« Obama: I Will Completely Change President's Posture Towards Rest Of World. | Home | Hillary On Obama's Speeches: "It's Change You Can Xerox" »

Hillary Hits Obama Over Surrogate's Inability To Name Obama Accomplishment

Hillary had to draw a sharp contrast with Obama tonight, and it just started in earnest: As might have been expected, she made an explicit and very barbed reference to that hapless State Senator who couldn't name a single Obama accomplishment the other night:

I have to confess, I was somewhat amused the other night when on one of the TV shows, one of Senator Obama’s supporters was asked to name one accomplishment of Senator Obama. And he couldn’t. So I know that there are comparisons and contrasts to be drawn between us. And it’s important that voters get that information. So yes, I do think that words are important, and words matter. But actions speak louder than words.

Obama's response coming.

Late Update: Obama's response:

Well I think actions do speak louder than words, which is why, over the 20 years of my public service, I have acted a lot to provide health care to people who didn’t have it, to provide tax breaks to families that needed it. To reform a criminal justice system that had resulted in wrongful convictions, to open up our government and to pass the toughest ethics reform legislation since Watergate, to make sure that we create transparency in our government so that we know where federal spending is going...

You know, I think if you talk those wounded warriors at Walter Reed, who prior to me getting to the Senate were having to pay for their meals, and have to pay for their phone calls after their family while they’re recovering from amputations, I think they’d say that I’ve engaged not just in talk but in action.



26 Comments

| Leave a comment

He killed her with his response.

we all knew that was coming

OK, she totally lost me now. She's getting screechy and preachy. Yuck.

I think she flew a lead ballon with the plagarism, silly season moment.

The video is obscure and really a Chris Mathews moment.

this is EXCELLENT NEWS FOR HILLARY!!!

Nothing like sticking a fellow dem State Senator in the back...

Yummy!

i think hillary will have one of those "moments" if BO keeps out debating her tonight

why is cnn making all of clinton's arguments for her. they're repeating her toughest criticisms, so we don't even have to hear them come out of her own mouth. 1) is he all hat and no cattle. 2) are you a plagiarist. 3) is he not ready to be commander in chief. without even saying anything, clinton wins all 3 points b/c cnn is letting her control the terms of the debate. obama's campaign should be furious.

That ought to swing Texas her way.

user-pic

My sarcasm detectors are a little weak tonight... you are being sarcastic, right? Sorry to ask...

hmmm...

"change you can Xerox"

I'm not neutral here, but it really feels good to see a canned line as bad as that fail so spectacularly.

Hillary garnished my wages for an aspirin! LOL

Don't forget in his reply, he said Clinton said "let's get real" in her campaign, and that that somehow implied so many people who currently support him are delusional.

Also, he later said in the same bout, relating to the plagiarism thing, "He gave me the line, and suggested that I use it".

user-pic

Her attack was pathetic. It was garbage. The poor guy froze. How does that reflect on Obama? It's nonsense and they both know it.

This is low, is she seriously implying in a debate on national tv that this guy's inability to respond when put on the spot somehow means that Obama doesn't have ANY legislative achievements? A complete idiot could see right through the logic of that argument, even Bush isn't that stupid.

She is shameless. And who is she to talk about achievements??

http://thepersonalispolitical.tumblr.com/post/26828168

She is gonna cry

its 9:45, and its over? WTF!!!

accomplishments of Hilary that I can name... first lady and a senator?

user-pic
accomplishments of Hilary that I can name... first lady and a senator?

Look, they both have accomplishments. I'm not going to diss Hillary's. (Don't ask me to list them. I'm sure they are there.) What pisses me off is that the Hillary camp -- and Hillary herself-- is STILL trying to paint Obama as being an accomplishment-free empty suit. Jeebus.

On that topic, consider this from Charles Peters, founding editor of the Washington Monthly, in the WaPo:

People who complain that Barack Obama lacks experience must be unaware of his legislative achievements. One reason these accomplishments are unfamiliar is that the media have not devoted enough attention to Obama's bills and the effort required to pass them, ignoring impressive, hard evidence of his character and ability.

