« The One Word That Rudy And Romney Fear Most | Home | New Iraq Proposal Would Allow Dems To Keep Standing Up To Bush »

Is Karl Rove An Atheist?

Could the "architect" of the political success of George Bush and the GOP — which relied heavily on cultivating the support and loyalty of Evangelicals, Christian conservatives, and megachurches from coast to coast — actually be an atheist?

So says none other than Christopher Hitchens, a sometimes-admirer of the White House's Iraq policies and the author of God Is Not Great: How Religion Poisons Everything. And he claims to have it straight from Rove himself. Asked in an interview with New York magazine if anyone in the Bush administration had ever confided in him about "being an atheist," Hitchens replied:

Well, I don’t talk that much to them — maybe people think I do. I know something which is known to few but is not a secret. Karl Rove is not a believer, and he doesn’t shout it from the rooftops, but when asked, he answers quite honestly. I think the way he puts it is, "I’m not fortunate enough to be a person of faith."

85 Comments

| Leave a comment
user-pic

Well, I can't speak for others, but this athiest sure as hell doesn't want to claim him as one of our own. God, next thing you'll be telling me his gay, too, then I'll really have to slit my wrists. Tastefully, of course.

user-pic

heh. I'm sure a lot of atheists agree with you on this one.

user-pic

How else could he use Christians against themselves?

user-pic

But of course. How does a pious, God fearing Christian rise to the pinnacle of Machiavellian political strategies and acquire the pet nickname 'Turd Blossom' along the road to success. If ever there was a Faustian figure in American Politics, it's Karl(there is no hell other than losing)Rove.

And now the Devil has come around, like Old Scratch always does, to collect his due. And no Daniel Webster is stepping forth to plead his case, either.

"If you talk about it, even the simplest thing becomes complex and incomprehensible." -Herman Hesse

user-pic

When winning is the only moral principle - not 'how you play the game' - it's consistent not with atheism per se, but with immorality.

Rove's actions have been inconsistent with morality by any sacred scripture, so it's no surprise that he's not a member of any established faith. But his actions in themselves are a choice to be immoral, something I've not seen in any atheist I've ever known.

He worships dishonesty and puts his faith in that. And as a Liarist, the man is obviously a perfect saint.

Kevin Hayden

user-pic

Atheist or agnostic? It's not clear from the (supposed) quote.

user-pic

Guess I will have to find a new club to join.


Think Regionally. Act Regionally

user-pic

Oh here's an irony. The black, foul heart of Republicanism giving atheism a bad name by being one.

user-pic

As if the atheists didn't have enough problems. But all is not lost. As long he's able to keep them in power, the Religious Right will hop into bed with him every night. I have no idea what they'll do there. I don't speculate on what goes on in the bedrooms of others.

user-pic

I do not believe.

user-pic

It's funny that you should mention about Karl Rove being gay in addition to being an atheist. He may not be gay, but he certainly does hire a LOT of gay men to serve as his minions. Ken Mehlman is only the most obvious example. There are many others who work or have worked for him. Some might use the term self-loathing homosexuals, but I would not be so presumptuous. :)

user-pic

Agnostic: "I’m not fortunate enough to be a person of faith."
Atheist: "I’m fortunate enough to not be a person of faith."

It's pretty much that simple.

And Kevin leads toward an observation of mine as well: Anyone I've met who has thought about the issue enough to label themselves as an atheist invests a great deal of thought into morality. The amoral folks are the ones that don't think about it and govern their actions based on what they are told. People of faith can go either way on that - they can be 'true believers' and turn off the critical thinking part of their brain and are often shocked to find that they've done things wrong because scripture didn't cover tax evasion, or some damn thing. Or they can be thoughtful people of faith that realize that eating shellfish isn't deserving of being stoned (nor is being gay).

user-pic

When they come for him, there will be no one left to speak up

user-pic
"There are different kinds of truths for different kinds of people. There are truths appropriate for children; truths that are appropriate for students; truths that are appropriate for educated adults; and truths that are appropriate for highly educated adults, and the notion that there should be one set of truths available to everyone is a modern democratic fallacy. It doesn't work."
--Irving Kristol, summarizing the views of Leo Strauss
user-pic

Well, I suppose if you 'are' god, then you don't need to be a "person of faith?"

