« Rove: Obama Is The Type Of Guy Who Hangs Out At Country Clubs | Home | Top McCain Adviser Charlie Black Regrets Saying Terror Attack Would Help Campaign »

McCain Distances Himself From Top Adviser's Claim That Terror Attack Would Help McCain

John McCain is rapidly distancing himself from a claim by senior adviser Charlie Black that a terror attack on the United States would help McCain in political terms.

Here's McCain at a presser today, responding to a question about his top adviser, who rather bluntly told Fortune magazine that the assassination of Benazir Bhutto "helped" McCain and added that a terror attack on U.S. soil "would be a big advantage" to McCain...

"I strenuously disagree," McCain said.

The funny thing about this is that while this is obviously a hideously tasteless gaffe for McCain's top adviser to make, the notion that a terror attack would help Republicans is something that's seen as perfectly routine when pundits argue it.

This odious argument somehow isn't seen as crude or distasteful when "disinterested" observers say it, which is bizarre, even putting aside the fact that it's probably outright wrong, given the multiple polls finding that the GOP's advantage on national security has long since evaporated.


55 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

I hope he gets pressed hard on this. It shows how Republicans plan on using fear to win.

user-pic

What an idiot Black is! Now we can say it, when necessary, because the cat is out of the bag.

We always knew these guys counted on terror to elect them ever since 9.11. But this fool said it!

YESSSSSSS. What an unpatriotic piece of garbage.

user-pic

it really does seem like an accidental revealing of the game plan

user-pic

No, more like an idiot stating an obvious fact. Just like casulties and bombings would help Obama's numbers...doesn't mean he wants it to happen...just a fact of the numbers.

user-pic

forgot the in Iraq part.

Creepy.

Sarge get over yourself. Be an American.

user-pic

I don't disagree with you but don't you have to have a screw loose to say it?

user-pic

If your an advisor to a campaign and speaker to a reporter?...Yes.

Memo

To: My Friends in the Media

From: John McCain

Re: Charlie Black

Who the heck is Charlie Black?

All Aboard The Straight Talk Express!

user-pic

We have to make it clear to McCain and the rest of the Republicans that terrorist attacks on or from this country, like a bombing campaign against Iran are election losing propositions.

user-pic

Won't be hard to communicate, they're probably tapping our phones and reading our mail already.

Oh, grow up. They definitely will if you keep working to get McCane in office.

Of course the Republicans rely on keep the voters too scared to think for their selves.

What do you think the Tom Ridge Color Swatches Cabaret was all about.


I still have my supply of Duct tape and Visquine sheets. Thanks to Tom Ridge we are feeling very safe and secure here at Camp Paranoia.

edit: rely on keeping

user-pic

These idiots are so delusional as to think that if, say Bush bombed Iran, people would rally around McCain. Kristol Was fantasizing about it on Fox news Sunday. Probably just delusional daydreaming on his part but sadly I wouldn't put it past Bush to bomb Iran before he leaves office, possibly before the election. The question is just weather or not him and his clique see how bad of an idea it really is.

But seriously, a bombing campaign would be the end of the republicans for good. Or at least a long-ass time.

McCain must immediateley denounce and reject this guy and sever all ties. IMMEDIATELY!
Black is a SENIOR ADVISER, not some loosely affiliated supporter. Let's see if the media treats McCain the way they would Obama if a similarly ranked adviser of his had said it.

I'm sure they'll be all over it just like those rape "jokes" or the John Hagee dust up.

Idiotic question in the first place. Just like it's absurd for pundits to opine that a terrorist attack would help McCain (which I disagree with), it's also a tasteless question to ask. Then when the advisor loses his mind and actually answers it, the media jumps all over him. The whole thing is stupid.

btw -- I also must laugh if Black thinks that Bhutto's assassination helped McCain. If they actually believe that, it helps explain why their campaign is a bit of a mess: They don't have a clue. Hope they keep up the good work!


user-pic

Considering that the Madrid bombings in 2004 helped kicked the conservative government out and the bin laden tape in November, 2004 didn't help Kerry, it's a reasonable question to ask. You just don't expect him to answer so honestly.

