« New Hillary Radio Ad In Pennsylvania Features Army Brass Saying Experience Trumps Charisma | Home | New Hillary Ad In Indiana: She'll Oppose Unfair Trade Deals »

Obama-Backing Unions Want Penn Kicked Out Of Entire Democratic Party

Mark Penn's demotion from his position as Hillary Clinton's top strategist has done little to solve the problem Penn has created for her with Big Labor.

The Change To Win labor federation, which has endorsed Barack Obama and has an estimated six-million members from seven big unions, has put up a blog post with the simple title, "Mark Penn Still Has To Go."

And they don't just mean Penn has to go from the campaign — they mean he has to be kicked out of the Democratic Party entirely.

"Our message on this matter is simple," writes Jason Lefkowitz, the federation's online communications director. "People who represent union-busters should not be welcome in the Democratic Party. People who represent death squads targeting trade unionists should not be welcome in the Democratic Party."


44 Comments

| Leave a comment

I wonder how all the Hillary supporters who have to pay union dues to these guys feel.

Really? I don't wonder at all.

But good on you for trying to carry the water on this one Otto--you're gonna get a workout.

user-pic

Hey, Otto--surprised you bothered to read past the headline.

Dues dollars are explicitly not allowed to be used for political purposes. Voluntary political contributions to Unions PACs are how it is funded.

Hillary was furious. Simply furious. Furious I tell you. Furious. . . about the Columbia situation blowing up into a big story. But she wasn't furious about the other conflicts of interest and anti-labor lobbying as long as it flew under the radar of everyone but hyper-informed blogging types. Cintas and Blackwater were just fine when it was just us nattering on about it. But when local PA newspapers picked up on Penn's Columbia lobbyig. . . Furious. Simply furious.

The Clintons have always said one thing to low income voters while doing another for their wealthy donors.

And the trends go on.

Mark Penn Speaks (In Private): Will Still Advise Clintons, Calms Nervous Aides

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/04/07/penn-speaks-in-private-wi_n_95508.html

This will be played up BIG in Pennsylvania by the unions as long as Penn is with the Clinton campaign.

People who represent union-busters should not be welcome in the Democratic Party. People who represent death squads targeting trade unionists should not be welcome in the Democratic Party.

Kind of hard to argue with their statement.

"People who represent union-busters should not be welcome in the Democratic Party. People who represent death squads targeting trade unionists should not be welcome in the Democratic Party."

Fair enough.

user-pic

Good for them. It will never happen; but it should.

(chuckle) Well *there's* their answer...

Have you noticed that Clinton always leads on decisions like opposing the Colombian free trade deal and boycotting the Olympics, then Obama finally follows her lead.

Still waiting on his position on the Olympics.

Clinton is the leader and Obama is the follower.

Clinton/Obama, if you want to win.

She didn't say that we should boycott Olympics. She said that Bush shouldn't attend the opening ceremonies. Personally, I think it's a silly in light of our normalized trade status with China and just unnecessarily creates international diplomatic tensions, but that's besides the point.

The point is, you're still a troll.

I believe Nancy Pelosi is the first major politician to come out and say that we should make a statement regarding the Olympics. Clinton didn't lead, she xeroxed.

Martin Luther King III is the one that said we needed a Poverty Czar to combat poverty affecting Americans of all races. Clinton didn't lead, she xeroxed.

Obama said we should never have gone into Iraq and had steadfastly stated his intention to withdraw from Iraq. Clinton didn't lead, she xeroxed.

Issue and issue, Clinton waits until someone else sticks their neck out and risk themselves before taking a position and demanding credit.

She's not a leader, she's a glory-hound.

user-pic

also, don't doubt for a second that there's apolitical motivation behind this. She wants to draw as many contrasts as possible with obama, so she pulls issues out of the air to try to force him to take a position on things like this.

Now we are talking.
I don't think the Mark Penn can be excluded from the democratic party but he should not be tolerated in any enlighted democratic candidate's campaign staff.
NO MORE window dressing by changing his title. Make candidates live up to their ideals and rhetoric by having him leave. Enough is enough.

Ouch, that's gotta smart.

I have to say I see the opinions of a group of unions comprising 6 million members as slightly more persuasive than a letter from 20 or so fatcat donors. It'll be interesting to see how this plays out.

user-pic

One can only hope.

I don't mind donating a few bucks, if they want to go on air in PA.

Anything to keep Penn away from human civilization.

user-pic

I must admit that if we're kicking people out of the party, I'd really like to start with Lieberman,

But it's ok with me if Penn is second.

Joe Lieberman is out of the party. He is an Independent now, and he is one of War Monger McCain's biggest backers.

user-pic

I am not sure it is possible to remove someone from the Democratic party... though I do appreciate the sentiment.......

My vote is noise. She may have a continued hit today because of Penn, but it won't last.

I wonder how all the Hillary supporters who have to pay union dues to these guys feel.
Posted by Otto F

Otto makes it clear that he approves of Union Busting Death Squads. and wants Hillary to continue employ their Enablers.

user-pic
I am not sure it is possible to remove someone from the Democratic party... though I do appreciate the sentiment.......