Perhaps rove is the 'god' bush follows? Cuz he sure doesn't seem to follow the God of any definition known to the world's religions. Unless you count a 'false god.'

Since rove is so good at corruptng "christians," how could he possibly have faith anyway?

user-pic

I am fortunate NOT to be a person of faith.

I am fortunate to be a person of REASON.

user-pic

It's hard to believe in a loving God when Karl Rove is still doing his dirty work and getting away with it.

user-pic

One of the dirty little secrets of the Machievellian conservatives is that most of them are atheists. It's what allows them to so cynically exploit the fundies for their own ends. If you think about it, a godless, moralless universe goes hand-in-hand with their free market theology that sees selfishness as the driving force of progress (and evolution).

I say this as an atheist. Cold, harsh logic easily leads to cynicism and nihilism. Morality is a difficult concept to reconcile with a scientific worldview until very recently. Turns out, our morality gives us an evolutionary edge. In fact, it is our concept of good and selflessness that gave us our great advantage over the other animals, not the other way around.

Dogs do not eat other dogs. They travel in packs.

user-pic

*coughJeffGannoncough*

user-pic

No it was Ari who was gay!

user-pic

I would like to reiterate something I have tried to spell out in my other ramblings:

Rove and all of his tricks boil down to basically a phone prank.
He thinks you are stupid and gullible and prey to his mind-manipulation (and many lefties think so too)...
But really, it is just human nature. You have no idea if your garage is really on fire when Karl Kalls. If you do carry Prince Albert in a can, and Karl Kalls, are you an idiot for having it on the self, or having a garage you cannot see from the phone jack?

No. He knows how to do tricks where you are defenseless for a moment. That's why he loves last minute ratfu**ing...there is no time to check out the story, call in some sources.


Like the boy who cried wolf, when Karl Kries your garage is on fire for the third time or lights a bag of dogpoo on your stoop...most of us will not be fooled again. If it were not for a complicit press and some rather bloodthirsty cover-ups and trial tampering NOBODY would have been fooled again by 2004.

True, with all the UnHoly forces of the Federal Govt, Federalist Society, Republican Lawyers, RNC, and Republican operatives everywhere....his arsenal has grown bigger and his pranks effect millions instead of thousands....and have now even perverted our justice, legal, and political landscape: his tricks are still just the same 3rd grade crap. It is not genius. It is not intelligence. It is not understanding human nature or any other ability. What it is - someone with an eye for weakness. Unseen chinks. Backdoor trickery(never strength or physical courage or man-to-man confrontation). If we cannot defeat the King of Prank Kalls then we are no true nation and we have lost ALL of our moral anchors.


Think Regionally. Act Regionally

user-pic

Great choice of words, Karl!
"Not fortunate enough to be a person of faith"
sounds humble to the faithful, and it saves Rove from having to attend church, and also, in this matter, make him NOT A HYPOCRITE!

user-pic

This is the same Karl Rove that drives a Jaguar XJ car, claiming that it is American (because British-based Jaguar is owned by Ford).

Not because it is right, but because it is NOT ILLEGAL.

user-pic

Not sure why this is news. I came across this factoid a couple years ago, although I can't google up the source right now. At some point in the past, I read that he was from Utah, an atheist and a teetotaler. Whoopee.

It's possible to be an atheist and honest, just harder. Based on current evidence, he didn't make the grade.

Thanks.

mp

If you have to ask what jazz is, you'll never know.
-- Louis Armstrong

user-pic

Does anyone really believe anything that either Christopher Hitchens or Karl Rove says?

Hitchens says Rove answered "honestly." Really?

Karl Rove?

Even so, knowing Hitchens is an "Honorary Associate" of the National Secular Society, might this not be a case of Rove telling Hitchens what he wants to hear?

A little chummy, chummy bonding, right before, you know, Rove outs a CIA agent or something...

(I've just spent way more brain power than either of these two deserve...) 

 

Our obligation is to define the liberty of all, not to mandate our own moral code. -- SCOTUS that was...

user-pic

Matthew 15-20:

15 Beware of false prophets, which come to you in sheep's clothing, but inwardly they are ravening wolves.
16 Ye shall know them by their fruits. Do men gather grapes of thorns, or figs of thistles?
17 Even so every good tree bringeth forth good fruit; but a corrupt tree bringeth forth evil fruit.
18 A good tree cannot bring forth evil fruit, neither can a corrupt tree bring forth good fruit.
19 Every tree that bringeth not forth good fruit is hewn down, and cast into the fire.
20 Wherefore by their fruits ye shall know them.

