic

Yes, "sounding tough" is working so well for Bush... by all means, let's imitate him.

user-pic

...and how many terrorist attacks have taken place in the US since 9/11?

user-pic

Not the only metric, douchebag. How many of our allies have been attacked? London? Madrid? Do I need to go on?

If we continue the "We weren't attacked, so fuck the rest of the world" line of thinking, instead of the traditional NATO "An attack on you is an attack on us" theme, then we can't be surprised when all members of the so-called "Coalition of the Willing" desert us and leave only Americans to die in Iraq. Shit, even Britain is leaving -- our "good friend," as Bush put it in a State of the Union speech with Blair in the audience.

user-pic

...and how many terrorist attacks have taken place in the US since 9/11?

First of all: You have no idea why this is. Even though there are thousands of competent domestic intel and counter-intel people working on this, every time some Bush crony announces a big bust (usually with politically motivated timing), it turns out the people busted were fairly harmless clowns.

Second of all: If you're going to attribute it to Bush's policies, then you also should attribute 9/11 itself to Bush. It happened on his watch, right? He ignored the warnings.

What Bush and all his tough talk has done is create a global terrorist's recruiting dream.

And let me tell you, I have a good friend who imports many, many containers into Newark, NJ, and he can't explain why there's been no second big attack. Either port security has stuff going on that we'll never know about, or terrorists just don't have the ability.

Has Bush shown one thing that really leads you to believe he's competent enough to be responsible for either one? All he's done is make life tougher for our own security people.


Leave a comment

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address