Since most of Obama's legislation was enacted in Illinois, most of the evidence is found there -- and it has been largely ignored by the media in a kind of Washington snobbery that assumes state legislatures are not to be taken seriously. (Another factor is reporters' fascination with the horse race at the expense of substance that they assume is boring, a fascination that despite being ridiculed for years continues to dominate political journalism.)

I am a rarity among Washington journalists in that I have served in a state legislature. I know from my time in the West Virginia legislature that the challenges faced by reform-minded state representatives are no less, if indeed not more, formidable than those encountered in Congress. For me, at least, trying to deal with those challenges involved as much drama as any election. And the "heart and soul" bill, the one for which a legislator gives everything he or she has to get passed, has long told me more than anything else about a person's character and ability.

Consider a bill into which Obama clearly put his heart and soul. The problem he wanted to address was that too many confessions, rather than being voluntary, were coerced -- by beating the daylights out of the accused.

Obama proposed requiring that interrogations and confessions be videotaped.

Peters then spends several paragraphs detailing exactly how Obama got this one done, through a combo of cajolery, poker, helping with other legislation, assuaging concerns, etc., etc... then:

Obama proved persuasive enough that the bill passed both houses of the legislature, the Senate by an incredible 35 to 0. Then he talked Blagojevich into signing the bill, making Illinois the first state to require such videotaping.

Obama didn't stop there. He played a major role in passing many other bills, including the state's first earned-income tax credit to help the working poor and the first ethics and campaign finance law in 25 years (a law a Post story said made Illinois "one of the best in the nation on campaign finance disclosure"). Obama's commitment to ethics continued in the U.S. Senate, where he co-authored the new lobbying reform law that, among its hard-to-sell provisions, requires lawmakers to disclose the names of lobbyists who "bundle" contributions for them.

Taken together, these accomplishments demonstrate that Obama has what Dillard, the Republican state senator, calls a "unique" ability "to deal with extremely complex issues, to reach across the aisle and to deal with diverse people." In other words, Obama's campaign claim that he can persuade us to rise above what divides us is not just rhetoric.

Sadly, for all Obama's wonderful rhetoric, Peters is a better advocate for Obama on this score than Obama himself is, at least judging by tonight's debate. He could have detailed some of this stuff, listed a few or several, or many, accomplishments specifically, but aside from the quoted text in the OP, I unfortunately didn't hear much, which was less than I wanted.

Hat tip to Randi Rhodes for reading the Peters piece on-air and linking to it on her website.

Anyone else think the moderators were friendly to Clinton? Lots of softball questions. "You have said you are Ready on Day One. Explain"

CNN = "Clinton News Network"


user-pic

Hillary's final statement was plagiarized from Bill's 1992 campaign.

They focus grouped preachy & screechy and are pretty confident it's going to kill. It's their "theme of the week".

One of Obama's better moments that the media will completely gloss over was in this section...

She's screeding him on his supporter not knowing his legislative record and he comes back with ...Senator Clinton has a fine record. So do I. ...

He doesn't need to slime her. He can find it in him to compliment her while smacking down her stoogery with grace and ease.

He's presidential. She's a churlish wonk.

user-pic

I saw Chris Matthews a couple nights ago when he asked that question.
This may actully be a blessing in disguise and bring out more talk of Obamas achievments.
I thought he looked very presidential last night and did very well.
He is so genuine and keeps his cool.
I am certain he will get the nomination.
Can't wait to see him debate McCain!

What struck me as funny was when they asked Obama about his accomplishments, even he couldn't name much. LOL


Rae

Oh, and he said again the line, "Washington was where good ideas go to die", yet he he's been in Senate for years and couldn't push through the legislation on immmigration either. So why should anyone think he'll be able to do any better as president? Sounds like the ideas were dying on his watch too.

But he is rather charismatic.


Rae

Leave a comment

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address