"If you talk about it, even the simplest thing becomes complex and incomprehensible." -Herman Hesse

user-pic

I don't think conservative Christians use the bible as a guidepost but as a battering ram to harm people they don't like. To those who are inclined to be manipulative and destructive, the bible offers a wealth of opportunities.

Bush doesn't believe Christ rose from the dead anymore than I do - nor does Robertson, Falwell, or any of those clowns. Right on down to conservative preacher with the corner lot - what they believe is that Christianity is a tool to exalt oneself and to bully others.

I think we should stop referring to anyone who is conservative as a person of faith. They have none so far as I can detect.

user-pic

All right now, people, cut it out. You keep rattling off all these Evil Gay Republicans and I'm going to go to Ted Haggard's counselor and turn myself Completely Heterosexual, I swear to God.

user-pic

Oops, forgot I was an athiest, there. I swear to... to... well, dammit, you get the idea.

user-pic

Are all of the members of the Ayn Rand/Objectivist school of thought atheists?

Karl isn't just an atheist. He also has Antisocial Personality Disorder, making him a sociopath or a psychopath.

Antisocial personality disorder (abbreviated APD or ASPD) is a psychiatric diagnosis in the DSM-IV-TR recognizable by the disordered individual's disregard for social rules and norms, impulsive behavior, and indifference to the rights and feelings of others.

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Antisocial_personality_disorder

Many ruthless, wealthy, successful folks may fall somewhere on this spectrum.

user-pic

There is no connection between faith and morality. Acting morally is a willfull choice, as both selfless and selfish impulses are hardwired into our brains. Believers and non-believers alike have demonstrated remarkable capacities for morality and immorality throughout history... often the same people demonstrating both.

So unless you believe GWB's God-fearing makes him a good person, please do not conclude that Rove's baseness is in any way connected to his purported lack of faith.

user-pic

Oh, I don't know. We ate Manila and butter clams this weekend at a family picnic. It was much better for those who were stoned.

user-pic

His sexuality is not my business, but Gannon only got into the Whitehouse because he was blackmailing someone. My belief is that it was Fleisher.

user-pic

Oh come on, how can Satan not believe in God?

thosethingswesay.blogspot.com

user-pic

That's why he can bark at Sheryl Crow when she gently lays her hand on his forarm.

He coulda gone on the road with Dick and Perry...and been perfectly contented, no doubt.

"If you talk about it, even the simplest thing becomes complex and incomprehensible." -Herman Hesse

user-pic

The problem is that he's evil, not that he's an atheist.

user-pic

This is actually old news (not the Hitchens part, but that Rove is an atheist). It was detailed last year in the book "The Architect" by James Moore and Wayne Slater, which you'll recall made headlines for a bit last year with the fact that Rove's stepfather is gay.

user-pic

According to the book of Job,(if you value the scripture) Satan is an agent of the Divine, who was set to work on Job as a kind of a trial--of Job's faith."

"I put you in this body as a kind of a trial,
You can use it as a weapon or to make a woman smile..." --Leonard Cohen

user-pic

What happens if you aren't paying enough attention to notice what types of fruit the tree is bearing?

I think that's where most conservative Christians are with regard to the Bush/Cheney administration.

user-pic

I'm not one who normally questions the veracity of anyone's religious beliefs, but I've felt for a LONG time that Bush's "born-again" status was a political ploy cooked up by none other than Turd Blossom Rove.

It served to "forgive" Georgie of ALL past wrong doings - drug use, (possession of cocaine WAS a felony in the '70s and '80s, wasn't it?) drunk driving conviction(s), AWOL status, and myriad other "indescretions" of his "youth"

Find a way to use the BASE, steal the rest of the votes you need, and BINGO! President Bush is created!

I didn't used to be such a cynic...

PEACE

user-pic

naugiedoggie: "It's possible to be an atheist and honest, just harder."

I strongly disagree. Please explain your position further.

user-pic

Most Christians aren't Christ-ians at all:

they're Church-ians. They don't actually want to take up the cross and make enemies of the members of there own household. They want to abdicate their responsibility to symbols of authority. Male figures of authority. Being a bona fide disciple of Christ is tough. But you don't need to put on your Sunday school clothes to do it or pray openly in public, like a Pharisee.

