« Hillary's Subdued Fundraising Email | Home | Hillary Holding A Public Event Today, After All »

Hillary Wins Indiana, Networks Say

It's official: Hillary will hang on to a victory, such as it is, in Indiana. MSNBC and Fox just called it for her.

With 99% reporting, Hillary wins it 51%-49%.

Given the magnitude of Obama's North Carolina victory, this falls far short of the split decision that the Hillary camp was hoping, at a minimum, to achieve tonight.

And it's not even a big enough win for the Hillary campaign to use in continuing to try to raise doubts about Obama's ability to compete in big states, either.

Right now, the pledged del count overall, from both states tonight, breaks down this way: Obama gets 80; Hillary gets 77; and 30 are still up in the air, more of which are likely to go to him.

Upshot: Just as tonight's popular vote gains for Obama effectively wiped out Hillary's gains from Pennsylvania, so, too, will his pledged del gains likely wipe out hers from the Keystone State.


123 Comments

| Leave a comment

Hillmentum!

Fox called it:


Rush Limbaugh Wins Indiana by 7%!

Way to go, fat boy!

How unfair of Clinton to over-ride the
election fraud going on in Gary.

Oh...BUMMER!!!

user-pic

Indiana - a clear win for Obama. Clinton needs about 60% of the delegates remaining in order to even make a good showing against Obama. Anything less is a victory for Obama since it puts him closer to getting the nomination.

Therefore, Indiana was a win for Obama since it got him closer to the nomination - and even increased the % of remaining delegates Clinton needs in order to become competetive.

Clinton could "Win" all the remaining states with the same margin as she "won" in Indiana and Obama would lock up the nomination.

He shoulda won by 8! (Which he predicted) Ind. is in his backyard. HE LOST dimwit.

She won via the Limbaugh vote.

co-sign.

Yep, now she can't even claim a consolation victory. Well, she made that bed.

To me, this raises the interesting question of whether Indiana still matters or not. I'm guessing it does, but just barely.

Just barely. And it doesn't count if you subtract Operation Chaos.

user-pic

Folks, even if Operation Chaos was the deciding factor, let's not make it a talking point. It looks like we're making excuses, which we don't need to do.

user-pic

Detox time?

Hillary hangs on.....by her fingernails.

and so it goes

Obama lost by 2 lousy points.

Oh, well.

It's over for her.

Who will continue to fund this?

Who really believes she can do anything but tear down our nominee?

Can we start to heal the party now?

Can we start to focus on McCain now?

What the hell are we going to do with her? What does Obama give her, if anything?

user-pic

I think it is actually less than 2 points. Really, really close. A loss actually given she was expected to win handily.

intimidation tactics, like what you are using now, won't lead to party healing.
So do you want to let the democratic process continue to play out, or do you want to intimidate it to a halt. In which case, much of the party will break off.
Unsavory tactics by our unifier has successfully divided this party like never before.

*clap, clap, clap* Congratulations, Obama. You have, once again, bounced back and defied expectations. What more is there to say?

"I am pleased to accept my party's nomination for President of the United States."

Factoring in a few percentage points for Operation Chaos, it really isn't a win. It's a loss.

Obama is the nominee. At long last.

user-pic

This won't even be in the papers tomorrow, it broke at 1AM.

Hillary won Indiana like she won Guam or Texas.

It's a virtual tie, which is a loss- a huge one coupled with NC.

It's. Over.

Except, of course, that Obama won in Guam.

user-pic

And, except of course, that Obama won Texas, too.

And it's not even a big enough win to allow the Hillary campaign to credibly continue to raise doubts about Obama's ability to compete in big states, either.

They didn't "credibly" raise doubts about Obama's ability to compete in big states before tonight, either. Have you read Josh's piece on why Hillary's attempts to extrapolate from primary results to general election results were thoroughly bogus?

http://talkingpointsmemo.com/archives/190967.php


user-pic

So, using Slate's Delegate Calculator (http://www.slate.com/id/2185278/), if she continues, we can project that she would need to win about 85% of the remaining votes, plus a little, to tie Obama in pledged delegates.

