« Hillary's Opening Statement: I Won't Hope For Change; I'll Work For It | Home | Obama To Hillary: "I'm Looking Forward To You Advising Me" »

Obama Defends Biden After Moderator Smacks Him On Race

Okay, this is just pathetic. The moderator of the debate, Des Moines Register editor Carolyn Washburn, just asked this question of Joe Biden:

Senator Biden, you and your campaign have had a number of occasions to correct or clarify things you've said relating to race, including your remarks about Senator Obama being, quote, "clean and articulate," your comment about Indians working at 7-11, and recently to the Washington Post in which you spoke about race while describing disparities between schools in Washington, D.C. and Iowa.

Do these gaffes, or misunderstandings, or however you characterize them indicate you're uncomfortable talking about race, or are people just being too sensitive?

Look, this is just absurd. Biden has been forced multiple times to defend this comment about Obama being "clean and articulate." Here's what he said of Obama at the time:

"I mean, you got the first mainstream African-American who is articulate and bright and clean and a nice-looking guy."

Some have pointed out convincingly that if you add a missing comma, Biden very clearly could have meant Obama is "mainstream" and in addition is "articulate and clean." At any rate, asking Biden to answer for this yet again is just a big waste of time.

Thankfully, Obama stepped forth to defend Biden, saying:

"I have absolutely no doubt about what is in his heart and the commitment he's made to racial equality in this country."

Good.


27 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

I know Sen Biden personally. I have sat along side him at a Union table. He is a good man. I have know him for over 30 years. BHO did a good thing, people who know him, know that's not him.

user-pic

I'm just stunned by the question. she really sucks.

user-pic

Good. Plus, it can't hurt him with Biden first choicers....

user-pic

If you remember this was another beck/rush/hannity smear move on Biden earlier in the season. They played this up and made this into a issue from nothing.

user-pic

What a dumb question. If anything Biden is TOO comfortable talking about race, which is how he gets into trouble.

Oh, and I agree it was good of Obama to defend him (not that I would expect anything different from anyone else).

user-pic

Obama is the man

a poet

rather then an engineer

user-pic

Biden is a great senator and person. It really is sad that they keep bringing this stuff up. He made a stupid gaffe and is gaffe prone. Does that make him a racist? Absolutely not. Obama was great to come to his defense.

General point. All of these "debates" have sucked. They all have. They're not debates at all but mini-press conferences. Also, the many of the moderators have tried to "outshine" the candidates or to make the news, like russert and this bozo, which is really pathetic. I am sick of them. I can't wait until the field narrows or if it doesn't they should break them up or something. This format sucks.

user-pic

Biden is an easy target and the moderator was just trying to draw blood (from a stone). Biden is lower tier anyway. I think he's hanging in for a cabinet seat.

user-pic

I like the way Obama came to his defense. Biden is a great man and I’ll vote for him any day. If I were in Iowa, Obama and Biden will be my first and second choice.

The two are the most sincere on the stage.

user-pic
All of these "debates" have sucked.

I agree, Michael A, and I think most everyone does. But I did think that the NPR debate a week or two ago (totally ignored here at TPM) was a notch above the rest. They limited the debate to three topics and that allowed for a more in depth discussion than trying to cover every topic imaginable. They also had no studio audience so there was no time wasted with applause and laughter and heckling. There were no set time limits for answers. And I thought the moderators and questions were better than in the other debates. I'm still baffled by the blackout of that debate on a web site called "Election Central."

user-pic

2008 Presidential Election Weekly Poll

http://www.votenic.com

The Only Poll That Matters.
Results Posted Every Tuesday Evening.

user-pic

all I can say is I am leaning towards Edwards.

user-pic

LG - I agree with you regarding the NPR forum. It was, at least to me, more than just a notch above the rest - it was much better than all of the rest, but given the standard that's not saying much.

Part of it is that it followed those travesties in Nevada where the audience had far too much input by their booing etc..

user-pic

I didn't get to see - did anyone ask about restoring the Constitution?