It's not.

What CtoW specifically said was that someone like Mark Penn "should not be welcome in the Democratic Party." And, "that there is no place on a Democratic campaign for someone who earns a paycheck helping companies that violate the basic human rights of working men and women paper over their offenses -- regardless of what title they carry."

They didn't use the term "kicked out", at least not in their official response or in anything else that I've seen.

She followed on the Colombian trade deal (not that that fact would change your "analysis"). As for the Olympics, Obama actually talked about it last week.

http://www.msnbc.msn.com/id/23916733/

But again, given your commitment to hatred of all things Obama, I don't think this facts will penetrate your anti-Obama filters.

This should go over well then

Mark Penn Speaks (In Private): Will Still Advise Clintons, Calms Nervous Aides

http://www.huffingtonpost.com/2008/04/07/penn-speaks-in-private-wi_n_95508.html

I'm an Obama supporter and Penn-basher, but this seems a bit ridiculous. You can't really kick someone out of a political party, can you?

You can cut their ties and their influence.

Which is what should be done. Mark Penn is no Democrat.

user-pic

For a year, there have been mutterings about Mark Penn and his union-busting activities, and the unions wrote to Clinton last June to complain about him. She blew them off then, assuming they'd come around at election time. Of course, at the time, she didn't dream that she'd actually be a facing a challenge at this point or that the unions would have a viable alternative. Once again, her campaign shows a lack of planning and judgment.

Indeed.

If you're a lowly paid worker sending her campaign $50 monthly, knowing that she made 109 million in 7 years and knowing that the largest line item on her campaign budget is paying Mark Penn, who is also taking 300,000 from a foreign government in a deal that could cost you your job, I don't understand why you would trust and support Hillary.

user-pic

i don't think that he could be "kicked out" i mean -- what, he shouldn't be allowed to register (D)?

OTOH, anyone who employs him could easily be seen as anti-labor, what with the union-busting and murder and all.

user-pic
I believe Nancy Pelosi is the first major politician to come out and say that we should make a statement regarding the Olympics. Clinton didn't lead, she xeroxed.

What did Pelosi say? I haven't seen anything and I think the whole thing should be cancelled.

It's disgusting.

The choice of senior staff rests solely with the candidate.
Bill Clinton strongly backed the right wing death squads in Columbia when he was president. Columbia was simply doing business as it has been done in Washington. Support the candidate that supports your positions and disregard the campaign noise.
Mark Penn was and is telling his clients that the conduit to the Clinton's is still open for business.
Columbia got upset when Penn tossed them under the bus to keep this incident as background noise.
Mark Penn and by extension Hillary & Bill Clinton and their supporters at the AFL-CIO, especially the president of the Machinists & Aerospace Workers, AFSCME & the NEA all support those that support union busting and right wing death squads that kill union leaders & organizers.
It is way past time for the good folks at the AFL-CIO to stand up for labor or stand up for the death squads that target labor and their supporters politics and the lobbying industries.

If Mark Penn wants to vote for Barack Obama for president, that's fine with me. But beyond that he needs to sit his fat ass down and shut his filthy pie hole. But, I mean that in a nice way.

user-pic

I'll repeat - as far as I know and I know it's been looked into with some zest by some real Lieberman haters, it is not possible to kick someone out of a political party. It's not like the state bar or anything.

But I still love the thought.

Who will put some steel in her spine?

Despite the moral stand that "Change to Win" is taking, which I feel deserves attention, this saga isn't really about how things play out in the media, at least at this point.

What's currently in the balance is whether the leadership of seven powerful unions will go from very powerful Obama supporters to very powerful Obama supporters who are also very angry enemies of Hillary Clinton.

It's pretty clear from CtoW's blistering response that the Clinton campaign's musical chairs "demotion" of Mark Penn is not the head on a platter they want.

Now it's Hillary's move. She can lose, or she can lose. (That's not a typing error.)

This is nightmare stuff for the Clinton campaign.

user-pic

The knees of Clinton's jumpsuits woulda been stained a deep, dark green even without Penn.

user-pic

I don't even really care all that much anymore about kicking Lieberman out of the party. Really, he's such an empty shell of a man. It can't be easy waking up each day knowing you're a joke.

All I want to know is that the "Kiss" float will show up if he ever runs for anything ever again. And also, that after we gain some more seats in the Senate, he's stripped of all power.

Emperor Palpatine would not go down without a fight...

Good for the Change to Win unions. Now, I don't know if you can formally kick the guy out of the party or not -- though he certainly deserves such treatment -- but Hillary's failure to sever all ties to Penn (including stopping all payments to him, his polling firm and Burson-Marsteller) speaks volumes about her lack of principles and ethical blind spots.

It also speaks volumes of the unions that have endorsed Hillary -- like AFSCME, AFT and the Machinists -- that they have not demanded the same thing. How can they justify the continued support of a candidate who continues to employ an advisor/pollster who makes millions of dollars representing union-busters and corrupt governments that sanction the assassinations of union leaders and activists?

Gerry McEntee, Tom Buffenbarger, Ed McElroy -- your silence is deafening!

Leave a comment

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address