At what point does this get ridiculous, if it hadn't already been there? Time for her to take a nice long vacation at the spa.

It's All O-VER!

Polls weren't the greatest in indiana & north carolina..... they were far off.....

Let's see if they do any better in the up coming contest.....


Zogby was quite good, pointing out a 14 point difference in North Carolina and a 2% win for Obama in Indiana, which is pretty accurate if you factor out most of the Limbaugh effect.

Mark beat me on the same thoguht too. I promise I wrote mine before them, I'm just a slower typist :)

Zogby had a good night and for once SUSA not so much

GMTA jess, see my post 2 mintues later. I type slower.

Zogby was the best of the pollers for the night.

He had Obama at +14 in NC, Obama wins by +15. Only PPP had it in double digits and Survey USA at 5 missed it by 10 points.

He had Obama +2 in IN, Clinton wins by +2, within the margin, and nowhere near the Survey USA number of 12 points for Clinton.

Zogby even did pretty good in Indiana if you figure in the Limbaugh effect... He nailed the race pretty closely, at least amongst Democrats.

Ahh the deafening silence from Goatlife and Crapweaver lmao. I am anxious to see how the Hillary people try to pervert mathematics after this one. All those fence sitting superdelegates need to be typing up their endorsement letters now to fax to the press in the morning.

I couldn't have said it better myself.

user-pic

they are republican trolls, not real hillary supporters. it's their troll version of operation chaos.

now they are strategizing what mean-spirited things they can do in the general election

Yes, but we haven't seen idiotic yet either!

by saying big states next to home state does not count

ha ha

Man I wish I could say without ambiguity it was over, however, something tells me she will keep dragging that carcass of a campaign down the road

I have my doubt as well. Of course, considering her canceling her TV appearances and then her less-than-optimistic letter to her supporters, one can't help but wonder where she goes from here...

user-pic

she'll be "in it" as far as all public comments from her camp until the exact minute she drops out

It would be best for Obama if she stays in until May 20th.

Obama is going to lose West Virginia big next week, and it'd be embarrassing if he lost it to a candidate who had dropped out.

I'm curious whether HRC will contest the flagrantly dubious results in Lake County, or if she'll pull an Al Gore and concede. The locals expected Gary would certainly be fudged (it always is) but that Hillary would win IN by double digits.

I hope she fights for it, of course.

user-pic

Only if its enough to counter the Limbaugh effect. If she draws to much attention to the mechanics, people will soon be saying that she picked up 7% from Limbaugh.

If she draws to much attention to the mechanics

The "mechanics" were clearly highjacked in Lake County. That's fraud, which is illegal.

Ironic how Obama was the one who stole the nomination, not Clinton.

So, you are claiming that if Hillary won IN by 3-4% instead of 2%, this would have changed the entire narrative?

Quit your whining and crying and get behind the nominee.

Quit your whining and crying and get behind the nominee.

No, you're actually going to have to earn my vote, brewmn61.

I actually think the Republicans deserve the credit for Obama's win in IN. Lots of evidence to suggest that.

I also think Clinton might concede today.

Wow, what an exhilarating and amazing night.
Certainly, the icing on the cake would have been a squeaker win in IN, but I love the results nonetheless. The writing is on the wall. We have our nominee. No talk of HRC as VP, please. Let's just savor this moment instead.

Lets all stay calm and listen to both speeches urging reconciliation and focus on November. This is over. Hillary's "fundraising" email is proof enough. She will probably go through Kentucky, then there will be a pause, before she starts backing Obama strong. She will end up being leader of the Senate. She will be great in this role as the Dems have needed a policy pitbull for years and that fits her to a T. If we all are smart, we will kiss and make up and Obama will be president.

user-pic

Well there needs to be a good cop and a bad cop to get things done. Does the bad cop normally get the lead position?

user-pic

Can we start bashing McCain now?

Absolutely. McBush is the target now.

I'm pretty sure she is broke.