"If you talk about it, even the simplest thing becomes complex and incomprehensible." -Herman Hesse

user-pic

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Right_Wing_Authoritarianism#Connection_with_Social_Dominance_Orientation

http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Social_dominance_orientation

The context of a Right Wing Authoritarian personality, with a Social Dominance Orientation, seems a better fit. See also Robert Altemeyer's work.

http://home.cc.umanitoba.ca/~altemey/

Although to be fair, as far as I know, Karl Rove is no racist (and neither is GWB) or anti-semite.

Just an ambitious, somewhat amoral, guy, with a very conservative value system.

user-pic

"Find a way to use the BASE, steal the rest of the votes you need, and BINGO! President Bush is created!"

Bush is an abomination cobbled together by Karl Rove robbing graves--he stole the ranch and the cowboy thing from Ronald Reagun, the name from G Bush sr, and the Bible thing from William Jennings Bryan, Pat Robertson, and Elmer Gantry. Raised up into a lightning storm by the Military Industrial Complex and 9/11, and we've got a monster on our hands. Karl Rove is Baron von Frankenstein.


"If you talk about it, even the simplest thing becomes complex and incomprehensible." -Herman Hesse

user-pic

I may not be 100% correct about this, but I've always been under the impression, based on Moore & Slater's books, The Brain, and The Architect, that Karl Rove's father is an openly gay man, living in San Francisco.

Now, in the normal scheme of things, the correct response to this should be "so what?" But considering how he's fanned the flames of hate and bigotry for quite successful political and electoral gain, this gives pause for thought.

user-pic

This is old news. Moore and Slater wrote about it their book The Architect. Wake up, people! Pay attention.

user-pic

I thnk Altenmeyer's work casts more light on the followers of the movement than Karl Rove, per se. I see NOTHING about Karl Rove that is conservative. If Karl Rove thinks you are a womanizer, he will get you a prostitute. If he thinks you're a junky, he will offer you Smack. If he thinks you're an alcoholic, he'll give you single malt scotch. If he thinks you're a bible thumper, he'll cry "Praise Jesus!" and pick your pocket.

This has nothing to do with limited government, and everything to do with leveraging someones vulnerabilities. It's about selling the sizzle, not the steak. That ain't conservative.

"If you talk about it, even the simplest thing becomes complex and incomprehensible." -Herman Hesse

user-pic

Belief is not a mental state for a political shaman who specializes in the manipulation of perception. In fact, belief in anything who be a professional limitation.

Karl Rove was telling Hitchens that he himself is not fortunate enough to enjoy the false certainties he congers for the nation.

user-pic

Amen.

user-pic

"I'm not fortunate enough to be a person of faith" is a strange way of saying "I don't believe in a God". It's leaves in quite a bit of wiggle room--I'm not fortunate, now, to be a person of faith, but I"m not shutting the door to being a person of faith in the future.

In any event, Rove gives atheists a bad name. Hell, Rove gives human beings a bad name.

user-pic

Dare we hope that a prison conversion is in his future?

user-pic

There are some rumors to that effect.

user-pic

If you don't think some Christians are willing and able to use Christians against other Christians, you haven't been paying attention. Ditto Jews, Muslims, Buddhists, Pagans, agnostics, atheists, whoever.

There's a long, long history of in-fighting within faiths, within sects of faiths, within specific houses, and so on, and there never seems to be any lack of people willing to take advantage of that for personal gain.

user-pic
Agnostic: "I’m not fortunate enough to be a person of faith." Atheist: "I’m fortunate enough to not be a person of faith."

It's pretty much that simple.

Well, no, it's not "that simple". I know it's not that simple because I happen to be fortunate enough to be an agnostic.

user-pic

Mm hmm, kinda like a certain high-level Republican with a lesbian daughter who also is more than happy to whip up the flames of anti-gay hate if it will further his political purposes.

Come to think of it, his lesbian daughter is more than happy to go along with it, too.

user-pic

Succinct, to the point, and true.

user-pic

Too bad we can't get the Evangelical Christians to realize they
have made a pact with the devil. It is hard to understand people who oppose stem cell research on the grounds that it destroys life, but who have no problem with the death penalty or the brutal war in Iraq, and who oppose gun control. Oh well!

user-pic

If he is I don't want to belong. He needs excommunicated immediately. He would give atheisism a bad name.

user-pic

I'm with Victor on this one.

