« Hillary Defends Obama From McCain's Hamas Attack | Home | Obama Campaign Silent On Talk Of Edwards Endorsement »

Will He Stay or Will He Go?

With the House Democrats already up three seats from special elections, a lot of eyes are now looking to another potential pickup in either a special election or this Fall: New York's 13th District, home of the scandal-plagued GOP Congressman Vito Fossella, where the national GOP leadership is frantically trying to push him out and take their chances on an open seat.

Fossella would be considered safe under normal circumstances -- but these are certainly not normal circumstances after he was arrested for drunk driving, called his girlfriend to pick him up from jail, and then had to admit that he had a girlfriend and a child with her outside of his marriage. Since then, the New York and Washington press and political operatives have practically been on a running deathwatch.

There is no question that the Republicans want him out -- indeed, the leadership has been reaching out to a potential new candidate. However, those close to Fossella say he's prepared to stay in, and a recent SurveyUSA poll showed early support at home despite the scandal.

The question, then, becomes whether Fossella's baggage will truly put this seat up for grabs, and which candidates will step forward to run a very tight, very expensive race.

This seat is the only New York city district carried by President Bush in 2004, giving him 55% of the vote. However, the Democrats have won much redder districts than this one in the recent special elections, so it's not any kind of a stretch to see it becoming competitive or even going Democratic in an open-seat race in the midst of a Democratic wave.

The first problem the GOP faces is what to do about Fossella. Many of them want him to go, and Minority Leader John Boehner and NRCC head Tom Cole have both contacted Staten Island District Attorney Dan Donovan about potentially running for the seat. Donovan currently serves about four fifths of the district and was re-elected with 68% of the vote in 2007, so he could be a very strong candidate.

Donovan is playing it cool for now, though. "Obviously everyone's waiting to see what the Congressman does, so we would pretty much take it form there," Donovan communications director William J. Smith told TPM Election Central. "The D.A. hasn't decided that he would be a candidate even if there was a vacancy, so obviously he would wait for the Congressman to make a decision."

The Democrats do have a candidate waiting in the wings: New York City Councillor Domenic Recchia, who hails from the Brooklyn part of the district and already has $325,000 cash on hand for the race. That's not much in the New York media market, but it's actually more than Fossella has -- as many seemingly safe incumbents don't see a need to raise too much money.

On top of that, Recchia could have a national party committee much more able to spend money on the race than Fossella or any other Republican would get. The DCCC had $32 million cash on hand at the end of March, compared to only $7 million for the NRCC -- so the GOP will likely have to conserve resources and focus on cheaper races, unless something radically changes, while the DCCC will be at greater liberty spend big on targeted races.

A big part of how this works out could come down to money. Are the Republicans truly willing to spend precious money on supporting a Fossella re-election bid? Probably not. And in the case of an open-seat race, the Dems could bring a lot more resources to bear, putting a seat in play that wasn't even remotely in question a mere two weeks ago.


10 Comments

| Leave a comment

The GOPs are a bunch of friggin hypocrites.

The drunk driving thing is bad and should be a point of contention, he broke the law and put people in danger but he wouldn't be the first politician to do that - however, his extramarital stuff is between him and his wife and his mistress.

The republicans really do eat their own.
Although to be fair, the dems have been known to do that from time to time.

You neglect to mention Democrat Steve Harrison, who ran against Fossella two years ago and got 43% of the vote. I don't know much about the politics of that part of NYC, but Brooklyn is such a small part of the district you would think the Dems would find a candidate in Staten Island. (Harrison is from the Brooklyn side also).

(The linked article also mentions another, perhaps even more important, ethical lapse by Fossella: he improperly used characters from Sesame Street in a mailer).

http://www.steveharrisonforcongress.com/2007/01/dems_to_vito_youre_going_down_this_time.php#more

And my point was, he's running for the Dem nomination again.

Since I am from the Isle of Staten, I am enthused about a chance to finally have a Democrat in congress and think we finally have at least a 50% shot.

You can shun your gay sister, you can have a secret love child and mistress, you may have a DWI, but when you misappropriate muppets in campaign materials you have gone to far sir!

Steve Harrison for Congress!

Constituent of NY-13

user-pic

Go Fossella!

I hate to be a stickler for punctuation, but you made an error. That should be:

GO, FOSSELLA!!!!

user-pic

The extramarital stuff is relevant because he's a big family values guy--hypocrisy again. But the stories further indicate that (1) he lied to his mistress and said he was separated, and (2) he may have been travelling with his mistress on the taxpayer's dime.

I feel sorry for his children from both mothers.

user-pic

Can't the GOP House leadership strip him of his committee assignments? Obviously they have the power to deny him any funds from the RNCC this cycle. And finally, they can launch (or threaten to launch) an Ethics Committee investigation.

Dancingbear, do you have a link to the travel allegations? Also, I think conflict of interest disclosures require you to list the names of your children so that you can't set up slush funds in their names. If he failed to list the child he had with the mistress, that would certainly be at a minimum an ethics offense, and as a signed document under oath, possibly a perjury problem.

I'd also wonder whether he was complying with Federal gift tax laws if he was providing any significant support to the mistress or the child.

user-pic
Fossella and his lover took several trips together overseas on official taxpayer-funded congressional business, including to Europe in July 2003. Questions remain about earlier congressionally approved trips Fossella took, where Fay may have joined him in exotic European and Mideast locales on the taxpayers' dime.

http://www.nydailynews.com/news/2008/05/10/2008-05-10_vito_fossella_lied_to_other_woman_wife_c-1.html

Cook upgraded the race from 'solid' to 'likely' back in October and another upgrade would have been likely with Fossella being behind (first time since at least 02 that he trailed a challenger) in money before all of this happened. It wasn't really 'safe'.

While Recchia's city council district overlaps portions of this congressional district he does not 'hail from the Brooklyn portion of the district', he lives outside of it. He lives in NY-08, Rep. Nadler's district.

Cy Guy, the House has 30 days since the arrest to start an ethics investigation or report why they decided not to. This process has already begun.

Also check out reference #26 and #27 at VinoFossella.com for information on the travel allegations.

Leave a comment

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address