The Spanish government willfully misled the public, which sealed their fate. And I don't believe for a second the Bin Laden tape affected the election in 2004. I worked my butt off for Kerry, but he never really had much of a shot at pulling it out.

I wouldn't discount the possibility that Bhutto's assassination helped McCain. Recall that last year, McCain was given up for dead in the GOP primaries, with Giuliani the front-runner and Mitt Romney (in part because he was largely self-financed) seen as the most obvious anti-Rudy challenger. Recall that McCain needed loans to stay afloat, and he indeed opted in-without-opting in

Arguably McCain won more because the others lost, but the perception among Republicans that McCain is strong on foreign policy certainly helped him survive, and the Bhutto assassination in December brought foreign policy more to the forefront of the campaign.

user-pic

Yes, but at best, that says it helped McCain relative to other Republicans. Even if it's true, a campaign strategist who believes that automatically means it helps in the general election is incompetent. (Granted, that does seem like an accurate description of McCain's campaign staff, but...)

Uh oh. Time to throw another barbecue.

I'm sorry, but to keep this guy on as a senior adviser is ridiculous. This is McCain's "out" with Black and he should use it to kick him to the curb and send a strong message. Get out from under his lobbyist ties without having it be an issue.

mccain knew about this guy along time ago and he is not sincere in his response

http://sensico.wordpress.com/2008/06/23/mccain-to-host-a-new-reality-game-show/

Breaking:

Turdblossom declares that Barack Obama is actually a White Anglo Saxon Protestant(WASP) Man, because that is the type that is usually found in Country Clubs.

Greggie. With a straight face can you seriously take time in your post on your disgust with campaigns AND commentator at sdiscussing qui bono from pre-election terrorist attacks to point out that in your personal opinion the predictions are most likely mistaken?

I'm thrilled that McCain is taking heat for a dumb, RFK-in-June-like comment from his top guy. But as you say, this is standard-order contingency thinking that any campaign manager would be committing professional misconduct not to do (although not talk about in public, at least in this way). And if the campaigns have license to think it through, then commentators certainly are within their mandate to do it.

Again, great that the guy was such a moron about it. But what's with the (I hope) fake innocentce about it?

Terrorism is part of God's plan to drive voters into the McCain promised land!

Boy if these numbnuts think that a terrorist attack will help the War Party of George W. Bush, they're in deeper doo than I had thought

I actually disagree with Black's assessment. The republicans have had 8 years to do something abotu the 'war on terror' and they have pretty much done very little besides make lots of knee-jerk induced headaches at the airport for travellers. The only think good that the republicans have managed to do over the last 8 years has been to prevent another attack (and I am not entirely sure that isn't just dumb luck). If another one were to occur, they would have basically failed on every account.


I can see where Black would think this would help, especially since McCain's only real advantage is in Nat's Security. However that doesn't mean he is right and I think that people are very suspicious of this kind of stuff coming out of the Repubs these days. Manufacture a war for political purposes??? No - not these guys....

umm....
"The only think good that the republicans " should be - "The only good thing that the republicans..."

Need. Edit. Function.

user-pic

Is that sort of like Demi Moore "strenously objecting" in A Few Good Men?

Obama needs to nail him to the wall on this. Enough of this fearmongering crap.

The only thing Black's comment was missing was specific targets. $5 says that if he kept on talking, he would've mentioned Ohio, Penn., Florida, and Michigan as possible targets. Since they're trying to scare up votes, might as well make the electoral math count. Idiots...

The real question, as Greg suggests, is whether the public would rally round the flag, as ususal, or ditch the republiks wholesale. This time, for once, I think the answer is that voters would exile the rethugs once and for all, since another attack, especially on our soil, would effectively destroy the only semi-lucid argument in favor of republiks at this point - no foreign attacks on US soil since 9/11 (and anthrax?).