I don't see how people who believe in God or the Easter Bunny have any more claim to being honest. In fact, I think they have much less of one as they haven't challenged whether that belief is honest in and of itself. They aren't adhering to *their* sense of morality, rather to one that's been passed down by others. That's dishonest on its face.

If I lie, I have no means to have that sin absolved through some ceremony. Praying won't make it go away. Instead it impacts my relationship with the people around me and that has to be corrected through hard work. I have no crutch to fall back on to ask forgiveness. I have to earn it. I've seen plenty of people of faith lie like I've never thought possible before and be forgiven with a wave of a hand and a show of a cross. And they return immediately to their old ways expecting the same treatment again. It's astonishing.

Being a dishonest atheist is a very painful thing and serves as an enormous incentive to be honest.

I too would like to know how faith makes one more honest.

user-pic

It's really a matter of conscience. Reason or faith or a combination of the two can arrive at "good" through conscience.

Not to gloss over the mistakes of the Catholic church over the centuries, but they also have a tradition of intellectual and philosophical rigor in faith. The same goes for the early intellectually serious Protestant reformation.

But much of today's American Evangelical Fundamentalism is just mindless, cult like dogma, with no intellectual seriousness. A religious regression to almost voodoo. Look for example at some churches which still practice speaking in tongues and personality cult worship of political leaders and charismatic pastors of mega-churches.

It's sad really. People drawn to faith for spirituality, philosophical learning, and a sense of community, they are being horribly exploited.

user-pic

Why do we who do not believe in god require a label? I don't recall needing a label for people who don't believe in Santa Claus.

When I want to put a label on Karl Rove the word criminal comes to mind.

user-pic

Not only is he an atheist, he's a nihilist. Only thing that makes sense. Cheney, too.

user-pic

I've never doubted he's an atheist. More specifically he's a Social Darwinian Nihilist. i.e. He believes in nothing, except power.

I always suspected he was so adept at manipulation and exploitation of the faithful, so wholly and remorselessly, precisely because he utterly lacks compassion or faith.

But that's really a matter of conscience more than religion. Both theists and atheists have to choose between more altruistic and enlightened beliefs, or predatory instincts which glorify power and selfishness.

One has to believe in something.

On one hand there is conscience/altruism, whether it's the good of the species and the beauty of evolution which evolved empathy, and where our deeds and accomplishments are eternal through the continued prosperity of all life; or a whether one believes in a compassionate redeeming god who rewards good for eternity in heaven. Either path towards conscience/altruism, faith or reason, produces much the same outlook on life. A person who does good for others believing in some form of "karma" is a primary example of the conscience/altruism paradigm.

On the other hand is nihilism/greed, basically the simplistic and devolved logic of predators and reptiles, like snakes for example. The belief that only the here and now matters, there is no reason for compassion or altruism, and that one should grab all one can in the most ruthless predatory manner. Nihilists may be atheistic Social Darwinians (a terrible misnomer that nature abhors) or Religious Crusaders exploiting faith to glorify themselves and seize treasure. Cannibals and sociopaths are primary examples of the nihilist/predator paradigm.

Biology may have something to do with it. Certainly upbringing has a lot to do with it.
When people are thrust into power or seek power, their beliefs tend to be crystallized further through actions.

In Rove's case, he's the end product of a ruthless ideology he was predisposed to, which was reinforced during his position in the college Republicans, then he was recognized for his talent and ruthlessness and taken under the wing of HW Bush, and from there he knew he'd rise to power so long as he was willing to be more ruthless than the next guy. His whole career going back to the college Republicans has been marked by ruthlessness and Machiavellian tendencies.

user-pic

mafioso - rovioso - atheoso - whatever... he's the mother of godfathers in this criminal cabal.

It's a cult, complete with vestal virgins - like monica, etc.

By Jove, it's "rove!"

user-pic

The next answer in the interview is also interesting:

I think it’s false to say that the president acts as if he believes he has God’s instructions. Compared to Jimmy Carter, he’s nowhere. He’s a Methodist, having joined his wife’s church in the end. He also claims that Jesus got him off the demon drink. He doesn’t believe it. His wife said, “If you don’t stop, I’m leaving and I’m taking the kids.” You can say that you got help from Jesus if you want, but that’s just a polite way of putting it in Texas.