I didn't think so.

user-pic

""""""""Robin wrote on December 13, 2007 4:04 PM:
all I can say is I am leaning towards Edwards.""""""""""""""""""""""""

I hope that is not all you can say. I favor obama, but i hope it remains at least a 3 person race for awhile. Nevertheless-----if it does boild down to 2 realistic choices---there are still 3 things you can do. One of those things is nothing.

user-pic

I didn't get to see - did anyone ask about restoring the Constitution?

How many debates in a row is that?

user-pic

"...Do these gaffes, or misunderstandings, or however you characterize them indicate you're uncomfortable talking about race, or are people just being too sensitive?..."

isn't the person asking the question supposed to know what they're asking and not say as part of the question: "however you characterize them"? That's either just lazy or they're answering their own question. Idiot commentator.

user-pic

yes biden gets himself in trouble for the things he says, but you can tell he's honest when he tries to explain what he really meant, and unlike the current administration, has never been too arrogant to apologize for his mistakes. That to me shows true character and integrity. At least the mistakes he makes are not of things that really matter like policy-making, votes, etc. Americans say they want honest straight-talkers, and if that is true, we should elect Biden. This woman's question was neither insightful nor useful to the voters in Iowa and the rest of the country. In fact, it wasn't even well-phrased...What I want to know is WHY is she the editor of the Des Moines Register?

user-pic

Once again, Obama shows himself to have the most class of the Democratic field. Not just letting Biden off the hook for his careless statements but vouching personally and defending a fellow competitor for the Democratic Nomination.

user-pic

Kefa,

I've been reading your posts all over TPMEC for several days now and your consistent use of Obama's middle initial (H. for Hussein) strikes me clearly as code. A bigoted one. Which makes your defense of Sen. Biden here as a good, non-racist man here completely disingenuous and hippocritical. So, are you a bigot, or are you just that desperate for Billary to win that you're willing to stoop to republican levels and use the politics of smear and fear?

user-pic

I agree that the formats suck. They give no room except for the canned, drab thirty-second lines we hear every debate. Actually Joe Biden himself previously had recommended having single-issue debates where they spend an hour and a half on health care, education or foreign policy. Then there'd be much greater potential for engagement on the issues. The candidates would have to be better prepared.

user-pic

I'm sorry, if Joe Biden were working in your office saying this kind of crap, he'd be a social pariah, and rightly so.

All you 'very serious people' might think this is a waste of time, but he's running for president, not chief technocrat. The kind of person this guy is matters. And repeated, sloppy, loose-lipped asides like these say something about the kind of man Joe Biden is.

user-pic

The immediate, spontaneous response by the other presidential candidates in support of Senator Biden when he was asked about his commitment to civil rights was striking as well as heartfelt. It was obvious to all but the most jaundiced observers that Biden commands a lot of respect, even from his competitors. Seems like an ideal person to bring the party together for the fall campaign, no?

Martin Edwin Andersen
Churchton, Maryland

user-pic

Obama was a day late and a dollar short. The time for him to have defended Joe Biden was when he first made the remark. But he didn’t. The media and Sharpton and Jackson made a federal case out of an offhanded remark that Obama was mainstream, good looking, clean and articulate. I assumed that Biden meant cleancut or clean meaning honest as opposed to dirty meaning dishonest. The media twisted it around and made a federal case out of it. It hurt Joe dearly, killed his campaign before it got started, he had to regroup and start over. No I don’t think it was touching, it was self serving.

user-pic

Moderator does not seem more absurd than 'which do you like, diamonds or pearls?' She's just a little schoolmarmish. Prefer her to Russert's lies and distortions by far.

user-pic

Like It Is,

At the time, although Obama stated he believed it was an historically inaccurate statement to say he was the first articulate African American candidate, he accepted Biden's apology and said he didn't take it personally. Incidentally, Jesse Jackson also spoke to Biden and then said he believed it was a gaffe and not a statement of Biden's ideology.

user-pic

Biden is a great man, it's a shame he isn't still in the race. The moderator was obviously an uninformed moron...alot of those in the media these days, just look at NH.

Leave a comment

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address