But we won't have to speculate much longer, since I fully expect Bush-McCain to do something totally provocative just prior to the election - whether it's blowing up Iran or a continental US target. The neocon-petroleum-military-crony complex simply has too much invested in Iraq and the rest of the neighborhood to just let the dems get elected and disassemble their little project without a fight.

user-pic

"But we won't have to speculate much longer, since I fully expect Bush-McCain to do something totally provocative just prior to the election - whether it's blowing up Iran or a continental US target. The neocon-petroleum-military-crony complex simply has too much invested in Iraq and the rest of the neighborhood to just let the dems get elected and disassemble their little project without a fight."
...and speculators in the "Tin Foil Hat" market go wild!

Wouldn't be the first time McShame betrayed his country

Won't be the last

http://www.usvetdsp.com/gifs/mcaincuban.jpg

user-pic

Make your fortune in the Tin Foil market...I did...find out how...

Anything you say Corporal Pyle


Fighting soldier from the sky...

Sgt Barry Sadler, Ballad of the green berets
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=LH4-tOqLH94

user-pic

So what's FISA if not a capitulation to fearmongering? I can see why they'd keep using the same strategy as long as we keep enabling it to work.

BREAKING!

WASHINGTON (AP) -- U.S. Secretary for Homeland Security Michael Chertoff just announced the increasing of the national security threat code to "a deep red, almost black."

Chertoff said the ratcheting up of the alert code was prompted by intelligence chatter indicative of a diminishing chance of a Republican White House after 2009 and of significant Republican losses in Congress.

"Oh, fuck! I think that was the classified part," Chertoff added. "Can I go off the record retroactively?"


GREG, CAN U DO US A FAVOR AND PUSH THIS???

GOD KNOWS THAT THE MEDIA WOULD GO F-IN BIZZERK IF AXELROD HAD SAID IT!!! come on!!! don't let them get away wiht ANOTHER ONE! the CONTEXT is CLEAR!!!

He looks like he's losing his bearings.

user-pic

I don't know that a terrorist attack would be good for the Republicans, but I imagine it would be good for Charlie Black. Isn't he on the Saudi payroll?

Charlie we are not supposed to be telling our little secrets, remember! Geeze, some guys just cannot keep a secret. The GOP is all about mis-information and lies, remember. Hey, its been working well for the last 8 years now.

Obama should hit him on this - I mean McCain goes after his VP vetter for crying out loud.

Charlie Black is absolutely correct.

user-pic

Memo to SFC Wallace: Is that a government computer you're using when you put the logo of the 7th Cav up there? You might want to be a bit more careful. I don't doubt that you serve proudly -- but as a former Marine -- what you're doing makes me wince.

So Hillary's referencing to Bobby Kennedy was said to be a dog whistle to her lunatic fringe supporters but McCain gets a pass when his top adviser is hoping for a terrorist attack because it would help John McCain?

I'm telling you, McCain can do no wrong with the press.

Sorry Gramps, your campaign is imploding.

Anybody notice the band-aids on top of McCain's head during this press conference?

I don't mean to be crude... But I haven't heard anyone mention it and they were very visible.

Has his cancer returned?

Jonze- exactly. While some have been busy bashin Obama, Mccain has said many things that the press should have crucified him for. Like for ex: the roevswade statement that he would overturn it and many other gaffes. I think this one is a biggie and he and Black should be held accountable for this. Greg- I urge you to push this story hard. NO MORE FEARMONGERING. sick of it!!!!!!!!!

I wouldn't put it past Bush to "accidentally" let one slip (again) in order to bail out McCain's poll numbers:

http://www.thepersonalispolitical.com/2008/06/terrorist-attack-mccains-miracle.html

If McSame is going to win this election, he will need a land invasion from Viet Nam.

Black only "regrets" that what he said was damaging to McSame; he doesn't regret the underlying sentiment, which is just continued evidence that the Repugs are all too happy to play politics with Americans' lives.

Leave a comment

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address