DC Drinking Liberally

user-pic

I've really been thinking about Martin Luther today between last night's evolution denials and now this.

"Reason must be deluded, blinded, and destroyed. Faith must trample underfoot all reason, sense, and understanding, and whatever it sees must be put out of sight and ... know nothing but the word of God."

I think that if you truly look around, you'd be hard pressed to find any real "religious" people in power. By "religious" I mean that their words and actions support their belief system - in this case Christian. And in the Christian sense it's pretty obvious that he's not a "believer". But even in his coy reply there's more honesty than in most of the "true believers" out there. As vile as most see his sometimes Machiavellian approach, you do have to acknowledge that fact. As a matter of fact, if Machiavelli were a "religion" than it could be argued that Rove is more pious than any other politician in Washington.

user-pic

He worships power, and will do anything for it and do anything to destroy those who stand in his way. There are people like that operating in all levels of society. Some of them do disguise themselves with the language of religious discourse and some with the language of secular morality because these are the standard discourses that everyone around them uses and understands, but I don't think they really have any loyalty except to themselves. Some on this thread identifies them as sociopaths or psychopaths, and I think that's correct.

In any case, the religious conservatives have been taken for a ride.

user-pic

Not sure I see the "poor impulse control behavior" in Rove. Might have missed any documented history of that. He seems to be able to plan pretty far in advance.
Maybe sociopath fits better.
There ought to be a whole new catagory in the DSM for the power hungery obsessed figures all too common in the political landscape.
Soul less, I do agree.
there's enough pathology in this group of Neo Con plotters to keep a whole herd of shrinks busy for yeras..as they no doubt will be.
And after all this is over and done, we will to face the shelves of books written about them.

user-pic

Yeah, that part doesn't fit him (or many others, think about ruthless criminal masterminds), but I don't think you have to have all of the criteria in order to be diagnosed.

user-pic

Just take a look at which churches supported the Iraq War and which opposed it based on the Christian doctrine of Just War.

user-pic

There are numerous sources contradicting this claim.

"I think it’s false to say that the president acts as if he believes he has God’s instructions."

user-pic

Could a member of our esteemed (/sarcasm) White House press corp please ask Bush to comment on this revelation?

user-pic

One need only observe Rove’s behavior to determine where he stands on matters of faith. He, like far too many who actually claim a belief in the Deity, is obviously not a keeper of either the first or of second covenants. I suspect the Turd Blossom has more in common with Marlowe's Doctor Faustus.

Whilst men are linked together, they easily and speedily communicate the alarm of any evil design. They are enabled to fathom it with common counsel, and to oppose it with united strength. Whereas, when they lie dispersed, without concert, order, or discipline, communication is uncertain, counsel difficult, and resistance impracticable. Where men are not acquainted with each other’s principles, nor experienced in each other’s talents, nor at all practiced in their mutual habitudes and dispositions by joint efforts in business; no personal confidence, no friendship, no common interest, subsisting among them; it is evidently impossible that they can act a public part with uniformity, perseverance, or efficacy. In a connection, the most inconsiderable man, by adding to the weight of the whole, has his value, and his use; out of it, the greatest talents are wholly unserviceable to the public. No man, who is not inflamed by vain-glory into enthusiasm, can flatter himself that his single, unsupported, desultory, unsystematic endeavors, are of power to defeat the subtle designs and united cabals of ambitious citizens. When bad men combine, the good must associate; else they will fall, one by one, an unpitied sacrifice in a contemptible struggle.

Edmund Burke

Whenever two people meet, there are really six people present. There is each man as he sees himself, each man as the other person sees him, and each man as he really is.

William James

user-pic

The Socially Dominant Orientation fits nicely.

SDOs think rules are a problem, *for other people*.

Rove's view of human frailty is to tolerate it in your allies, and use it against your enemies.

He is actually, apparently, something of a firm family man. I suspect his only vice is that he reads too many books ;-).

The movement is full Right Wing Authoritarians (there is such a thing as a left wing Authoritarian, but it's much rarer-- but was common in places like Stalin's Russia), but the leaders have something else, an X factor.

I would say that X factor (ditto for Newt) is the desire to dominate.

user-pic

See my post above about Right Wing Authoritarians and Social Dominance Orientation.