McCain really is the real target now. Let's focus on him, 100%. No need to continue to even talk of Hillary in comparison to Obama.

user-pic

I hope this is over. I hope that Hillary can see the writing on the wall. But I've been fooled before. I'm just assuming she's taking it all the way to the convention unless I hear the words "I concede" directly from her lips. And even then, I'll check to make sure she hasn't crossed her fingers.

Got to give some HRC fans some due, on TLC a blog I admired greatly at one time and still do through the filter of avoiding some of their frankly blind bloggers, Steve Soto was class and even he sees the writing on the wall.

She is taking the day off today after this, reportedly. She can go win in West Virginia and Kentucky now if she likes, but she may be reassessing the value of that. If Obama should lose in November, she can still run in 2012 if she does not now demolish the party in a cavalier way. Running any more just for the sake of running, knowing full well that one cannot plausibly win? That may not be worth the long-term damage to herself.

She can and will take those 2 States, but there's not reallya point anymore. She's going to be taking bad press from here on out. And her money problems will be plaguing her big time. Not to mention the increasing flow of SuperDels to the Obama camp.

No bright days ahead for Hillary. Time to exit, stage left.

My mum just rang from UK and was just a bit happy. She is American and in 70s was deeply invested in the feminist movement. She felt disillusioned & betrayed by HRC. Tonight was the first time my mum sounded relieved.

By the way, where is Gotnolife in all this? I thought our gal was going to win both states, delivering a hammering blow in the Hoosier state?

Hmm? No time to go mute, Gotnolife!

user-pic

Time to kick rethuglican behind.

Finally!
~

You had to (almost) feel sorry for Lanny Davis on CNN, where he was reduced to saying, "Yeah, but if you count Michigan and Florida ..."
He knows it's over, but until Hillary herself concedes as much, he has to spout the official Clinton line.
Hopefully, a slew of superdelegates will screw up their courage tomorrow and signal that the primary race is no longer in doubt.
This was her last, desperate shot. She fell far short.
I don't see her appeal for renewed donations having any resonance; maybe she can coast till June on the off-chance that Obama gets hit by a bus, but that's all she's got left.

Lanny Davis deserves no sympathy. He was the hachet man pushing the Wright story even when it had died down.

user-pic

I remember Lanny Davis and Joe Lieberman and Ned Lamont.

I'm not ready to make nice. Amd I probably never will be.
~

I agree.Some of these jerks think that character assassination is OK, even against a member of their own party.

They need to do penance, or be banned from positions of authority within the party.

Lanny Davis deserves about as much sympathy as Grover Dill did Scott Farkus hit him. Screw him. He's trash and its time to take it out.

I have to say. I don't support Hillary as leader of the senate and I don't think her fellow senator's would either. I think pushing for her to become Governor of New York is more likely. If they like here there, that's up to them but there's no way Hillary and Bill belong on this ticket. That would be a HUGE mistake.

I hope he picks someone incredible that will work well with him and create an awesome team for change in the white house... I hope he does not just go by the usual ideas everyone is talking about. Clearly they have to be someone who would make an excellent president and I agree that he should leave the senators in the senate so that they can get things done once he is in office. Please don't pick someone just to get their state... yuck.. no Rendell, thanks. Someone who share's his values for change in Washington. I was hoping it would be Edwards. I know that they would disagree on some things but I also know Senator Obama wants people around him who will tell him the truth and not necessarily agree with him on everything. I wish Edwards would consider being VP. That could set us up for 16 great years...

user-pic

Ok, first of, stopping mentioning gotalife, lol, do you really miss him?

Here's a McCain question:

Looking at the county to county results, on average about 30% of the Republican voters DID NOT VOTE MCCAIN!

Huckabee, Paul, Romney take 30% of the vote from the declared nominee. I think that represents a major problem for McCain, it's not that they will vote Democrat, it's that they will stay home in November...

HRC has a chance to do this the right way or she can burn every bridge the Clintons built. Honestly I fear charred bridges

Gotalife is Gettingstrife at the the twisted knife that was rammed into his bitter life

Where is gotalife ? Where is gotalife ?
LOL

Just did the math in North Carolina. With the large, very pro-Obama Mecklenburg County still to report a few percent of its result, it seems likely that Obama will achieve a 15 point win in North Carolina.

(It's currently at about 14.81%, but Mecklenburg favors him 75%-25%.)

Hillary's win in Indiana seems likely to be about 1.8%.

It drives me nuts how Obama's most likely 14.9 win in NC is only 14 point and Hillary's 9.4 becomes a 10 point win in PA.

I miss idiotic... could it be that idiotic was a Hillary supporter after all?

user-pic

This is EXCELLENT NEWS! For HILLARY!
~

Loses something in the translation.

It's the beginning of the end for Obama.

Indeed it is. There is nothing to be done for him.

user-pic

Congrats Hillary Clinton

Me three.

It's on to the Vineyard for the Summer.
I will still be wondering why Obama voted for Cheney's Energy Bill. Something stinks to high Heaven.

Waaaaaah?

user-pic

Well, I do agree that there is a stench coming from this part of the thread.

Hillary: Full speed ahead...starting the day after tomorrow...
Well hill just announced that she is going into hiding for a day to shed her skin. How will she emerge?

user-pic

well, it looks like Obama is on the verge of wrapping it up....

user-pic

and America is going to have a "learning experience" about how affirmative action works. Man oh man, apparently Rice's performance as NSA wasn't enough to drive the point home: promoting black people to positions they can't handle might make you feel good, but it has a fearsome price. Rice, worst NSA in history by commom acclaim. Clarence Thomas, clearly a third rate hack who never should have been appointed to the Supreme Court. Donna Brazille, a nice ornament that cost Gore the election. The list goes on and on....

Ludmila - I am outraged by your comment. It deserves no rebuttle. You'd better go now, you're late for your meeting. Is your white hood clean and pressed?

Idiot. Get off my computer screen.

user-pic

But of course you're not a slimy racist.

Bush, Cheney, Rumsfeld, Bremer, heckuvajobBrownee, etc, etc, etc ad nauseum were all White incompetents unfit for their jobs. But those white guys EARNED their positions the old fashioned way, the way we WHITE people do it:

Bloodlines, money and blowjobs.

As if George Bush is any kind of example of how great it is to have a "white president"?!? Certainly Obama cannot be any WORSE than what we have had the last eight years...in fact, I expect he will be quite wonderful as a president per se! Your argument by analogy is rather lacking.

user-pic

Dr Cheese, don't bother. This Milo Buggeroff/Mila/Ludmila character is a disgrace and keeps changing its screen name, probably because it keeps getting banned. Best to ignore the vile spew that comes from this troglodyte. ;)

user-pic

What strikes me most of all is the abrupt shift of the media - I was watching MSNBC until they called Indiana for Clinton and they were talking about Obama as if he were the presumptive nominee and talking about Clinton's campaign in the past tense. Something that we've known for months now seemed to only become apparent to them last night (although, truth be told, they have known it was over for months and kept it going for their own amusement). She's got to see that once the media declares your campaign DOA it's really, truly time to fold the tent and go home. I think I detected a tiny bit of that in her speech last night.

What got me most annoyed was MSNBC's constant chatter about the possibility of her being on the ticket as VP and that Obama is going to have to take that seriously. Absolutely not - that's bullshit and I don't think he's going to go that route. Hopefully the chatter about the "Dream Ticket" (which is anything but a dream, in my opinion - more like a nightmare) was done for their own amusement and enjoyment.