Rove is, I think, an example of the latter, working in the context of the former.

user-pic

Not at all. They have the Supreme Court.

That is what was promised, and what they wanted.

user-pic

People aren't so stupid.

They wanted to be part of such a church, they *are* part of such a church.

I don't think we can call people stupid or misled. Maybe about Iraq, but that was more general. Americans who supported Bush and Rove wanted to believe what they believed.

It's a bit like liberals refusing to believe that JFK sponsored secret wars.

user-pic

No GWB is a genuine convert-- hence his reliance on faith. He has all the traits of someone who has turned to religion as a way of dealing with his own eff ups in life: a lot of ex-alcoholics have that attitude.

The fact that he uses his faith as a justification of everything he does, is self serving, but I don't think it's operating at a conscious level.

Ronnie Reagan was much more hypocritical in his use of religion (but as always with Reagan, even his closest advisors never quite knew what was an act, and what was the man-- in a sense, there wasn't a difference).

user-pic

The silence coming from the Religionists on this is deafening. SSDD - IOKIYAR.

user-pic

Especially for kozmik (loved your post) and mcboo...

This is my first post ever anywhere so here goes:

Just needed to say a word about Machiavelli, often "credited" with being the father of modern politics, and someone whose name has become an adjective associated with the worst kind of political ruthlessness.

According to former Harvard professor, D.J. Wilcox, in his course on "The Intellectual History of the Italian Renaissance," (no - wait - this is IMPORTANT) Machiavelli has gotten one of the worst and most undeserved raps in history.

He was essentially a republican, and I mean that in the nicest possible way: he believed, passionately, in the strength and integrity of the various Italian republics. He spent many years in public service, but was imprisoned and exiled when the Medicis came to power. He wrote "The Prince" while in exile (and/or prison - I forget) as a political satire, mocking the Medici to whom it was "dedicated."

His short treatise on the value of being the ruthless Prince, better to be feared than loved, etc., was a bitter commentary on the man and family whose political practices were abhorrent to him.

His republican friends begged him not to publish the small volume, convinced he would only get into further trouble with the despots in charge.

There was no surviving bejeweled dedication copy, nor any record of one, which there would have been, had the dedication been real and sincere and the book presented to the Prince to honor, rather than to mock, him.

Machiavelli spent years of his life writing a huge treatise on the republic, versus the short time he spent writing "The Prince," yet no one remembers what he spent the bulk of his life doing. He is only remembered - and misunderstood - for this slim, satirical treatise.

His famously quoted "The ends justify the means" is apparently a mistranslation and has further damaged his reputation. What he really said was, "The means BECOME the ends," in other words, if you use corruption to accomplish something, you end up tainting your goals with that same tarred brush. He was warning that if you want to accomplish something good, you must use worthy means, NOT the other way around.

Funny - my first posting and I'm defending a guy who's been dead for hundreds of years. But maybe it's all of a piece: the whisper mill, destroying people's reputations by untruths or half-truths, hasn't changed much.

user-pic

PS To be more concise:

Machiavelli was the Stephen Colbert of his day, except, happily, Stephen's not in jail or exile...

user-pic

Latvia,Riga escort service,sauna,massage,escort boys,Vip escort Massage salons and much more. hello from Riga www.exclusivescort.com
Latvia,Riga escort service,sauna,massage,escort boys,Vip escort Massage salons and much more.Travel.. hello from Riga http://www.exclusivescort.com http://www.escort-service.lv

user-pic

Riga,Latvia best escort girls, massage salons, escort boys and sauna. All information about adult's entertainment in Riga, Latvia.
http://www.ladies.lv friend www.escort-service.lv

I wouldn't be surprised of Rove was an atheist. Harry Shearer (Mr. Burns from the Simpsons) did a hilarious riff on him. If you haven't seen it yet, here's the link - it's definitely worth watching.

http://www.mydamnchannel.com/Harry_Shearer/Music_Videos/TurdBlossomSpecial_838.aspx

I wouldn't be surprised of Rove was an atheist. Harry Shearer (Mr. Burns from the Simpsons) did a hilarious riff on him. If you haven't seen it yet, here's the link - it's definitely worth watching.

Karl Rove is a Turd Blossom

Leave a comment

Advertise Liberally
Share
Close Social Web Email

"To" Email Address

Your Name

Your Email Address