And one gem from Al Giordano from the Field (he's been following Operation Chaos very closely):

And if anyone thinks that Rush Limbaugh didnโ€™t deliver at least 19,000 votes to Senator Clinton in Indiana, Iโ€™ve got a bridge to sell you.

http://208.76.84.21/thefield/?p=1164

Funny thing is, Limbaugh failed miserably, didn't he? Despite his best efforts, he's going to have Obama to face in the fall (something obviously he didn't want), and I don't think there's anything that can stop Obama - not Limbaugh, not the Swift Boaters, certainly not Clinton.

user-pic

How dare you insult troglodytes that way!

user-pic

LOLOL! How about cockroach?? ;)

"LOLOL" means "laughing out loud out loud"

Netiquette dictates that a simple LOL will suffice here. Adding an exclamation point or two would drive home the desired emphasis, but adding extra OL's really is akin to stuttering.

Thank you for your attention.

user-pic

Actually, Republicans don't care which of the 2 McCain faces in November. Rush's goal was jjust to keep them beating eachother up through the summer, which appears to have been pretty successful so far.

So you are comparing Obama to all the black republicans you can think of, plus someone in the Gore campaign who "cost the election", nevermind Scalia and the rest of them who are white men. Hmmm...Racism runs deep in this country. We only have to look at Ludmila.

...and one more thing. In general, arguments from analogy are notoriously weak, and sometimes even fallacious.

Okay, maybe two things...I have a sad confession to make. While I deeply want to believe that we can never have a president worse than Bush, I have to admit that it is at least possible. After all, I once thought that it would not be possible for the US to have a president that I disliked more than Reagan (you know, that "snowballs in hell" feeling). Sadly, I was SO wrong...which makes me very leary of saying "no one could be worse than Bush." While I have to admit that it may be possible, I NEVER want to see it!!

user-pic

Something to keep in mind for the general:

26% OF REPUBLICAN VOTERS AGAINST MCCAIN IN NC
22% GO AGAINST MCCAIN IN INDIANA...

We've been so preoccupied with the question of whether Hillary has permanently damaged support for Obama with her slimey attacks, we've lost sight of the fact that McCain still has a huge chunk of Republicans who look like they will never vote for him.

For him to lose about a quarter of the vote with no real opponent is pretty bad. Especially for Republicans who would normally unify to vote for a brain-dead weasel if the party ran one (hypothetically speaking, of course).

So all the talk about Obama not getting the white, working class vote may be diverting our attention from McCain's big problem: not even having his base lined up.

O-Bomb wins 91 delegates on the night; Hill wins 79.
She needed not only to win, but by a huge margin to make this realistic. Unfortunately for her, reality has a well-known Obama bias.

Hi, Carol,

Thanks for the tip (and giving me my first "acknowledged" comment in TPM--I am honored that it was you!)...I was aware of Ludmila's antics...it just the post so frustrated/angered me I wanted to point out its utter absurdity. I'll try to avoid providing very much troll food in the future...even though I do try to practice the "love thine enemies" approach, even towards trolls. ;-) Okay, back to the last batch of papers...

user-pic

Oh, you're quite welcome. I know how you feel - its posts get me in a blind rage as well. They are horrible and I've asked Greg and Eric to please ban the poster. But it's really not worth it to get crazed, because people like that are not reasonable. It's a waste of time to even try (although, I must confess, I still respond to some of its posts. I can't help myself sometimes LOL!)

Cheers! ;)

Prediction: Terry McAuliffe will be on Fox within the hour, claiming to have raised 6 billion dollars since last night.

Wolfson on NPR right now, pitching to SD's, but his tone is definitely subdued.

NPR challenging him. Saying he plans on dealing in a back room.

He's saying no, says Clinton is taking it to the convention.

user-pic

The media seem to have undergone a wonderful sea change overnight, haven't they? There is just no way for them to spin this anymore - as Tim Russert said last night (I'm paraphrasing here), "sometimes the candidate is the last to know the best timing [for conceding]. It's like being on life support - once they start removing the systems, you really have no choice."

It was interesting to hear the hosts take him to task if even for a moment. NPR, more than anyone in the Dem primary I think, try to keep it real down the middle, you know?

But they were basically saying, How you gonna do it?
Spin is fine and all, but what's in it for the rest of us if you all are shooting blanks...

Well, they hyped up the horse race as much as they could but there's no primaries with any sort of surprise left.

The Clinton camp is in damage control mode, but claiming they will go to the convention is preposturous even for Wolfson.

Yep, it is preposterous. However, I suspect that her campaign literally cannot afford to suspend right now - she must continue raising *primary* funds in order to retire massive debt. In order to do that she must at least pretend to be still running a campaign.

When she drops out, the money she has raised for the general election has to be returned to the donors. She was able to use that money to inflate her fundraising totals for a while, making her campaign look more viable than it really was. But she cannot use those funds to retire debt incurred during the primary. Most of that money is presumably from donors who had maxed out for the primary, so that well is dry.

Her target is no longer voters or superdelegates, it is new/small campaign contributors.

user-pic

Lets get to work building the Democratic party. What senate seats are in play? What house seats are in play? What about your local legislature? Here in my neck of the woods we have been treated to years of Republican rule. The local state senator absolutely hates creating jobs. I bet if you are suffering from a similar Republican administration your local candidates could use your help. What have you done to help your local democratic candidates? Have you met any of them? Have you contributed to your state party? Have you been to an event?

Staring at a keyboard is fun, but getting out and doing something is even more fun.

"It's over for her.

Who will continue to fund this?"

Richard Mellon Scaife

"Damn, she's out before I can accuse her of murdering Vince Foster again."

My predictions from last week:

1. Obama wins NC by 15 pts
2. Clinton wins IN by 3 pts
3. Eric posts about how Clinton's 3 pt win in IN is decisive but Obama's 15 pt win in NC is really a loss since he needed an even bigger landslide.
---------------------------------
So I was within one point on both states, which as far as I can tell is better than any of the pollsters did. Still waiting on #3, but I think even Eric has given up.

What do I win?

Your prize: Obama as POTUS.

Obama's back yard!

He predicted a 7-8 point win there but lost by 2.

He will be a loser in general election too if nominated and join the ranks of:

*Dukakis
*Ted Kennedy
*Gore
*John Kerry
*Daschel

Notice how all the LOSERS with the exception of Gore are supporting or hinting at supporting Obama? Obama will eventually join their club.

Clintons are the ONLY successful Dems in how many years now? hmmm. Long time it seems.

But you guys go ahead and have your little party. If Obama is nominated, me and about 35% of the other Hillary supporters will be casting our votes for McCain. I would do that EVEN if Hillary were the VP Candidate.

And just ONE reason why is because of the media types like MSNBC. The other reason being that Obama would be TERRIBLE for our country!

I've not yet given up on our gal Hillary. IF its do-able, she'll do it.

But if the super delegates fall in line behind Obama, we will vote McCain and get a lot of satisfaction out of sitting back and watching this upstart, no-experienced anti-patriot LOSE to the war hero Patriot, Sen. John McCain. A lot of the votes for Obama was by republicans who will be voting McCain and figured Obama would be easier to beat. They are right of course.

Rae

Well, so long. Don't let the door hit you in the ass on the way out of the Democratic Party. Given how vile you're rhetoric has been since you showed up here, you'll fit right in in your new home with the worst of the trash in the Republican Party.

But, hey, don't look back. You're liable to find that that big parade of Clinton supporters your expecting to find behind you won't be there. Just you, Matthew Weaver and Joe Lieberman; it'll be a pretty pathetic parade.

And stay out of the way of all the people coming over to Obama their side or you'll get trampled.

user-pic

IF its do-able, she'll do it.

That's the point. It's not doable. So, you're officially a McCain supporter. You can go now. Bye.

Hate-spewing Republican troll.

Falls far short of what Greg? A win is a win is a win. Obama/AxelRove said that Indiana was a tie breaker. NC, he led by double digits throughout.....I think yourself and the MSM are spinning as usual.

oh come on Louisville.

That probably sounded good last night, when Hillary was up by a whopping 4%, but now, in the clear morning light it is confirmed:

Hillary has no credible path to the nomination.

And that's all that matters.

You really, truly don't understand how this delegate math stuff works at all, do you?

Leave a comment

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address